Bill Shuster may be facing an all-too-familiar foe in the 2018 Republican primary — and based on recent history, perhaps in the general election as well.
Art Halvorson, a former Coast Guard officer and Tea Party-style Republican who challenged Mr. Shuster in 2014 and 2016, has commissioned a poll suggesting that just under one-third of Republicans in the 9th district think the nine-term incumbent deserves re-election.
According to a summary of the Gravis Marketing survey provided by Mr. Halvorson, some 578 likely Republican voters in the district were asked "Do you think Congressman Bill Shuster deserves to be re-elected to a 10th term in Congress, or do you think it is time to give a new person a chance to do a better job?" Some 32 percent said they would either "probably" or "definitely' vote to re-elect Mr. Shuster, while 55 percent indicated they would "probably" or "definitely" vote for "a new person."
Previously, Mr. Halvorson has told the Post-Gazette that he was still deciding whether to challenge Mr. Shuster again. And in a release sent out with the poll findings Thursday morning, Mr. Halvorson said he would announce that decision in January, but pointedly added that the incumbent "must have a challenger who is an outsider, not a politician like him, and he or she must be a bona fide conservative."
Internal surveys commissioned by a candidate -- especially those distributed to reporters -- are regarded as less reliable than independent polling. And the Gravis survey wasn't all good news for the potential challenger. It suggests 51 percent of voters had either a "somewhat" or "very" favorable opinion of Mr. Shuster. Mr. Halvorson's approval rating was slightly lower, at 46 percent, with 38 percent of those surveyed saying they had no opinion about him. In a question about how they would vote in a Shuster/Halvorson rematch, Mr. Shuster led 38-36, with 26 percent saying they weren't sure.
But if nothing else, Mr. Halvorson's decision to release the survey suggests the potential for a rematch.
Mr. Shuster easily bested Mr. Halvorson in a three-way 2014 primary, but Mr. Halvorson nearly toppled him two years later. In a 2016 primary in which Mr. Halvorson was heavily outspent, he lost to Mr. Shuster by a narrow margin of 50.6 to 49.4. He then challenged Mr Shuster as a Democrat in the fall election, having secured enough write-in votes on the Democratic side. In the heavily Republican 9th district, he lost to Mr. Shuster by nearly two-to-one in the November election.
Mr. Halvorson would face steep hurdles in mounting another challenge. His campaign committee still carries a $362,000 in debt owed to Mr. Halvorson, with just over $17,000 in cash on hand. Mr. Shuster's campaign, meanwhile is sitting on just under $917,450.
But should Mr. Halvorson run again, he seems likely to work from a similar script of denouncing Mr. Shuster as an establishment lackey. Among the questions asked by his poll: Whether voters agreed that President Donald Trump "is being hampered by career politicians, including the Republicans who overwhelmingly control the House and Senate." Nearly 3 in 4, 73 percent, said they strongly agreed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.