Five inmates on Pennsylvania’s death row filed a federal lawsuit Thursday against the state department of corrections and the superintendents who oversee the two prisons where those sentenced to die reside claiming that being held in almost exclusively solitary confinement violates the Constitution.
Filed in the Middle District of Pennsylvania, the lawsuit seeks class action status to represent the 156 male inmates currently on death row -- nine of whom were sentenced in Allegheny County -- as well as a permanent injunction to ban mandatory solitary for those sentenced to capital punishment.
According to the complaint, filed by the American Civil Liberties Union, the inmates are given just two hours each day on weekdays out of their 8-by-12-foot cells and that’s to exercise alone. The ACLU claims that the practice violates both due process rights, as well as the right to be free of cruel and unusual punishment.
The plaintiffs, who were all convicted in either Philadelphia or Schuylkill counties, have been on death row for at least 19 years. One of them has been for 37 years.
The prisoners named as plaintiffs, according to Witold Walczak, legal director of the ACLU of Pennsylvania, were those who have been most vocal about trying to receive better treatment.
They include Ricardo Natividad, 49, who was sentenced to death in 1997 out of Philadelphia; Anthony Reid, 50, who was also sentenced out of Philadelphia in 1990; Mark Spotz, 46, sentenced out of Schuylkill; Ronald Gibson, 49, sentenced from Philadelphia in 1991 and Jermont Cox, 46, sentenced in Philadelphia in 1995.
The complaint alleges that many of the inmates serving on death row at the state correctional institutions at Greene or Graterford suffer from mental illness because of their isolation. On weekends, they can go for as many as 70 hours without being out of their cells, where lights remain on 24 hours each day.
Death row inmates cannot participate in any prison programming, the lawsuit said, forcing them to spend “almost all of their time idle and alone in their cells.” Further, the complaint continued, they are not allowed to participate in any communal religious worship.
"These restrictions, taken in [total], deprive death-sentenced prisoners of virtually all meaningful human contact. Indeed, on weekdays when no exercise is permitted and on most weekends, a few words exchanged with an officer as a food tray is delivered or removed may be the only human contact that a death-sentenced prisoner experiences—if he experiences even that,” the lawsuit said.
The lawsuit cites extensive research that shows that solitary confinement for any lengthy period of time can cause “substantial physical, mental and emotional harm,” and can cause a decline in inmates' cognitive capacities and ability to communicate effectively.
“Solitary confinement is psychological torture,” Mr. Walczak said. “No human being should be placed in a cage and deprived of human contact for days, much less decades.”
According to the complaint, it is DOC policy for all inmates on death row to be held in a solitary-like setting, no matter their behavior in prison. The lawsuit argues that inmates should be classified based on their prior prison disciplinary history and age, not just on their sentence.
Several states, according to the complaint, have integrated death-sentenced prisoners into general population or allowed them additional time in a group setting without additional risk of violence. Those who have done so include Delaware, Colorado, California, North Carolina and Missouri.
The Pennsylvania DOC, in a statement issued Thursday, wrote that it has “undertaken initiatives to reduce violence in its prisons and thereby reduce the use of segregated housing. As part of the department’s 2018 administrative segregation restructuring measures, the department is already undertaking changes that will allow more out-of-cell time in capital case housing units.
“Currently, all inmates with serious mental illnesses in restricted housing, including capital case inmates, are allowed additional time out of their cells for therapeutic treatment services,” the statement said.
However, according to the complaint, attorneys for the ACLU wrote to corrections officials last year to try to change the housing status of death row inmates but were told DOC would continue following its policy.
“We stand by the description of conditions in the complaint,” Mr. Walczak said. “Whatever the DOC may be doing is either in the planning or not-yet-operational stage. Any lessening of restrictions is welcome, but this is one of the most severe systems of isolation in the country so they’ve got a long way to go.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.