Here’s how quickly the state Supreme Court’s new map of Congressional districts is changing Pennsylvania politics: Just the other day, Democrat Aaron Anthony was campaigning on behalf of a candidate he may end up running against months from now.
While the new map is “wonderful,” campaign spokesman Brandon Blache-Cohen said, “There is some potential irony. We have photos of Aaron knocking on doors and wearing Conor Lamb buttons.”
Mr. Lamb, of Mt. Lebanon, is running in a March 13 special election to fill the vacancy in the 18th District, south of the city. Mr. Anthony, meanwhile, has been among four Democrats hoping to be on the November ballot for the 12th District, a north-of-Pittsburgh district held by Keith Rothfus.
But the map unveiled Monday draws Mt. Lebanon into Mr. Anthony’s district, now renumbered the 17th. Mr. Lamb could well be competing there in the May primary.
“I am running for this seat now and I will be running later no matter where they draw the lines,” asserted a Lamb campaign statement issued Tuesday.
Mr. Blache-Cohen said even if Mr. Lamb does run in the 17th, the campaign has no regrets about backing him — “This is part of a broader movement,” he said. Other Democrats in the new 17th aren’t complaining either.
Read More
The new map “has made things more fair,” said Ray Linsenmeyer, another Democrat running in what was the 12th District.
“Now that we’ll have a more balanced voting district, Keith will have to run on his record and platform and that’s not good news for him,” said a statement from Democrat Tom Prigg. “Traditionally, the [area] has been considered a ‘safe seat’ for Republicans, but the tide is changing.”
Independent observers agree.
Under the new map, Mr. Rothfus’ district went from an area that backed President Donald Trump by 21 percentage points to a district where Mr. Trump won by under 3 percentage points. The old district sprawled from the Ohio border to Johnstown and Somerset: The new 17th drops those far-flung areas, holding to Beaver County and the North Hills, while absorbing more Democratic-friendly river-valley towns and some South Hills communities.
A New York Times analysis said the 17th was “probably a better district for Democrats than they would have hoped for.” The University of Virginia’s Center for Politics now ranks the 17th as “Leans Republican,” a bluer ranking than the old 12th’s “Safe Republican.”
Perhaps not surprisingly, Republicans have denounced the new lines.
Mr. Rothfus called the new map “an act of hubris,” and voiced sympathy with those, including fellow Pennsylvania Republican Ryan Costello, who are calling for impeachment of the court’s Democratic majority. Mr. Rothfus noted that three of the Democrats elected in 2015 spoke about gerrymandering during the campaign. If those remarks were specific enough that they should have prompted recusal from the matter, he said, “You have got to hold them accountable, whether through impeachment or some other mechanism.”
Concerning his district specifically, Mr. Rothfus lamented that the new 17th had “orphaned” Johnstown, drawing boundaries that excluded it from nearby communities. Given the Rust Belt area’s needs, he said, “a legislator would never have sundered the Johnstown community.”
Mr. Rothfus also defended the current map. The 12th invites comparisons to malnourished hammerhead sharks or the hands of God and Adam touching on the Sistine Chapel ceiling, but Mr. Rothfus said its communities had much in common. Beaver and Cambria counties may not lie next door, he said, but they share “very specific challenges.”
Then again, the new map makes for shorter drives — and potentially more responsive government, Democrats say.
“Meeting someone in Johnstown could take half a day,” said Mr. Blache-Cohen. “We loved the relationships we built there, but the district being more compact is better for the process.”
To be sure, there may be logistical challenges in the short run. Candidates will begin gathering signatures on election petitions next week, and voters may be confused about the district they live in. “We’ll definitely overshoot the minimum [signature] requirement by quite a lot to compensate,” said Abigail Gardner, a spokeswoman for District 17 candidate Beth Tarasi.
But she added that Ms. Tarasi, a lawyer from Sewickley, was well positioned to run in the 17th.
“The places that Beth has covered have mostly been northern Allegheny County and Beaver,” which lie in both the old and new map, she said. “The only difference now is that we have some even better terrain.”
Nor do Democrats profess concern about Mr. Lamb potentially swooping into a race they’ve been running for months. (Mr. Lamb would not be obliged to run in the 17th even if he lived there; candidates don’t have to live in the district they run in. But the current 18th District will be much less friendly territory for Democrats after the new map goes into effect.)
Mr. Lamb’s special election has drawn national attention. Much of it has been in the form of a multimillion-dollar negative TV ad campaign by national Republicans — ads voters in the 17th have seen too — but Mr. Lamb raised $557,551 in just the last few weeks of 2017. Ms. Tarasi, District 12’s top fundraiser by a wide margin, raised $174,248 last year.
“We’re running our race, and it’s against Keith Rothfus,” said Ms. Gardner.
“It’s been an incredible exercise in democracy,” said Mr. Blache-Cohen. “And in roller coaster riding.”
Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.