Chuck Howenstein, a lifelong Democrat, assured his wife he was supporting Hillary Clinton. Then he walked into his Pittsburgh voting booth and pushed the button for Donald Trump.

When Mr. Trump won, with help from a stunning swing in Pennsylvania, Mr. Howenstein, who had supported Barack Obama, couldn’t even tell his wife, Jackie, that he had been part of the shift. She didn’t find out until Chuck was quoted in news reports more than two years later. She was assuaged by one thing: Now, Chuck says, he wants Mr. Trump gone.

He sees a president fanning hatred and division, and worries about what scars he has inflicted.

“The future looks bleak to me, very bleak, with what’s going on and if this doesn’t change,” Mr. Howenstein, 63, said recently. Earlier, he said, “You could have a good economy, but if it destroys our country, I don’t want my children to be part of that.”

Advertise with us

David Ruminski went through a similar transition — but has come to the opposite conclusion. He hails Mr. Trump’s work on the economy, dismisses the president’s incendiary rhetoric as part strategy, part show, and is sold on a second term.

A longtime union member from Erie County, Mr. Ruminski voted twice for Mr. Obama, but by 2016 felt the Democrat had forgotten people like him.

“He seemed to think America had reached its peak and we had to get ready for a new normal, that my kids’ kids would not be able to succeed like their forefathers,” hei said. “I just really didn’t accept that economic message.”

Mr. Howenstein and Mr. Ruminski, both white 63-year-olds from Western Pennsylvania, represent just one small slice of a diverse electorate. But in a critical state decided by fewer than 44,000 votes in 2016, so-called “Obama-Trump” voters like them played a key role in deciding the election, helping deliver Pennsylvania to a Republican for the first time since 1988.

They could again have an outsize influence in 2020 as Democrats seek to win back some of the voters and states that put Mr. Trump over the top.

Advertise with us

Studies estimate that around 6 million to just over 9 million voters switched from Mr. Obama in 2012 to Mr. Trump in 2016, a sizable figure considering the razor-thin margins in Pennsylvania, Michigan (decided by 11,000 votes) and Wisconsin (23,000 votes).

These voters tend to be older and whiter, groups disproportionately represented in the Rust Belt. They “are likely to be well distributed geographically for the purpose of electoral impact,” said a May analysis from the Democracy Fund Voter Study Group, a collaboration of scholars and analysts from across the political spectrum.

And unlike most voters, whose views on Trump are locked in, some of these people are up for grabs.

Some 66% of Obama-Trump voters still supported the president, according to a January survey of nearly 7,000 people, the Study Group found. That’s a drop from 85% in 2016. They were the only cohort to show a substantial change in views of Mr. Trump.

Mr. Howenstein embodies that slide. Even a small segment of voters like him could help bring key states back to a Democrat. Yet at the same time, some of the early positions staked out by Democratic contenders have worried him, illustrating the challenge for a party trying to energize its liberal base and win over more moderate voters.

Advertise with us

‘He was so different’

As Mr. Trump incinerated every rule of politics in 2016, Mr. Howenstein couldn’t wait to see what he would do next.

“He was so different, he was exciting,” he said. “Every time he’s on, he’s going to do something or say something, you know it’s going to be entertaining.”

He thought an outsider like Mr. Trump would excise the rot in Washington, while Ms. Clinton represented the insider class. “We were so tired of the corruption, that’s why I was against Hillary,” he said. He had often switched allegiances, voting for Ronald Reagan and both Bushes, but also Bill Clinton and Mr. Obama.

Mr. Howenstein would sometimes defend Mr. Trump’s antics, even though Jackie, a loyal Democrat who supported Hillary Clinton, felt Mr. Trump got away with things no woman ever could. She couldn’t stand when the Republican came on TV. “I would literally have to get out of the room,” she said.

Advertise with us

But Mr. Howenstein’s views changed as Mr. Trump continued the non-stop attacks in office. The president’s faltering response to the 2017 neo-Nazi march in Charlottesville, Va., was his breaking point. That disgust has only been reinforced by Mr. Trump’s declaration that four Congresswomen of color should “go back” to their home countries (despite being U.S. citizens) and the Trump echoes running through the El Paso, Texas, shooter’s anti-immigrant manifesto.

“There’s never been a time in this country like this,” he said. “He stirs the pot and inflames this hatred with this white supremacy and all this stuff.”

Mr. Howenstein, who sells fire safety equipment and is semi-retired, won’t vote for Mr. Trump again, and said his two daughters have had the same change of heart.

‘No way I could vote for her’

Mr. Ruminski’s decision was easy once Ms. Clinton secured the Democratic nomination.

Advertise with us

“There was no way I could vote for her, so Trump was it, and it just seemed that anything the media did was to get Trump and that’s their whole agenda,” he said.

His impression of Ms. Clinton ran deep, he pointed back to 2002, when Clinton administration staffers removed “Ws” from White House keyboards just before George W. Bush took office. “It’s pretty petty, man. Who does that?”

A lifelong Democrat who moved to Erie County for college and then worked in a state welfare office there, Mr. Ruminski has grown more supportive of Mr. Trump the more criticism he hears of the president. He blames the media and Democrats for wild accusations.

“Since I voted for Trump, I went from being a Russian bot to a white supremacist. I’m not a white supremacist, and I’ve never been to Russia,” he said. He later added, “They’re just pushing me further to that right side.”

Mr. Ruminski, of Harborcreek, just outside of Erie, was part of a wave of one-time Democrats who broke for Mr. Trump in rural and small-city Pennsylvania. Mr. Obama won Erie County by 19,000 votes in 2012. Ms. Clinton lost it by nearly 2,000.

Advertise with us

Beat Donald Trump

In the back of a packed union hall, Mr. Howenstein looked over the reporters hammering at their laptops, and joked about how serious everyone looked.

Not far from his Pittsburgh home, he had come to Joe Biden’s first campaign rally. Biden spoke that April day about a “battle for America’s soul.” Importantly to Mr. Howenstein, there was no name-calling or personal attacks.

He was sold, and spoke to a few reporters about it.

Mr. Howenstein thinks Biden can win. But he worries about how other Democrats have attacked him, and, by extension, Mr. Obama, while pushing for more liberal policies.

Advertise with us

“The bottom line is the biggest prize: we beat Donald Trump. How do we do that? We don’t beat each other up all the way through,” he said

Considering some of the ideas that have captured attention in the primary, Mr. Howenstein said, “I don’t believe in anything free.”

He also worried about calls to loosen enforcement at the border. To him, there are too few resources already for homelessness and other problems. “You should take care of your own first, your own home, before you help your neighbor,” he said.

‘He’s on reality TV’

When Mr. Ruminski retired last year and started driving Uber, he says he noticed the effects of a growing economy.

Advertise with us

“I was truly floored at the number of people that had just started working that had aspirational hopes to improve their lives,” he said, crediting Mr. Trump.

He doesn’t follow the president on Twitter, doesn’t watch cable news, and doesn’t take the president’s rhetoric too seriously.

“Come on, he’s on reality TV, we know what the guy is about. It’s not a surprise, right?” Mr. Ruminski said. “He’s a blowhard isn’t he?” He chalks it up to Mr. Trump being a hot-blooded New Yorker, and laying traps for opponents.

As for recent warnings about the economy, Mr. Ruminski sees another media hit. “That’s just the next thing to get Trump isn’t it?

He’s also unimpressed by the Democratic contenders, especially those arguing for providing health coverage to undocumented immigrants. Mr. Ruminski doesn’t have health insurance and pays for doctor’s visits out of pocket.

“They want to give illegal aliens free health care and I’m standing here and I have to pay for it,” he said.