HARRISBURG — A divided panel of judges ruled Wednesday that Gov. Tom Wolf overstepped his authority when he undid his predecessor’s appointment to lead the state Office of Open Records, a decision the governor then appealed to the state Supreme Court.

Shortly after taking office, Mr. Wolf fired Erik Arneson, a former top Senate Republican aide, saying his appointment during the waning days of the Tom Corbett administration lacked transparency.

The firing prompted an early dispute with Senate Republicans, who joined Mr. Arneson in challenging the governor’s action in court. The ruling Wednesday ensured the disputes between the governor and the Senate Republican majority would not fade from the forefront of Capitol discussions, after the Senate earlier this week voted down Mr. Wolf’s nominee to lead the state police.

In its 4-3 ruling, the Commonwealth Court said the Office of Open Records must sometimes determine whether documents of the governor should be made public, and that the office is structured to be independent of the executive branch.

Advertise with us

Citing these factors, as well as the records chief's fixed term of office and the office’s status as a quasi-judicial agency, the court concluded: “We find clear legislative intent that the executive director of [the Office of Open Records], an independent body, is insulated from the governor's power to remove appointees at will.”

The court ordered that Mr. Arneson be restored as executive director with back pay.

In a dissenting opinion, President Judge Dan Pellegrini said the state Constitution holds that the governor can remove the open records director without showing cause. He noted that the executive director is not confirmed by the Senate.

“It is an insult to governors to suggest that they would remove the executive director simply because he rendered an unfavorable decision,” Judge Pellegrini wrote.

Two other judges, of the seven who heard the case, joined in the dissent.

Advertise with us

Mr. Arneson said in a statement that the decision was a “tremendous step forward” for the records office.

“The Office of Open Records must be truly independent in order for it to function as it was intended,” he said. “I very much look forward to establishing a positive working relationship with Gov. Wolf and his administration.”

Senate Republicans applauded the decision and said the governor should let it stand.

“We are hopeful that the governor will stop his efforts to undo the wall of independence between the Office of the Governor and the Office of Open Records,” Senate Majority Leader Jake Corman, R-Centre, said in a statement.

As a top aide to Sen. Dominic Pileggi, R-Delaware, the previous Republican leader, Mr. Arneson was involved in developing the state right-to-know law.

Advertise with us

Mr. Pileggi said in a statement that the court had confirmed the intent of the law — that “in order for the Office of Open Records to function effectively, it must be free from meddling by the governor and other political forces.”

Jeffrey Sheridan, spokesman for Mr. Wolf, found “absurdity” in the Republican stance, saying the law had been written to exempt the Senate from the jurisdiction of the records office.

The disagreements between the governor and Senate majority come as they, along with House Republicans, meet in private ahead of the June 30 state budget deadline.

Karen Langley: klangley@post-gazette.com, 717-787-2141 or on Twitter @karen_langley.