Allegheny County family court Judge Dwayne Woodruff’s campaign for Supreme Court went into overtime last night, as early vote counts showed the race between him and his Republican opponent, Sallie Mundy, too close to call. But the former Steeler conceded shortly after 11 p.m.

Early returns showed Judge Woodruff, 60, with a lead, thanks largely to margins of nearly 2-to-1 in the former pro football player’s home county. The numbers turned in Justice Mundy’s direction around 10 p.m. as more results filtered in.

At Room 16, the Strip District club where Judge Woodruff was holding his election party, the room was far from crowded by 11 p.m. There was ample room for dancing, with several children taking the floor at times.

Tuesday’s results will not change the balance of power on the state’s highest court, where Democrats already held a 5-2 majority even with Justice Mundy serving on an interim basis. Judge Woodruff’s victory would have merely added to a Democratic advantage that seems likely to endure for the next decade at least.

Advertise with us

Judge Woodruff, who was seeking to become the first black justice to serve on the Supreme Court since Cynthia Baldwin retired in 2008, was facing a better-funded incumbent in his first statewide race.

Formerly a Superior Court judge, Justice Mundy was was appointed by Gov. Tom Wolf in 2016 on an interim basis to replace Justice Michael Eakin, who resigned amid a pornographic email scandal. Her work there, and her prior legal career, garnered a “highly recommended” rating from the state’s Bar Association. She also joined or authored opinions that won the favor of trial lawyers and a statewide teachers union.

That allowed her to retain traditional Republican bases, like abortion foes, while also capturing groups that typically align with Democrats. The resulting financial edge allowed Justice Mundy to buy TV ads in Philadelphia telling voters she was “Not your typical Republican” — even as she touted backing from gun-rights advocates and opponents of abortion rights.

"This is a great win for Justice Mundy and our other judges. Despite there being 800,000 more Democrats than Republicans in Pennsylvania, our Party came together to support these highly qualified and hard working judges,” said Val DiGiorgio, chairman of the Republican Party in Pennsylvania.

Greg Manz, a spokesman for the state Republican Party, said “Keystone State voters spoke loudly” on Election Day.

Advertise with us

“Justice Mundy’s election is a win for conservative values and the rule of law. We're thrilled that Justice Mundy will continue her defense of the Constitution as a Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice."

But Judge Woodruff, a former defensive back for the Pittsburgh Steelers who earned a Super Bowl ring in his 1979 rookie year, once again found himself playing with a strong team. Democrats and liberal causes reaped big wins in Virginia and elsewhere Tuesday night.

Judge Woodruff, who has served on family court since 2005 and ran a failed 2015 Supreme Court bid, ran a low-key campaign this year. He did, however, raise eyebrows by criticizing President Donald Trump for denouncing professional football players who knelt during the national anthem. Judge Woodruff put out a statement comparing the players to civil rights champions like Rosa Parks and Martin Luther King, and said Mr. Trump had “push[ed] our country to become more divided and ultimately penalize[d] our First Amendment rights.”

Republicans tried to use those remarks against Democrats, with a mailing urging voters to back “judges who share our values and stand for the flag."

“Incumbency matters and she had a seat already, which certainly aided her campaign,” said Chris Borick, a pollster at Muhlenberg College. “And she ran a campaign that tried to appeal to multiple constituencies: the Republican base, which is key in any race, but also appeals to more moderate suburban Dems by saying she wasn’t the ultraconservative they’ve come to fear. The attempt to craft a broad-based image paid off.”

The Supreme Court is the state’s final court of appeal, and hears more than 3,000 requests for review each year. Justices earn $206,054 a year and serve 10-year terms, after which they face an up-or-down vote for retention.