A nascent movement to decrease the term of second-class supervisors is stirring widespread criticism.

Under the terms of a state legislative committee proposal, supervisor terms would be reduced from six to two years. In Pennsylvania, elected borough, first-class townships, city and school board seats have four-year terms.

“It would cause instability,” said Pine Manager Scott Anderson. His counterparts across Pennsylvania agree.

Dave Sanko, executive director of the Pennsylvania State Association of Township Supervisors, said a groundswell of opposition to the measure led to a unanimous vote in April to declare the organization against the proposed legislation.

Advertise with us

“It can take a new board member two years just to get familiar with things. [Under this proposal,] that new member would be going off the board or having to run again,” Mr. Sanko said.

Pennsylvania has 1,454 second-class townships, fewer than 50 of which are operated under home rule charters and can choose term lengths. Mr. Sanko said the proposed legislation would not impact those municipalities, such as Pine.

Either way, Mr. Anderson said he objects to the proposal in principle.

“From the township’s (management) perspective, I’m not sure it matters quite as much. But, for those who would have to run (for office) and to do that every two years, I think it would be a burden. It would be a disincentive to run. And it could reduce continuity and that could impact the public,” he said.

Some municipalities across Allegheny County already have made public statements against the idea, including officials in North Fayette and South Park,

Advertise with us

Sponsored by state Rep. Joe Emrick, R-Northampton, House Bill 864 was referred April 1 to the Local Government Committee. The legislation has five co-sponsors, including state Rep. Daryl Metcalfe, R-Cranberry. Mr. Metcalfe did not return a call to his office. Mr. Emrick has contended that shorter terms would translate to greater accountability on the part of elected officials to their constituents.

To become law, House Bill 864 would have to pass through state House and Senate committees as well as pass both chambers and then be signed by the governor. Mr. Sanko of PSATS said the initiative was made at least once before and died in committee.

Cranberry Manager Jerry Andree said he sees the situation as “if it isn’t broke, don’t fix it. I have never heard a complaint from a supervisor about six years being too long. I’ve never heard a complaint (from a taxpayer.) Having six-year terms provides for stability,” he said.

Marshall Manager Neil McFadden said he could understand the potential for regarding six years as “a major commitment with a capital C.” And he said he even could entertain the notion that it would make sense to reduce the term somewhat. But, going from six years to two years seems drastic, he said.

“I think two years would have a negative affect. There’d be a lack of continuity. What we’ve got now is stability - and what we have is a luxury that may be hard won for those who make the commitment. But, the turnover every two years, well, I don’t think it would be a positive for the community,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Sanko said the membership that voted unanimously to oppose the legislative proposal saw only negatives: not enough time for a new board member to become familiar with municipal operations; not giving as much opportunity for newly elected officials to interract with experienced officials; setting up a scenario that could leave to an entirely new board every two years.

“The general concensus is that this is to the greater detriment of the taxpayer who is looking for stability and efficiency from local government,” Mr. Sanko said.

The change would affect elected officials in these other Allegheny County towns: Fawn, Findlay, Forward, Frazer, Harmar, Kilbuck, Moon and Ohio Township.

Karen Kane: kkane@post-gazette.com or at 724-772-9180. Freelance writer Sonja Reis contributed to this story: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.