The two top Republicans in Pennsylvania's Senate petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court on Monday to put a halt to the three-day extension for counties to receive and count mail-in ballots this November.
At issue is the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's ruling this month that mail-in ballots postmarked by 8 p.m. on Election Day and delivered to county offices by mail during the three days following the Nov. 3 election — as long as they're received by 5 p.m. Nov. 6 — shall be counted.
Arguing that the state Supreme Court violated federal law and the U.S. Constitution by altering the rules of the election and superseding the legislature's authority, Republicans are asking the nation's highest court to restore the original received-by ballot deadline — 8 p.m. on Election Day — pending the outcome of their forthcoming request for the court to review the ruling.
Lawyers for Senate President Pro Tempore Joe Scarnati, R-Jefferson, and Majority Leader Jake Corman, R-Centre, argue that the Pennsylvania court “rewrote” the state’s law governing federal elections and violated the constitution, “sowing chaos into the electoral process mere weeks before the already intricate November General Election.”

“This is an open invitation to voters to cast their ballots after Election Day, thereby injecting chaos and the potential for gamesmanship into what was an orderly and secure schedule of clear, bright-line deadlines,” the Republicans claimed, alleging that the state ruling mandates that county elections offices count ballots "even if they lack a legible postmark or any postmark at all."
The Senate leaders claim that if the Supreme Court doesn't act, it will open the door for lower federal and state courts across the country to change deadlines before the election.
Read More
"Absent a stay, the machinery of the election will continue inexorably towards Election Day," they wrote in the petition. "With each passing day, more and more voters will learn that the deadline is not Election Day — as established by statute — but three days after Election Day."
In its Sept. 17 ruling, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania determined that voters can't exercise their right to vote if the deadline passes and their applications are stuck in a postal facility because of United States Postal Service delays.
“The Legislature enacted an extremely condensed timeline, providing only seven days between the last date to request a mail-in ballot and the last day to return a completed ballot,” Justice Max Baer wrote in the majority opinion. “While it may be feasible under normal conditions, it will unquestionably fail under the strain of COVID-19 and the 2020 Presidential Election, resulting in the disenfranchisement of voters.”
On the issue of judicial authority, Justice Baer argued that it isn't uncommon for courts of common pleas to intervene in election administration during emergency situations on the day of the election, and that the court has “no hesitation in concluding that the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic equates to a natural disaster.”
The filing with the nation’s highest court comes as Pennsylvania counties, including Philadelphia and Allegheny, have begun sending out ballots to registered voters who asked to vote by mail.
It also comes less than two days after President Donald Trump, at a rally at Harrisburg International Airport, said the only way he can lose Pennsylvania is if Democrats cheat as part of his long-running effort to discredit voting by mail.
“They’re going to try to steal the election. ... The only they way to win Pennsylvania frankly is to cheat on the ballots,” Mr. Trump said Saturday at a rally attended by thousands.
In accusing Democrats of cheating, Mr. Trump also again seized on a matter that emerged last week in northeastern Pennsylvania where, according to a county official there, a temporary election worker mistakenly threw away nine mailed-in military ballots in the election office.
Seven were completed ballots cast for Mr. Trump, according to federal investigators. There were no accusations of election fraud from authorities investigating it, although Mr. Trump’s campaign quickly touted it as Democrats trying to steal the election.
It still wasn’t clear, however, how or why they ended up in the trash, and Gov. Tom Wolf, a Democrat, said Monday that his administration is still trying to find that out.
He also pointed that voting by mail has been going on in Pennsylvania for a long time — although a year-old law greatly expanded it — and he suggested that Mr. Trump is calling it fraudulent because he is losing.
“I certainly understand the idea of the side that appears to be losing would call foul on the process,” Mr. Wolf said. “But the commonwealth is doing everything we can do make sure the elections are fair and every ballot is counted, just as we did back in the primary with this new system.”
The Republicans’ request was filed with Justice Samuel Alito, who oversees the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit in Philadelphia. It is likely to be referred by him to the entire court.
The justices usually are reluctant to intervene in legal battles over voting close to an election. The court often defers to state courts over such matters.
It is the first election-related case to be filed since the death of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. She wrote a dissent in April, when the court voted 5 to 4 to stop some of the accommodations federal judges had allowed for Wisconsin primary voters because of the pandemic.
“The concerns advanced by the court and the applicants pale in comparison to the risk that tens of thousands of voters will be disenfranchised,” she wrote for her liberal colleagues. “Ensuring an opportunity for the people of Wisconsin to exercise their votes should be our paramount concern.”
Even in that case, though, the conservative majority allowed Wisconsin officials to count ballots received after the day of the primary if it was clear that they had been mailed by then.
Associated Press and Washington Post contributed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.