HARRISBURG — Everybody here is getting ready for the holidays.

There’s a Christmas tree in the Capitol. Garlands and wreaths hang in the Rotunda. Groups of holiday carolers sing daily, surrounded by lobbyists and legislators hurrying past.

Everything is in readiness — except a spending plan for the state. The budget season that was supposed to be over June 30 has dragged, month by month, into the holiday season. Human service agencies around the state have laid off staff, and some school districts are threatening not to reopen after their Christmas break.

Political analysts, legislators and Capitol staffers point to a number of factors — among them increasing political polarization, a potential contentious tax hike, a 2009 court decision from the last lengthy impasse — as having dragged the current stalemate to nearly the six-month mark.

Advertise with us

On June 30, Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf vetoed a Republican-crafted budget sent to him by the Legislature; the two sides have been wrangling over a budget since. Mr. Wolf has favored additional funds for education, and Republicans have resisted higher taxes to pay for it.

There’s one primary factor — divided government, in the form of a Democratic governor, and a House and Senate controlled by Republican majorities. But the two sides arguably aren’t just from different parties — they have completely divergent visions of what state government and a state budget should do.

Read More

Many Republicans in the general assembly “believe the role of government should be less,” said Senate Minority Leader Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills. “And the governor believes that we need to invest — whether it be in education, human services or economic development.”

“Both sides have firmly held philosophical beliefs that are polar opposites in some respects,” said Charlie Gerow, a Republican consultant in Harrisburg.

Additionally, because of the 2014 election results that brought Mr. Wolf into office by a large margin, and that also grew the number of Republican legislators in both the House and Senate, both sides believe they have a mandate from the voters, said Christopher Borick, a professor of political science at Muhlenberg College in Allentown.

Advertise with us

“Everybody feels empowered,” he said.

Pollster Terry Madonna of Franklin & Marshall College says in his view, polarization is the primary culprit.

“We now have the most conservative Legislature in modern history,” Mr. Madonna said, noting many Republican members were elected on no-tax pledges and come from heavily gerrymandered districts. Add to that a liberal governor, and that’s the main reason the commonwealth’s impasse is ongoing, Mr. Madonna said.

Another potential factor, in Mr. Gerow’s view, was the governor’s veto of the entire budget on June 30, as opposed to just line-item vetoing the portions of the budget he didn’t agree with. If he had vetoed only the portions he disagreed with, there would have been more of a framework to start negotiations earlier on, Mr. Gerow said.

Many in the Capitol also see a court ruling from the last budget standoff, in 2009, as having enormous impact this time around. The 2009 Supreme Court decision that said state employees who work must be paid during a budget impasse removed some of the pressure legislators got in past stalemates from angry unpaid state workers.

Advertise with us

That court ruling “removed a big pressure point that in past years often led to budgets getting done,” said Bill Patton, a spokesman for the House Democratic Caucus and a veteran of budget impasses in 1991, 2003 and 2009.

State workers have continued on the job as usual this year, despite the lack of a signed state budget since July 1.

“I think that pushed the pressure points back several months,” Mr. Costa said.

Another added complication, Mr. Madonna believes, is that it is far more difficult for legislative leaders to get members to vote for deals they have struck — a situation currently playing out in the House Republican caucus. House GOP members have revolted over a framework of a deal agreed to by their leaders last month.

“They don’t have the carrots and sticks the leadership used 10 years ago,” when leaders were able to steer funds for legislators’ pet projects to their districts more easily, Mr. Madonna said.

Advertise with us

Furthermore, any tax vote is going to be contentious. There are additional complicating factors that have become wrapped into this budget negotiation.

“It’s too simplistic to say this is all about taxes,” said Michael Manzo, a vice president at public relations and lobbying firm Triad Strategies, and the longtime chief of staff to former House Speaker Bill DeWeese.

This year’s budget has also become tied to two very complex issues: liquor privatization backed by House Republicans and public pension reform Senate Republicans want.

“The general assembly has been trying to do liquor reform since [the] Shapp [administration]” in the 1970s, Mr. Manzo said. “Pension reform has been kicked around this building for the last decade.”

As the impasse marks 173 days today, it’s still unclear how it will end. The Senate has passed a $30.78 billion budget — though not the tax package needed to pay for it — supported by the governor, but the House then passed its own $30.26 billion plan, which Mr. Wolf opposes.

Advertise with us

“Divided government can end in compromise — or it can end in gridlock,” Mr. Borick said.

Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com or 717-787-4254 or on Twitter @KateGiammarise.