Pennsylvania state Rep. Harry Readshaw said today that there is “no legislation more important” to pass than a controversial bill he co-sponsored that would block public officials from releasing the names of police officers under investigation for shooting people or using other types of force.
Appearing at a news conference at the Capitol in Harrisburg with several colleagues in the Legislature and police union officials, Mr. Readshaw, D-Carrick, professed his appreciation for police officers and said, “I hope there is a strong effort to get it passed as quickly and as soon as possible so we can protect law enforcement officers.”
Today's statement marks Mr. Readshaw's first public comments on House Bill 1538, which has garnered bipartisan support and drawn 52 co-sponsors. Mr. Readshaw declined an interview request last week.
The bill, introduced by Rep. Martina White, R-Philadelphia, would bar public employees from identifying an officer who shot someone or used force in the line of duty. They could release the name of an officer who is criminally charged. But without charges filed, the name could remain hidden depending on whether identifying the officer could "reasonably be expected' to harm the officer or an immediate family member, or their property.
Civil liberties, media and open-records advocates oppose the bill, arguing that it would diminish accountability and further fray relations between police officers and communities.
State Sen. John Rafferty, R-Montgomery, another speaker, warned of a “growing 'anti-cop' mentalityin many of our communities that is posing a real danger to police officers.”
“We have seen a surge in the murder of law enforcement officers recently putting officers at even greater danger for retribution and violence. These men and women proudly wear the badge and face danger on the job every day. In some cases, they may have to discharge a firearm or use force to maintain peace and security," Mr. Rafferty said in a statement released this afternoon. "In these cases, they should be afforded respect and protection for themselves and their families when an investigation is ongoing. Releasing their identities puts them at terrible risk simply for doing their job, and often leads to a presumption of guilt before the facts can be reviewed.”
Rep. White said her bill was to prevent a “rush to judgment” of police officers, whom she referred to as “heroes.”
“Rushing to judgment and making assumptions about officers’ actions only serves to feed into the mob mentality that is plaguing our nation and is creating targets out of our officers,” Ms. White said. “While criminals threaten the well-being of our officers every day, our own public officials shouldn't be the ones handing over officers’ information. That can lead criminals straight to them and their families, where they can take vengeful actions. It’s wrong, and now is the time to do something about it.”
State Sen. John Sabatina Jr., D-Philadelphia, who is working on a companion bill in the Senate, also raised the specter of “mob” actions. He noted -- as have Rep. White and the Philadelphia police union -- that law enforcement agencies internally examine use of force by officers.
“The actions of the officers who use force should be subject to thorough scrutiny by responsible supervisors,” Sen. Sabatina said. “But if those actions withstand this scrutiny, they should not be turned over for re-judgment by an emotional mob.”
Mr. Readshaw seemed to agree and said after the news conference that he did not think the legislation would harm the accountability of police.
He said police investigations of shooting incidents involving officers “will be reasonable and impartial, and obviously they will come up with the conclusions that are fair and honest.”
Standing in the Capitol rotunda, Mr. Rafferty posed a rhetorical question:
“Why would you put a police officer's name out there until an investigation is completed?” Mr. Rafferty asked. “We need to make sure that we protect the identity of our police officers during any investigation. If there's no charges filed, that police officer and his or her family, in this day and age of Google, can continue to be protected.”
One legislator who has publicly criticized Ms. White’s bill is Rep. Brian Sims, D-Philadelphia. Earlier this month, he said that despite being the son of two military officers, he would rather support reforms such as mandating officers to wear body cameras rather than hiding their names.
“We need to protect good cops from threats and violence,” Mr. Sims said in a statement. “But good cops don't need this legislation. I stand with [Philadelphia police] Commissioner [Charles] Ramsey and oppose a sweeping bill that would fuel 'cover-up’ suspicions and corrode the very trust with the community that law enforcement needs to keep everyone safe, including themselves.”
Mr. Ramsey this summer created a new policy in Philadelphia that releases the names of officers involved in shootings within 72 hours unless there are extenuating circumstances.
Pittsburgh police Chief Cameron McLay has declined comment on the bill.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg. Karen Langley: klangley@post-gazette.com or 717-787-2141 or on Twitter @karen_langley.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.