A battle over what may be the most contentious TV ad of the state Supreme Court race — a spot targeting Democratic Judge Kevin Dougherty — continues, with lawyers trading letters and accusations. Today, the group behind that campaign alleged that Judge Dougherty had reason to know he’d placed a 10-year-old with a convicted murderer, years before police would charge the adult with horrific acts of abuse.

Placed by an outside-spending group called the Republican State Leadership Committee, the ad faults the Philadelphia judge for a 2002 decision to place a 10-year-old girl, Beatrice Weston, with Linda Weston, an aunt who’d been convicted of killing another sister’s boyfriend nearly 20 years before.

As the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette previously reported, there appears to be no evidence that Judge Dougherty knew of Linda Weston’s criminal past when he placed Beatrice in her home. Transcripts and filings in a subsequent federal lawsuit suggest that family members and child welfare officials supported the placement. In the months that followed, a child welfare worker visited Beatrice and Linda Weston 19 times. As U.S. District Judge Barclay Surrick wrote in a January opinion, the worker “viewed Beatrice as being in a safe, stable environment and doing well with her aunt.”

That history prompted Adam Bonin, an attorney for the Dougherty campaign, to demand TV stations remove the ad, which he called “fraudulent to its core.”

Advertise with us

But the RSLC has stood by the ad, most recently in a letter it sent to TV stations today. While the letter offered no evidence to suggest Judge Dougherty knew of Linda Weston’s past in 2002, it said Judge Dougherty could have done more at the time, and should have done more a year later.

When placing Beatrice in 2002, “Judge Dougherty never asked … if a background check had been conducted,” the letter said. Moreover, “Judge Dougherty learned on December 1, 2003, that Linda Weston was convicted for murder in 1983,” but “did not remove Beatrice Weston from Linda Weston’s home.” Had he done so, the letter contended, "Judge Dougherty could have saved Beatrice Weston from nearly eight years of 'horrific' suffering."

The 2003 date appears to refer to a separate court hearing involving not Beatrice, but her brother. At that hearing, apparently also held before Judge Dougherty, Beatrice’s mother and another aunt “represented to the court that Linda Weston had previously been convicted of murder,” Judge Surrick wrote. The court “directed [child-safety] workers to investigate these claims and file a restraining order if Beatrice was not safe,” Judge Surrick wrote, but officials failed to follow up on that concern. Evidence suggested child-welfare officials reported Beatrice being safe at least as late as November 2004, the judge wrote.

The RSLC stuck by its claims in a statement to the Post-Gazette. “While ignorance is no excuse, in this case it is not even accurate,” said spokeswoman Ellie Wallace. “Judge Dougherty was presented with Linda Weston’s criminal record as a convicted murderer in 2003 by the victim in question’s family, yet he still failed to take the girl out of a dangerous environment that would become an unspeakable nightmare for her. Enough with the excuses.”

None of the tragedy surrounding the case is Judge Dougherty's fault, countered Philadelphia attorney Shanin Specter, whose law firm handled the lawsuit filed against the city. That suit did not name Judge Dougherty, who “did nothing wrong,” said Mr. Specter. “The suggestion that he did is outrageous. A judge is limited by what the parties and the attorneys tell him.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Specter has donated more than $45,000 to Committee for a Better Tomorrow, a political committee tied to the Philadelphia Trial Lawyers that is heavily supporting Democrats — and helping to fund an organization called Pennsylvanians for Judicial Reform, which has launched its own controversial ads attacking the Republican slate.

“Obviously if DHS had informed the judge, he would have made a different decision,” said Ken Snyder, a spokesman for the Dougherty campaign. “But the judge is only as good as the information he’s getting. It’s a wildly misleading spot, and we’ll let the lawyers litigate the whole thing.”