A five-judge panel of the state Commonwealth Court ruled Wednesday that former Gov. Tom Corbett had the authority to line-item veto elements of the 2014 fiscal code providing funding to the state Senate.

Members of Senate leadership filed a petition against the governor in November 2014, challenging his ability to cut funding for items such as Senate salaries, wages and personnel expenses, including lodging, meals and incidentals while away on business, as well as $2.5 million from the department of general services for rental, relocation and municipal charges to the House.

In the petition, the senators claimed that the vetoes were improper and that because the House session had been adjourned the day before the veto and because Mr. Corbett did not give public notice of his actions, that they were invalid. Further, they argued that the governor was not constitutionally permitted to disapprove select portions of the fiscal code because it is not a general appropriation bill, and that he must either have approved or disapproved it in its entirety.

But Judge Bonnie Brigance Leadbetter, in ruling on the governor’s preliminary objections and Senate motion for summary judgment, disagreed.

Advertise with us

Mr. Corbett did provide public notice of his veto by issuing a press release regarding his actions, and his objections were properly served on the House Parliamentarian, whose office remained open even during adjournment, she wrote.

In addition, the court found, “While the governor is not empowered to interfere with the legislative power to craft the purpose and scope of general legislation via a partial veto, he has been empowered with the ability to disapprove of specific items of appropriation in a bill making appropriations of money — that is, he can disapprove of any provision in a bill directing funds to be spent for a particular purpose, thereby exerting a greater influence and measure of control (i.e., his limited legislative authority in the appropriations context) in achieving a budget acceptable to all sides.”

At the time of the cuts, Mr. Corbett said that he made them because the Legislature failed to rework the state pension system.

“They filled the budget with discretionary spending and then refused to deal with the biggest fiscal challenge facing Pennsylvania: our unsustainable public pension system,” Mr. Corbett said in July 2014. “For these reasons I am forcing mutual sacrifice with the General Assembly through the governor's ability to line-item veto and hold spending in budgetary reserve.”

The petition was initially lodged against Mr. Corbett, but he was replaced as a party when Gov. Tom Wolf took office. Previous Senate leaders who filed the petition were also replaced with the new office-holders.

Advertise with us

Drew Crompton, counsel to Senate Republicans, said he was disappointed in the decision but was unsure if they would appeal. The Commonwealth Court has retained jurisdiction of the case.

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.