Tuesday's primary balloting will kick off an election cycle that will determine the shape of the state Supreme Court for a generation, test the clout of a new cast of local leaders and the interest of voters who, recent turnout levels suggest, are increasingly estranged from the political process.
For the scandal-plagued high court, both parties feature primary races with six candidates vying for the three nominations at stake on each side. Those nominations will set the stage for a November election that will determine the court’s partisan balance for years to come.
The Democratic field includes Superior Court Judge Christine L. Donohue, Kevin M. Dougherty, administrative judge of the Trial Division in Philadelphia Common Pleas Court; John Foradora, a Common Pleas judge in Jefferson County since 2002; Superior Court Judge Anne E. Lazarus, Superior Court Judge David N. Wecht, and Dwayne Woodruff, an Allegheny County Common Pleas Court judge since 2006.
The Republican contenders include one sitting justice, Correale F. Stevens, along with Superior Court Judge Cheryl L. Allen; Commonwealth Court Judge Anne Covey; Adams County Common Pleas Court Judge Michael George, Superior Court Judge Judith Olson, and Rebecca Warren,the Montour County district attorney.
The unprecedented number of vacancies _ the most in one year in the court's history _ were created by the retirement of former Chief Justice Ronald Castille, the resignation under fire of former Justice Seamus McCaffery, and the resignation and felony conviction of former Justice Joan Orie Melvin. Justice Stevens was appointed by former Gov. Tom Corbett to fill the unexpired portion of the Melvin term.
The Brennan Center for Justice at the NYU law school has been tracking the spending in a race that their analysts expect to be one of the most expensive judicial contests in the country. Trying to break through the fog of anonymity that typically surrounds court contests, candidates for the high court had spent a collective $2.4 million on broadcast television ads by Friday, according to the Brennan analysis.
Philadelphia's Judge Dougherty spent the most – at least $1 million – and another Democrat, Judge Wecht, had spent at least $440,000. Judge Lazarus' spending topped $200,000. Judges Donohue and Woodruff had yet to purchase air time according to the Brennan report.
Three of the GOP hopefuls had booked advertising time, though at levels that trailed the leading Democratic spenders. Judge George was the biggest spender, with $200,000 on his own and another $170,000 in joint spending with Judge Olson. Judge Covey had reserved air time costing more than $140,000.
In addition to ads and endorsements, the nominations could turn on regional voting and the relative turnouts across the state. In that context, the Western Pennsylvania Democrats face a hurdle posed by the degree of interest generated by the other races that will appear on Tuesday's ballot.
Voters in Philadelphia, the state's largest Democratic stronghold, may be lured to the polls by a mayor's race that drawn a big field and big spending. In Allegheny County, by contrast, incumbents in the top offices of executive and district attorney are unopposed.
By default, the most attention in a quiet year has been focused on two fiscal offices that would usually be second-tier contests. The controllers of Allegheny County and the city of Pittsburgh, both face challenges from candidates supported by their government's top office-holders. County Controller Chelsa Wagner faces her predecessor, Mark Patrick Flaherty for the Democratic nomination. Mr. Flaherty is strongly supported by county Executive Rich Fitzgerald despite the fact that they ran against one another for executive four years ago.
In the city, Controller Michael Lamb is doing his best to fend off a challenge from city Councilwoman Natalia Rudiak, whose candidacy was embraced by Mayor Bill Peduto. Mr. Peduto and Mr. Fitzgerald, political allies who are both in their first terms, represent a new political establishment in local government. The respective controllers' races will be watched not just on their own terms, but as tests of the extent to which the Fitzgerald-Peduto alliance can extend its influence to other offices.
Based on past experience, Mark Wolosik, the veteran head of the county elections division, predicted last week that roughly 25 percent of Democratic voters would show up on Tuesday, along with 21 percent of the GOP's registered voters. Last year's primaries for governor suggest that those projections could be optimistic.
The county's GOP turnout was just under 11 percent in the 2014 primary — understandable, perhaps, in that former Gov. Tom Corbett faced no opposition for renomination. But the Democratic ballot was led by a spirited governor's race with a big field of credible, well-financed candidates. yet it drew a turnout in the county of just more than 20 percent.
Statewide, Gov. Tom Wolf won the nomination in a landslide, with 58 percent of the Democratic tally. But his victory percentage was more impressive than his absolute vote total. Four years earlier, Dan Onorato won the Democratic gubernatorial nomination with a plurality of just 45 percent. But his vote total, 460,000, was only about 25,000 below the 485,000 collected by Mr. Wolf. And in 2002, former Gov. Ed Rendell won the nomination over now-Sen. Bob Casey with 56 percent of the vote. That was a little short of Mr. Wolf 2014 percentage, but because of the significantly higher turnout that year, Mr. Rendell's vote total, just over 700,000, dwarfed Mr. Wolf's tally.
Altogether, Tuesday's balloting across Allegheny County will determine the nominees for 1,386 contests for municipal, school board and judicial offices, according to Mr. Wolosik.
In addition to the Supreme Court contests, voters will nominate candidates for one seat on Superior Court and another on Commonwealth Court. In Allegheny County, eight candidates are competing for three open seats on Common Pleas Court.
There are three contested primaries for county council, one Republican and two Democratic. The Democratic county council race in the 11th District comes with a figurative asterisk as one candidate, the late Councilwoman Barbara Daly Danko died two week ago. Her name is nonetheless still on the ballot and some party members are still urging a vote for her over the remaining candidate, Caroline Mitchell.
On Pittsburgh city council there are four contested primaries on the Democratic side. In contrast to county council, no Republican has served on the city’s legislature in generations.
Politics editor James O'Toole: jotoole@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1562.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.