HARRISBURG — The state Supreme Court must decide whether Gov. Tom Wolf forced some home health care workers into a defacto union or whether he merely sought their guidance on issues he already oversees.
The Supreme Court, which consists of five Democrats and two Republicans, heard arguments in the case Tuesday morning and will issue an opinion at a later date. At the center of the case is an executive order the Democratic governor issued in February 2015, when he was just two months into his first and current term in office.
“This case is about separation of powers,” said David Osborne, an attorney for The Fairness Center, which is working with some of the home health care workers. The center promises to help those “facing unjust treatment from public employee union officials.”
Mr. Wolf’s executive order requires direct care workers, who work like independent contractors to provide people with medical care in their homes, to select a representative who will meet regularly with the governor’s administration “for the purpose of discussing issues of mutual concern,” such as wage ranges, health benefits and paid time off.
The order also required the state to create a list of all direct-care workers, which could be released to an employee organization that provides proof that it represents at least 50 of the workers. Pennsylvania counts about 20,000 direct care workers in the state. (An attorney for the state said Tuesday that it has since given workers the option to opt off of the list that is released.)
Direct care workers currently work with patients, often family members, to settle on terms of their employment, such as their pay rate and work hours.
Attorneys for some of the direct care workers said they felt the process outlined in the executive order seemed to force their clients into the collective bargaining process that public sector unions use to settle contract issues, but doesn’t seem to provide them with the same benefits. They pointed, for example, to a provision in the executive order that says the direct care workers can’t try to remove their representative for at least one year.
“This is outside the bounds of what an executive order can do,” Mr. Osborne said.
Several justices peppered him with questions about whether any agreements reached with the state would be binding and whether the governor already has the authority to make some of the changes unilaterally. They noted, for example, that the state already sets a range of wages that the patients can select from when deciding how much to pay their caregivers.
Sean Concannon, who represented the governor, argued, “This is a dialogue, nothing more, nothing less.”
“The word negotiate is not found in the executive order,” he said later, “and it’s not implied either.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.