With voting results still being tabulated Wednesday, some seats on the state’s intermediate appellate courts were still being contested. But it seemed safe to say that both the Superior Court and the Commonwealth Court would retain their Republican majorities.

Three Democrats and one Republican were leading in the vote count for four seats on the Superior Court, but the margin between the two Republicans vying for fourth place was too close to call.

The two seats open on the Commonwealth Court were split between a Democrat and a Republican, meaning that panel will maintain its 7-2 Republican majority.

Superior Court

Advertise with us

There were nine candidates running for four seats on the 15-member Superior Court. Three of the top four vote-getters were Democratic newcomers Deborah Kunselman, Maria McLaughlin and Carolyn Nichols.

The fourth spot turned into a race between Republicans Mary Murray, a magisterial district judge in Allegheny County, and Craig Stedman, district attorney of Lancaster County.

The top four finishers will serve 10-year terms on the Superior Court, which hears appeals from the Courts of Common Pleas in most criminal and civil cases, plus family law matters.

The other Superior Court candidate on the ballot, Republican Judge Jacqueline O. Shogun of Pittsburgh, was overwhelmingly retained for a new 10-year term.

Among the candidates that voters rejected was Judge Geoff Moulton Jr., 59, a Montgomery County Democrat, who was appointed by Gov. Tom Wolf to the Superior Court to fill a vacancy last year.

Advertise with us

The results would change the court’s makeup from eight Republicans and six Democrats (with one vacancy) to eight Republicans and seven Democrats.

Judge Kunselman, 50, a 1992 graduate of the University of Notre Dame School of Law, currently is a judge on the Court of Common Pleas of Beaver County.

Judge McLaughlin, 51, who graduated from the Delaware Law School at Widener University in 1992, is a judge on the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia.

Judge Nichols, a 1994 graduate of Temple University, is a judge on the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia.

Ms. Murray, a 1996 graduate of the Duquesne University School of Law, said the move from the magisterial district courts to an appellate court would allow her to bring a fresh boots-on-the-ground approach to Superior Court.

Advertise with us

If elected, Mr. Stedman, 53, a 1991 graduate of Pennsylvania State University’s Dickinson School of Law, noted during the campaign that he would be the only Superior Court judge who previously served as an elected district attorney.

Commonwealth Court

The race for the two seats on the Commonwealth Court proved to be among the tightest on the ballot. The leaders as of Wednesday morning were Democratic candidate Ellen Ceisler, currently a judge on the Philadelphia Common Pleas Court, and Republican Christine Fizzano Cannon, a judge on the Delaware County Common Pleas Court. Each will serve a 10-year term.

The nine-member court has initial jurisdiction in cases involving state government, including litigation against agencies such as the state police, Department of Corrections and Department of Human Services. It also hears appeals of government-related cases that originated in county courts — such as residents' appeals of zoning, eminent domain and right-to-know rulings.

Judge Fizzano Cannon, 48, a former Delaware County councilwoman, was elected to a 10-year term on the Delaware County court in 2011. She currently serves as head of the Civil Trial Section of the court and has presided over 120 trials and more than 1,400 civil cases. She was a 1994 graduate of the Widener University School of Law.

Advertise with us

Judge Ceisler, 60, has been on the Philadelphia court for 10 years, overseeing criminal and civil trials. A 1986 graduate of the Temple University School of Law, she has been an assistant district attorney, an investigative television news producer and director of the Philadelphia Police Department's Integrity and Accountability Office.

She was leading over Irene McLaughlin Clark, 55, a former judge on the Pittsburgh Municipal Court.

Ms. Clark, 55, was appointed to Municipal Court in 1993 by then-Mayor Sophie Masloff and served until the court was reorganized in 2003. A 1988 graduate of the City University of New York School of Law at Queens College, she has since been back in private practice.

Dan Majors: dmajors@post-gazette.com and 412-263-1456.