Before Tuesday, Rick Saccone was poised for one of those rare political reincarnations.

In a race where name recognition would surely matter, he was the candidate — not Guy Reschenthaler — two months removed from standing beside Donald Trump on national television. He was the one, according to analysts, who had an organized campaign apparatus and a centralized message of experience and conservative bravado.

But as the last Republican primary vote in Pennsylvania's 14th Congressional District was counted Tuesday night, it was Mr. Rechenthaler, the 35-year-old state senator, on his way to a general election matchup with a seat in the U.S. House on the line — with Mr. Saccone on the receiving end of a second humiliating loss in as many months.

"I think people said to Dr. Saccone, 'you had your chance,'" Republican state Sen. Kim Ward said. "'We need to try something new.'"

Advertise with us

In the aftermath of the primary, several Republican officials in Harrisburg and elsewhere across Pennsylvania expressed enthusiasm over what they deemed a renewed energy in the 14th — partly because of Mr. Reschenthaler's youth and vision, but also because they wouldn't have to worry about Mr. Saccone losing to a Democrat again in a bright red district, as he had in the 18th in March.

With Mr. Reschenthaler at the helm against Democratic nominee Bibiana Boerio, a former Ford executive, GOP officials said they are confident they won't have to sink too many resources in holding onto their geographic advantage.

"Guy is roundly seen as someone who has crossover appeal, a great resume, and he’s energetic and youthful," said Val DiGiorgio, who chairs the state Republican Party. "He’ll make a great candidate."

To analysts, it was Mr. Reschenthaler's image of change and moderation that won him voters in the 14th, which covers territory in Fayette, Greene and Washington counties and part of Westmoreland. More than 12,000 voters sided with him (in comparison to Mr. Saccone's 7,700) because he was "more the outsider" and "more critical of the way things get done," said Franklin & Marshall political analyst G. Terry Madonna.

But Mr. Reschenthaler also reminded voters throughout the election that Mr. Saccone lost the 18th, at one point calling it an "embarrassment to southwestern Pennsylvania."

Advertise with us

"Once you lose in politics, you’re in trouble," said Joseph DiSarro, a Republican who chairs the political science department at Washington and Jefferson College. "It could be by just 700 votes ... but he lost in a district which he should have won by 7,000 votes."

Ms. Boerio, the Democrat, faces an uphill battle in a district that is rated "likely Republican" by the nonpartisan Cook Political Report, which handicaps House races. After redistricting, about 57 percent of the seat carried over from the old 18th — which Donald Trump won by nearly 20 points in 2016 — but is even more rural and three points more Republican, according to an analysis by Cook's David Wasserman.

But Democrats hope Ms. Boerio's message of solutions-based problem solving with character and civility, along with her experience in the automotive industry and as former U.S. Rep. Joe Sestak's chief of staff, will help her expand on her already-strong roots in Westmoreland County. There, she won more than 13,000 votes, which was more than Mr. Reschenthaler carried.

They also hope to get a boost from heightened Democratic enthusiasm in the midterms, as well as what Democratic National Committee Women's Media Director Elizabeth Renda called a hunger for female leadership in the party. On Tuesday, seven women, including Ms. Boerio, won Democratic primary races in Pennsylvania.

It is unclear if Ms. Boerio will get outside help from national Democratic groups. The 14th was not listed among the 91 districts the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee was targeting in November, but that list was released before she declared her candidacy.

Advertise with us

"Everything has to be break the right way for Bibiana for her to have a shot," said David Misra, political science instructor for the Community College of Allegheny County. "She has to move the needle and show the people that she can both raise money and also get people excited in her candidacy. If she can achieve those two objectives, then I do think some Democrats will put some funding into this race."

But Ms. Boerio insisted that either way, the race is about southwestern Pennsylvania. She said it didn't matter if Mr. Reschenthaler or Mr. Saccone was her opponent, either.

"I was willing and able to go into the election against either one of them. I have to do a bit of work," Ms. Boerio said of what she knows about Mr. Reschenthaler. "Here's what I think my approach is: I spent many years, more than three decades, in the real world doing real things making real things happen."

Though Republicans say they aren't worried about the district, they're taking no chances with a redrawn map and reshuffled prospects. In April, the National Republican Campaign Committee reserved $3.8 million in television air time in the Pittsburgh media market to target or defend candidates in any races they choose.

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth