HARRISBURG — To an observer, the negotiation of the Pennsylvania state budget — and the major policy changes that can accompany it — looks like clusters of sharply dressed people coming and going from closed-door meetings.

In a Capitol hallway, small groups of legislative leaders and top aides emerge from the elevator or appear at the top of the stairs and duck into an office by the governor’s ornate reception room. The governor, and a handful of the men and women in his cabinet, stride across the hallway connecting his personal offices and those containing a conference room with a long wooden table marked “Office of the Governor.”

Reporters loitering in the hallway often wait until the meeting’s adjournment, when the news will be newest, to shout questions. In the past few days, increasing frustration over the slow pace of negotiations has been evident in the answers (or the silence) that follow those questions.

Inside the conference room, surrounded by reproductions of paintings by Violet Oakley, whose art decorates the Capitol, the principal figures in Pennsylvania lawmaking discuss their areas of difference — or at least a schedule for further meetings. The “nitty gritty” details of budget writing, as one aide put it, are generally delegated to staff.

Advertise with us

Gov. Tom Wolf and House Speaker Mike Turzai on Tuesday each claimed the other was standing in the way of progress with just a week to go before the budget deadline.

Budget timeline

June 27: GOP pension bill advances after Democrats walk out of committee meeting

June 26: The Republicans start to advance their own budget; Wolf threatens veto

June 25: The governor says he hasn't seen a GOP proposed budget, so can't say whether he'd veto

Advertise with us

June 24: Lawmakers begin to discuss possibility of submitting budget with none of the governor's input

June 23: Stalemate -- Meetings between governor and Republicans mostly focus on scheduling future meetings

Key proposals of Mr. Wolf, a Democrat who unseated former Gov. Tom Corbett by nearly 10 points in November, conflict with priorities of the Republicans who in the same election strengthened their majorities in the state House and Senate.

Mr. Wolf has emphasized his proposals to increase education funding through a severance tax on natural gas and to subsidize the property taxes of the middle class, which he has called for doing by increasing the state sales and personal income taxes.

Speaking to reporters Monday, the top Republican in the Senate, President Pro Tem Joe Scarnati, said Republicans believe they can balance the budget without broad-based tax increases.

Advertise with us

Mr. Wolf has insisted he won’t bend on the education issue and the means to finance it, but that he is willing to talk about pension reform and changes in the state’s liquor control system.

Mr. Wolf took office after Mr. Corbett, who was not known for his rapport with legislators, and the new governor made a point of reaching out to House and Senate members, often visiting them in their Capitol offices.

“These discussions are getting difficult because the philosophical balance, or the philosophical differences, are substantial among the House and Senate Republicans and the governor,” said Drew Crompton, general counsel to Senate Republicans. “It’s always better to talk to someone who is collegial than not, but these are philosophical differences. This isn’t rising and falling on personalities.”

Leaving a closed-door meeting with the governor Tuesday, Mr. Turzai, R-Marshall, said that “wide gulfs” remain in the negotiations, and that Republicans in the House and Senate are prepared to move forward alone on legislation to remake retirement benefits for state and public school workers and to turn the state business in wine and spirits over to the private sector.

“We’ve got to have pension reform and we’ve got to have real privatization, and the governor so far has completely stalled on those two issues,” Mr. Turzai said.

Advertise with us

Minutes later, a visibly frustrated Mr. Wolf said the talks had yielded “movement” on the topics of pensions and liquor. But he said it’s time to “park that” and move on to talking about property taxes, school funding and the state’s budget shortfall.

“They’re holding this hostage to liquor,” Mr. Wolf said. “He is, the speaker. I’m not willing to hold property tax relief hostage to booze. I’m not willing to hold our kids and their education hostage to booze.”

Later, the House Republican leader, Dave Reed, said his members would not hold up the budget over a liquor bill.

On Tuesday morning, Mr. Turzai said the meeting had focused solely on the scheduling of additional meetings. But Sen. Pat Browne, R-Lehigh and chairman of the Senate Appropriations Committee, said both substance and scheduling had been addressed.

“There’s concessions being made, as there are in negotiations,” Mr. Browne said. “Just nothing that’s gotten us to a final deal yet.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Wolf said the talks had yet to address education funding, a leading issue in his gubernatorial campaign.

If funding levels have not been touched upon, a proposed change to how that money is distributed began to move Tuesday, as the Senate Education Committee approved an allocation formula that was unanimously recommended last week by a bipartisan panel of legislators and administration officials.

The chairman, Sen. Lloyd Smucker, said the formula should be used to distribute any increase in K-12 education funding included in the upcoming state budget.

As to the negotiations, there was no word Tuesday evening when the next meeting would be.