HARRISBURG — As a seat on the state Supreme Court sits open, Senate Republican leaders have raised concerns about a commission Gov. Tom Wolf has convened to advise him on potential nominees for the appellate courts.

The 11-member commission will review applications from people who want to be considered to fill vacancies on the Commonwealth, Superior and Supreme courts and present the governor with qualified candidates, said Jeffrey Sheridan, spokesman for Mr. Wolf. A two-thirds Senate vote is required to confirm an interim judge, and with the Senate divided between 30 Republicans and 19 Democrats, votes from both parties are needed.

In interviews in recent weeks, Senate Republican leaders expressed discomfort with the composition of the commission and resistance to the idea that all nominees would be reviewed by the group.

“The governor certainly has every right to review and to do background checks, and he should, on any nominees that we may submit to him,” said Senate Majority Leader Jake Corman, R-Centre. “But I’m not going to have people go through a panel of his choosing to let them decide whether people are qualified or not.”

Advertise with us

“I can’t see any way we would confirm a list of judicial nominees coming over from the governor’s private, hand-picked commission without approval and consultation with the Senate,” said Senate President Pro Tem Joe Scarnati, R-Jefferson.

The Senate Republicans’ general counsel, Drew Crompton, said the GOP leaders are not disputing that Mr. Wolf has a right to name an advisory commission.

“But he doesn’t have a right to form a commission that impedes our ability to support and promote candidates we think would garner the required votes in the Senate,” Mr. Crompton said.

Mr. Sheridan said the governor has no plans to go around the Senate, and that he will continue to take suggestions for nominees and consider the reactions of the Senate.

“The role of the commission is to present to the governor qualified individuals, nothing more and nothing less, for vacancies,” Mr. Sheridan said in an email. “The governor will still work with the Senate to get its advice and consent on his nominees, as is explicitly laid out in the Pennsylvania Constitution.”

Advertise with us

Robert Jubelirer, a Republican who served as Senate president pro tem for nearly 21 years, said that with the two-thirds confirmation threshold, “in essence, the governor is pretty much forced to work with the leadership of the Senate.”

There are three vacancies on the Superior Court, two vacancies on the Commonwealth Court and one vacancy on the Supreme Court, said Jim Koval, spokesman for the courts. A person confirmed to fill a vacant seat serves until the winner of the next election in which judges are on the ballot — in this case, in November 2017 — is sworn into office.

Dusty Elias Kirk, the commission chairwoman and an attorney with ReedSmith in Pittsburgh, said the commission has interviewed nearly all of the 46 applicants for the vacancies on the Superior Court and the Commonwealth Court. The commission was asked to complete its evaluations of applicants for those courts by April 30, she said.

In evaluating applicants, the commission is looking for “someone who’s going to be able to not have a long learning curve, because there is not time for a long learning curve,” Ms. Kirk said. She said the commission is looking for applicants who are familiar with appellate procedure and the rules of evidence, and who like to write. It is also considering diversity and service to the community and legal profession.

In February, Mr. Corman and Mr. Scarnati declined an invitation to recommend a member for the commission. In a Feb. 16 letter to Mr. Wolf’s general counsel, Denise Smyler, they wrote that the nomination and confirmation of interim appellate judges is “a political process.”

Advertise with us

“Factors not directly related to the individual’s credentials are often woven into the deliberative process,” Mr. Corman and Mr. Scarnati wrote. “For example, the number of vacancies, the interest of the individual to seek a full term, party affiliation, other outstanding non-judicial vacancies and geographical balance are often all considerations.”

In questioning the role of the commission, Senate Republicans said they have looked into the party affiliations of the members, and believe all but one to be Democrats, with the affiliation of the remaining member undetermined.

Mr. Sheridan said the governor’s office does not know the party affiliations of commission members.

“We don’t care about party affiliation,” he said. “It’s about qualifications.”

Ms. Kirk said she, too, does not know whether members are Democrats, Republicans or independents, and she said the commission does not know the affiliations of applicants for judicial vacancies.

Advertise with us

“That’s not our charge,” she said. “We’re looking at who’s best qualified.”

In addition to Ms. Kirk, the commission’s members are, according to a list from the governor’s office: Rachel E. Branson of SunGard Data Systems Inc.; Mandi Culhane of Goehring Rutter & Boehm, PC; Lisa M. Benzie of Navitsky Olson & Wisneski, LLP; Carl E. Singley of Tucker Law Group; Sharon R. Lopez of Triquetra Law; Gregg J. Potter, president of the Lehigh Valley Labor Council; Thomas J. Duffy of Duffy + Partners; Margaret Casey McGrath, owner and CEO of Universal Printing Company LLC; Gerald Lawrence of Lowey Dannenberg Cohen & Hart, P.C.; and Gaetan J. Alfano, chancellor of the Philadelphia Bar Association and partner at Pietragallo Gordon Alfano Bosick & Raspanti.

Mr. Sheridan said the process is similar to one put in place by former Gov. Tom Ridge, a Republican who led the state from 1995 to 2001. A March 1998 press release from Mr. Ridge’s office announced the naming of a judicial advisory commission to “identify qualified persons to consider for nomination to vacancies on the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas.” A June 2000 press release announced a judicial advisory commission to address vacancies on the Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas and the Philadelphia Municipal Court.

Former Gov. Ed Rendell, a Democrat who served from 2003 to 2011, said that in considering potential nominees for vacancies on the appellate courts, he consulted his general counsel and his own knowledge, as well as bar associations. But he said there is no reason a governor should not use a commission.

“Gov. Wolf isn’t a lawyer, so a commission is probably a good idea,” Mr. Rendell said.

Karen Langley: klangley@post-gazette.com or 717-787-2141 or on Twitter @karen_langley.