It may seem too early to think about the 2016 elections: Many voters haven’t even finished ignoring this year’s judicial races yet.
But politicos are already scrutinizing the Democrats seeking to challenge Republican U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey next year. And the candidate with the most unorthodox campaign may not even be the tattooed, 6-foot-8-inch mayor of Braddock.
To be sure, John Fetterman is unusual, possessing what the candidate himself calls a “freak-show appearance” and a singular narrative about his efforts to restore his long-suffering mill town. “What we’re doing in Braddock isn’t partisan or political,” he said. “It’s just trying to rebuild a community.”
He might also seem a dark horse against two Democrats who’ve run statewide before: retired Adm. Joe Sestak, a former congressman who narrowly lost to Mr. Toomey in 2010, and Katie McGinty, who finished well behind Gov. Tom Wolf in 2014 and later became his chief of staff.
But Mr. Fetterman’s campaign isn’t merely a feel-good exercise.
“We have an incredibly gifted team [with] plenty of horsepower,” Mr. Fetterman said. It’s being managed by Bill Hyers, who handled New York Mayor Bill de Blasio’s successful campaign, and other heavy hitters may get on board.
Larry Ceisler, a longtime political analyst in Philadelphia, said Mr. Fetterman was attracting interest from political insiders there. “They are getting calls from D.C. and some very credible people saying, ‘You should talk to this guy and take him seriously.’ ”
A serious primary campaign will likely cost at least $4 million, said Christopher Nicholas, a veteran consultant who has worked on statewide Republican campaigns. In its first 17 days, Mr. Fetterman’s campaign raised just under $169,000, of which over $30,000 came from family members. But more than a third of the funds were donated in sums of less than $200, which Mr. Fetterman touts as proof of strong grass-roots support.
Currently, most of the bigger money seems inclined to Ms. McGinty, who raised more than $990,000 between early August and the end of September. Of that, $106,500 came from committees tied to interest groups such as unions, which can also provide political manpower on Election Day.
Ms. McGinty’s bid has been helped by the backing of Mr. Wolf, and supporters ranging from Kutztown Mayor Sandra Green to the United Steelworkers.
“In a relatively short period, she’s demonstrated that she has broad-based support,” said McGinty spokesman Mike Mikus.
High-powered backing can be a double-edged sword at a time when voters seem fed up with party elites, said Jim Burn, a one-time chair of the state Democratic Party. “You almost don’t want to get endorsed by the quote-unquote establishment,” he said. “She has to show that she’s her own person. But she is very personable, and has the ability to connect.”
In fact, Mr. Mikus said Ms. McGinty’s early fundraising included 2,300 people who’d contributed less than $200. “It shows people believe that Katie can get things done,” he said.
Mr. Sestak, meanwhile, is waging a near-insurgency in the face of opposition from party elders. Its centerpiece is a “Walking in Your Shoes” campaign, which began with a statewide hike last spring and continued Friday with a 3-mile walk between events in Pittsburgh. The campaign frequently surfaces to fire off press releases at Mr. Toomey before blending back into the countryside — at up to 200 events for other causes each year, his campaign said.
Mr. Nicholas said that approach plays to Mr. Sestak’s strength as an “indefatigable” retail campaigner, one with “supporters from more pockets throughout the state because he’s been campaigning since 2009.”
Between July and September, however, Mr. Sestak reaped just under $551,000 in contributions, well below Ms. McGinty’s haul. Less than $5,000 of Mr. Sestak’s support came from political committees, as he’s been unable to match Ms. McGinty’s labor backing.
Still, his early start in the race leaves him with $2.4 million in cash, and his campaign seemed unfazed by recent financial news, or by Ms. McGinty’s success with unions. In a statement, it touted his 100 percent rating from the AFL-CIO during his time in Congress, and said, “Joe wants to represent people, not organizations.”
Mr. Toomey, who beat Mr. Sestak by just 2 percentage points in 2010, appears well-positioned to face whichever candidate wins next spring. His campaign is already sitting on a war chest of nearly $8.6 million, and outside interests, including the American Chemistry Council and a conservative veterans group, have already been advertising on his behalf.
In August, a Quinnipiac University poll showed Mr. Toomey leading Mr. Sestak and Ms. Ginty by 15- and 16-point margins, respectively. A Franklin & Marshall poll that same month showed Mr. Toomey holding a slightly wider lead over both candidates.
Mr. Fetterman’s name wasn’t polled until early October, when a Public Policy Polling survey showed tighter margins for Mr. Toomey. But the PPP poll showed Democratic voters with no clear preference for a champion: Mr. Fetterman was the pick of 14 percent of Democrats, while Mr. Sestak and Ms. McGinty were in the 20s.
“The numbers don’t mean much right now,” said PPP director Tom Jensen. “All three of these folks have a chance.”
Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.