On the eve of a critical Senate hearing on her political future, Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane on Monday asked the state Supreme Court to reinstate her law license.
Ms. Kane contended that when the high court voted unanimously to temporarily suspend her law license last fall, its opinion was “incurably tainted“ by Justice J. Michael Eakin’s involvement in a scandal that has become known as Porngate.
Ms. Kane said Justice Eakin was aware that she had access to several dozen emails with pornographic and other offensive content that he sent or received on a personal email account. The emails were captured on state computer servers because a deputy attorney general, using his government email account, took part in the exchanges.
“Justice Eakin’s participation was not just a lapse in judgment, but rather was a knowing and deliberate attempt to remove his accuser,” Ms. Kane contended in court papers filed Monday afternoon.
Ms. Kane’s lawyer, James F. Mundy, said he hoped to receive a decision in the matter before 1 p.m. today, when a state Senate committee is to hold its final hearing on whether Ms. Kane should be removed from office. However, it is unlikely the high court will move that swiftly.
For several months, the committee has been exploring whether Ms. Kane, a Democrat, can continue to function as the state’s top law enforcement officer without an active law license. The state constitution requires the attorney general to be a lawyer, and the committee has heard testimony from constitutional experts that most of her duties require her to act as a lawyer.
Read More
The high court suspended Ms. Kane’s law license after she was charged with perjury and other offenses for allegedly leaking confidential grand jury material in a bid to embarrass a critic. She has pleaded not guilty.
Ms. Kane, 49, the first woman and Democrat to be elected to the office, also contends that the Legislature is pursuing a unconstitutional process.
Last week, she said she would not appear before the committee.
Instead, former Democratic Gov. Ed Rendell has said he was willing to testify on her behalf. But he said late Monday he was unsure if he could clear his schedule to attend because Ms. Kane’s staff only contacted earlier in the day to nail down his appearance.
Jonathan Duecker, Ms. Kane’s chief of staff, submitted testimony to committee members on Monday, saying Ms. Kane’s duties as attorney general involve much more than legal decisions.
He said she sets policy, personnel and funding priorities, and — not unlike the governor or other high-ranking elected officials who are not lawyers — views public safety as the core of her mission.
He objected to characterizations of the Attorney General’s office under Ms. Kane as “a leaderless, directionless agency.”
After its hearing Tuesday, the Senate committee is expected to produce a report to recommend whether the full Senate should vote to remove her. The constitution provides that she and other elected officials may be removed by the governor for “reasonable cause,” after a two-thirds vote in the Senate.
“If the Senate were to give the governor power to remove her, the constitution provides no remedy to put her back in there — you can’t take it back,” Mr. Mundy said. “It’s called irreparable harm.”
Justice Eakin, a Republican from Cumberland County, was temporarily suspended last month by the Court of Judicial Discipline. The three-judge panel found that his participation in the email scandal had jeopardized the public’s trust in the judiciary. A formal trial to determine further discipline, if any, for Justice Eakin is expected early this year.
Last week, three new justices were sworn in on the state Supreme court, all Democrats. With Justice Eakin’s suspension, Chief Justice Thomas Saylor is the only Republican on the Supreme Court.
The porn email scandal first roiled the Supreme Court in late 2014, when Justice Seamus McCaffery suddenly retired after he was linked to hundreds of offensive emails.
Afterward, the court hired an outside lawyer to review all emails sent or received by all justices, and the lawyer found Justice Eakin’s “unremarkable.”
Ms. Kane raised the issue of Justice Eakin’s emails anew in the fall. She did so after he joined his colleagues on the Supreme Court in unanimously voting to suspend her law license.
Ms. Kane made public several dozen of his emails, including ones that contained pictures and videos of topless women and supposed jokes at the expense of gays, lesbians, feminists and others.
Justice Eakin has apologized for the messages, saying they do not reflect his character.
Ms. Kane argued in her emergency petition that Justice Eakin should have recused himself from the vote to suspend her license and that judicial impartiality is critical to her right to due process.
While Justice Eakin was only one of five justices to vote to suspend Ms. Kane’s license in September, her lawyers argued that he might have influenced the entire court through his powers of persuasion. “Appellate judges do not operate in silos,” they wrote.
Despite Ms. Kane's emergency petition, Senate lawyers said Monday that today’s committee hearing will proceed as scheduled.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.