HARRISBURG — The Republicans are fighting again.

With less than a week left until the primary, the GOP is turning its attention to the 38th Senatorial District, which covers part of Pittsburgh and some of its northern suburbs.

There, state Sen. Randy Vulakovich faces a challenge from Ross Commissioner Jeremy Shaffer, who is favored by a group that seeks to snuff out so-called RINOs — Republicans in Name Only — and replace them with politicians who will be loyal to their version of conservative principles no matter the cost.

The entire race embodies a question Republican politicians are asking themselves across the country: If you're hoping to counter a wave of Democratic enthusiasm, do you pitch a candidate who can compromise, or one who promises to energize GOP partisans?

Advertise with us

If this race is any indication, the fight will be dirty and expensive.

Mr. Vulakovich, a former state representative and police officer, was elected to the Senate in 2012 when he won the special election to replace state Sen. Jane Orie. He sailed through to a full term, winning his office in 2014 without facing a challenger.

He has sponsored legislation dealing with law enforcement issues and tends to vote conservatively on social issues, such as abortion. He has also voted at times for tax increases, often amid budget impasses that ultimately left politicians in both parties feeling dissatisfied with the outcome. Those budgets votes are among the reasons Shaffer decided to run.

Mr. Vulakovich said, "My votes are votes I put up to get something done."

The senator has been loyal to the party, helping to support other GOP candidates' campaigns. The party returned the favor. The Senate Republican Campaign Committee, which works to help maintain a Republican majority in the Senate, has given $260,000 to Mr. Vulakovich's campaign since February.

Advertise with us

The Citizens Alliance of Pennsylvania, a conservative group pushing Mr. Shaffer, believes the SRCC exerts too much influence over Republican senators and acknowledges that it has taken an "outsized interest" in this race in hopes of sending a message to other incumbents.

"Senate leadership...can convince members to take bad votes only as long as members believe that the Senate and SRCC can protect them," said Leo Knepper, chief executive officer of CAP. "This race, in particular, is an opportunity for us to really show other members of the Senate that they need to vote according to principles, or they are going to face challengers in the future — credible challengers."

But established senators describe CAP in similar terms.

"I'll tell you, honestly, with CAP, if you don't do exactly what CAP wants they try to control you and they want to come after you. That's pretty much it," Mr. Vulakovich said.

While Mr. Vulakovich and Mr. Shaffer have both tried to keep their criticisms focused heavily on the issues, the groups backing them haven't shied away from attacks.

Advertise with us

CAP sent out mailers in the race, including some targeted at SRCC donors.

"Your donations to the Republican establishment are going straight to save liberal career politicians," CAP wrote in one flier. The group also described Mr. Vulakovich as a "liberal" — an idea that has raised some eyebrows in the Capitol.

The SRCC, through its attorney, asked the Department of State last week to conduct an audit looking at whether CAP was improperly coordinating with Mr. Shaffer. It noted that the two have used "identical staff and consultants" but did not go into specifics.

CAP has two components. It has a political action committee that accepts publicly disclosed donations and can donate to candidates. It also has a 501(c)4 group, a "social welfare" organization that seeks to educate voters on issues and does not have to disclose its donors or details of its expenses.

The similarities in their consultants raise "the critical question of whether CAP is violating established law regarding CAP's 501c(4) status that limits the amount it may expend on campaign effort," SRCC attorney Matthew Haverstick wrote in a letter to the Department of State last week. “This issue deserves a full investigative audit.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Knepper called the group's letter "nonsense" and said he believes it was “designed to try to intimidate” CAP. He said CAP has only used money from its political action committee to support its efforts to back Mr. Shaffer.

At the end of last week — on the day its financial reports were due — CAP reported that its political action committee has spent more than $100,000 on mailers in the Shaffer race and a separate race in the center part of the state. If Mr. Shaffer and CAP are spending their own money on the same consultants, Mr. Knepper said, it's no different than if a Republican candidate on their own pays for a consultant who has also done work for the SRCC.

Wanda Murren, a spokeswoman for the Department of State, said she could not confirm or deny whether it is investigating.

Mr. Shaffer declined to discuss the specifics of the letter, saying he had not yet read it, but said he would comply fully with an audit if asked. "I have followed all the rules completely," he said.

“I think they're obviously pretty desperate right now,” he said of the SRCC.

Advertise with us

Senate President Pro-Tempore Joe Scarnati, R-Jefferson, who plays a key role in the SRCC, says it's not about desperation at all. “We've got real issues,” he said.

Mr. Scarnati described CAP's challenge in the district as “unfortunate.”

“It doesn't do anything to help keep Republicans in the House or the Senate when they do this," he said. "It's really a race to the bottom.”

Liz Navratil: lnavratil@post-gazette.com