Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf scrapped his predecessor’s health plan in favor of a Medicaid expansion when he took over as Pennsylvania governor in 2015. But now a Medicaid plan with features of former Republican Gov. Tom Corbett’s Healthy PA — including a work requirement — could become law under Mr. Wolf.
Legislation passed by the state Senate late last month could re-shape the commonwealth’s Medicaid program — potentially making benefit changes and requiring work from the program’s able-bodied recipients.
The changes are opposed by Mr. Wolf, though it’s unclear if he might still approve them as part of a larger budget deal with the Republican-controlled Legislature. The proposals are part of the human services code, one of several code bills that must be passed to enact the budget.
Among the major changes put forward, the state would need to request a waiver from the federal government for “options or reforms that require reasonable employment and job search requirements” for nondisabled, nonpregnant, nonelderly adults in the Medicaid program, as well as requiring the state to seek “appropriate limits on nonessential benefits.”
More than 2.8 million Pennsylvanians get their health insurance through Medicaid, although many of those individuals are children, elderly or disabled. The program is a major cost-driver in the state budget.
The effort is opposed by health care advocacy groups.
Read More
“[House Bill] 59 is a reckless attack on health care that will jeopardize the ability of individuals to keep healthy and keep working. HB 59 will allow the state to cut or limit ‘nonessential’ benefits like dental, vision and prescription drugs. It opens the door to future cuts and reductions. This is a bad deal for Pennsylvania families and should be rejected by the General Assembly and the governor,” said a statement from Antoinette Kraus, executive director of the Pennsylvania Health Access Network.
“We don’t believe [the work requirement] is onerous. There are certain exceptions,” said Jennifer Kocher, a spokeswoman for Senate Republicans.
The bill must return to the House for approval before it would reach the governor’s desk.
State human services officials, who oppose the bill as it is currently written, say “nonessential benefits” can include things that many people would consider to be an essential part of comprehensive health care — such as pharmacy services and dental care.
“We are strongly opposed to House Bill 59,” as it is currently, said Brendan Harris, the state’ executive deputy secretary for human services, referring to the proposal’s bill number.
Some observers have noted if these changes are adopted, the state could eventually wind up with some Medicaid changes in line with what Mr. Corbett had proposed — namely, a work requirement and slimmed-down benefits.
Parts of Mr. Corbett’s proposal were approved by the federal government in August 2014, though many of his proposals were not enacted because he lost his re-election campaign in November of that year and Mr. Wolf chose to scrap Mr. Corbett’s Healthy PA in favor of a straightforward expansion of the Medicaid program as permitted under the Affordable Care Act. An estimated 700,000 additional Pennsylvanians have gained coverage through Medicaid due to the expansion.
A work requirement for the program would require federal approval — something that federal officials have not previously allowed for Pennsylvania’s Medicaid program or any other, though many policy experts predict that will be permitted under the Trump administration.
This administration and Seema Verma, the administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, have signaled that they would be open to states experimenting with work requirements, said Robert Doar, Morgridge Fellow in Poverty Studies at the conservative think tank the American Enterprise Institute.
When someone is applying for Medicaid or another safety-net program, “why shouldn’t we say, ‘We’ll help you get a job,’ ” said Mr. Doar, who previously worked as commissioner of New York City’s Human Resources Administration, overseeing public assistance programs.
A number of states have pending waivers involving work requirements before the federal government said MaryBeth Musumeci, associate director at the Kaiser Family Foundation’s program on Medicaid and the Uninsured.
Most able-bodied adults on Medicaid are working, and those who aren’t are often caring for a family member, going to school or looking for work, she noted.
“Just telling people to work is not necessarily going to get those people working,” Ms. Musumeci said.
Advocates for making the changes note that some other safety net programs also have work requirements.
Last year, a requirement kicked in for most Pennsylvania counties that required able-bodied adults without dependents in the food stamp program to be working 20 hours every week to receive benefits. About 30,000 fewer people in that category statewide are receiving benefits than before the requirement went into effect, though state officials caution that they can’t say for sure if that is due to the work requirement.
Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909 or on Twitter @KateGiammarise.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.