HARRISBURG — Gov. Tom Wolf and Democratic legislators on Wednesday cited the closely watched religious freedom law in Indiana as they advocated for Pennsylvania to ban discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation.

Bills to do so languished in committee in the last legislative session. Leaders of the Republicans, who hold the majority in the state House and Senate, have not indicated whether prospects have brightened this year.

“Indiana’s actions should serve as a call for Pennsylvania to pass non-discrimination legislation right now,” Jeffrey Sheridan, spokesman for Mr. Wolf, said in a statement. “All people — regardless of sexual orientation — should be treated equally under Pennsylvania law.”

Sens. Daylin Leach, D-Montgomery, Vincent Hughes and Larry Farnese, both D-Philadelphia, and Rep. Dan Frankel, D-Squirrel Hill, issued an open letter urging Mr. Wolf, who has previously asked for a bill enshrining the protections, to “redouble” his efforts. They invoked the nation’s history of legalized racial discrimination, writing that the Indiana law “is tantamount to a resurrection of Jim Crow.”

Advertise with us

Also Wednesday, a group of technology industry executives — including the CEOs of Lyft, Twitter, Airbnb and eBay — released a statement calling on legislatures to add sexual orientation and gender identity to the classes protected under state civil rights laws and to explicitly forbid denying services to anyone.

“Anything less will only serve to place barriers between people, create hurdles to creativity and inclusion and smother the kind of open and transparent society that is necessary to create the jobs of the future,” said the statement, distributed by the Human Rights Campaign, which advocates for LGBT rights.

Thirty-four Pennsylvania municipalities have local ordinances banning discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation and gender identity, according to Equality Pennsylvania, an advocacy group.

Pennsylvania is one of a number of states that have had religious freedom protections on their books before the adoption of the Indiana law drew protests from technology companies, an expression of concern from the National Collegiate Athletic Association and bans on publicly funded travel to the state from the governors of Connecticut, New York and Washington.

But the Pennsylvania law, enacted in 2002, differs from the Indiana statute in significant ways, both in its text and in the context in which it was passed, legal experts say.

Advertise with us

The Pennsylvania law states that neither the state nor local governments should “substantially burden” a person’s exercise of religion, unless there is a “compelling” government interest that is achieved in the least intrusive way. An individual, church or religious nonprofit could go to court to seek an injunction.

The Indiana law differs in three key ways, said Tobias Wolff, a University of Pennsylvania law professor who represented a New Mexico woman who prevailed in a discrimination complaint against a photographer who had declined to document her commitment ceremony to another woman.

In Indiana, the law can be invoked by for-profit businesses, which the Pennsylvania law does not allow. The Indiana law applies to private disputes, where the Pennsylvania law appears restricted to cases in which the government is directly involved. And parties who succeed in a claim brought under the Indiana law could seek damages, where victors in a Pennsylvania claim cannot.

In the New Mexico case, the state Supreme Court found that because the state’s religious freedom law states that it applies only to actions by a government agency, it does not apply to disputes between private parties, Mr. Wolff said.

“The laws are being drafted now in an explicit attempt to make sure that businesses will be able to turn away customers or fire employees without running into limitations,” he said.

Advertise with us

A federal religious freedom law grew out of an effort to protect the rights of religious minorities, such as Native Americans penalized for smoking peyote in religious ceremonies. State laws followed after the federal law was found to not apply to states.

“You didn’t have this rise of respect for the rights of people in same-sex relations,” said Gary Gildin, interim dean of the Dickinson School of Law at Penn State University. “There was really no motivation at that time to say this is what we need this act for.”

The context is different now, with increasing numbers of states recognizing marriages between couples of the same sex. A federal appeals court struck down Indiana’s ban on same-sex marriage last year.

Randall Wenger, chief counsel for the Pennsylvania Family Institute, which advocates for religious liberty, said that the right to raise religious objections does not mean the government cannot show it has a compelling interest in combating discrimination. But he said that society should be careful in deciding which acts deserve to be punished.

“In a free society, we should have space for people to disagree about fundamental things, like what is marriage, to be free to decide with word or deed to support or not support certain things,” he said. “I think that goes to who we are as a people.”