One veteran congressman easily deflected a challenge in Tuesday’s primary, while a powerful colleague — hobbled by ethical questions — claimed a razor-thin victory over a hard-charging opponent..

Rep. Mike Doyle, D-Forest Hills, defeated Janis C. Brooks, a North Versailles pastor and founder of a community nonprofit, for the third time in as many 14th District primaries. The district, which Mr. Doyle has represented for 22 years, takes in parts of Allegheny and Westmoreland counties.

In the more spirited 9th District primary race, Rep. Bill Shuster, R-Bedford, claimed victory over Art Halvorson, a retired Coast Guard captain from Bedford County, who had questioned the incumbent’s record and ties to a female lobbyist.

Mr. Shuster, a congressman since 2001 and chairman of the powerful Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, had defeated Mr. Halvorson and a second challenger in the 2014 primary. The two were neck and neck all night, separated at times by only a few hundred votes.

Advertise with us

While Mr. Halvorson was refusing to concede, Mr. Shuster issued a statement early today, saying, “I am honored to represent a region that I have called home my entire life, and I thank the people of the 9th district for electing me to represent the Republican Party in the election this November. My campaign focused on a positive message of conservative solutions that cut spending and put up a roadblock to President [Barack] Obama’s disastrous agenda, and I won’t stop fighting for these values.”

The district takes in Bedford, Blair, Fayette, Franklin, Fulton and Indiana counties and parts of Cambria, Greene, Huntingdon, Somerset, Washington and Westmoreland counties.

Lacking opposition from the other party, the primary winners in both races are likely to sail to victory in the fall. “You know, I’ve always felt that the best way to campaign is to do your job,” Mr. Doyle said.

Mr. Doyle and Ms. Brooks both campaigned on job growth and the expansion of economic opportunity, though the latter asserted that a new voice was necessary to achieve progress. She said she was particularly worried about “angry” youths in disadvantaged communities, while Mr. Doyle campaigned on his efforts to spur innovation and grow the region’s technology economy.

Citing the wide lead he held throughout the night, Mr. Doyle said that it is “nice to have the affirmation of the voters.”

Advertise with us

“It just motivates me to go back to Washington, D.C., and work even harder on their behalf,” he said, citing his commitment to ensuring Pittsburgh is a place where one’s “kids and grandkids can find jobs and homes and stay.”

Mr. Shuster took over the 9th District seat after the retirement of his father, Bud Shuster, a Transportation Committee chairman who at the end of his lengthy career was reproved by a House ethics panel for various lapses, some relating to a lobbyist. Some political observers had predicted that the younger Mr. Shuster now was at risk of his own forced retirement.

Waging an aggressive but shoestring campaign, Mr. Halvorson suggested that Mr. Shuster was not conservative enough and, despite his clout, had not accomplished as much as he should have during 15 years in Congress. In addition, he assailed the incumbent’s relationship with a female airline industry lobbyist, calling it grounds for a resignation.

He said Mr. Shuster embodies a Beltway culture in which “lobbyists have direct access and taxpayers have no access to Washington.” He said Mr. Shuster and his father together represent a 40-year “dynasty” supported by moneyed interests and that a defeat of the incumbent would be a blow to establishment politics..

Mr. Shuster has declined to discuss his personal life in detail but insisted that there is no conflict of interest because the lobbyist does not attempt to influence his office. He said Mr. Halvorson, a Rhode Island native who moved to Bedford County nine years ago, did not understand the district and misrepresented the incumbent’s record.

Joe Smydo: jsmydo@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1548.