State politicians and a local official who toured a family immigration detention center in Berks County Monday morning left divided about whether or not the practice of detaining families seeking asylum in the United States should continue.

Sen. Judy Schwank of Ruscombmanor Township, Reps. Chris Rabb of Philadelphia and Peter G. Schweyer of Allentown, and Berks Recorder of Deeds Fred Sheeler visited the Berks County Residential Center on a “fact-finding mission,” Ms. Schwank said.

Monday’s tour came amid calls from activists and politicians alike for Gov. Tom Wolf to close the detention center, which is located in Leesport, an hour outside of Philadelphia. One of three family immigration detention centers in the U.S., Berks is the only facility where parents and children are detained together for more than a few weeks at a time. The facility is operated by Berks County through a contract with Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

Activists cite a history of health and human rights violations at the facility. A guard was convicted of raping a detainee in 2016, and attorneys representing the asylum seekers say detainees have been denied adequate medical care, among other allegations.

Advertise with us

The facility’s license was revoked in 2016, but the county appealed, and the center is still operating as the legal battle continues.

Mr. Rabb and 24 other state legislators last week sent a letter to the governor, urging him to issue an Emergency Removal Order that would remove the 24 families housed in the center and end family detention in Pennsylvania. Neither Ms. Schwank nor Mr. Schweyer signed the letter. Ms. Schwank said she had more to learn about the practice.

On Saturday, Mr. Wolf’s office released a statement saying that the facility is regularly inspected by the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services and has not shown violations that merit an emergency removal order.

The officials who visited Monday said they requested the tour to be sure that the center is not housing unaccompanied children who had been separated from their parents, and to see for themselves the conditions facing families in detention.

Ms. Schwank was a Berks County Commissioner when the facility first opened, in 2001. She said that the officials on Monday were shown medical facilities, bedrooms, a dining area, and a common room.

Advertise with us

“It reminded me of the rooms of the daycare my granddaughter goes to,” she said. “It didn’t look like a horrific place where mistreatment is occurring.”

But she said she only spoke to one detainee, a Honduran man who is being detained with his 3-year-old son, and would need to hear from others to get a full picture.

Pat Uribe-Lichty, a volunteer with the Shut Down Berks Campaign who acted as an interpreter for Mr. Rabb, said the detainee she spoke with broke down in tears as he described his experience in Berks. The man has been detained for over two months with his 15-year-old son, she said, and was still wearing the clothes he arrived in.

Ms. Schwank told reporters that she opposes family separation and the long-term detention of families, but would not support an emergency removal order at this point in time. She said she plans to meet with attorneys from the Department of Homeland Security to learn more about federal oversight of facilities that house children seeking asylum.

Fred Sheeler, Recorder of Deeds for Berks County, was more critical, questioning whether the facility is necessary at all. Alternatives to detention, like releasing asylum seekers with an ankle monitor, are cheaper and more humane, he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Sheeler encouraged Americans to think back to their own immigrant roots and the comparatively lax border laws that allowed families like his own to enter the country around the turn of the 20th century. He also advocated compassion for those seeking asylum.

“They’re fleeing, they don’t just want to come here for something different,” he said. “They’re trying to get something better so their kids can live.”

Annie Rosenthal: arosenthal@post-gazette.com or on Twitter: AnnieRosenthal8.