HARRISBURG — A proposal to give the Legislature new authority in determining which charitable organizations deserve tax exemptions gives too much power to state lawmakers, according to a coalition of local government officials and organized labor.

That coalition is opposing a bill that could lead to a statewide vote on the issue and, ultimately, a constitutional amendment.

The issue of tax-exempt nonprofits — including hospitals and other large employers — is a familiar one in Pittsburgh and Allegheny County but has statewide impact as well.

“It affects every municipality, every county, every township, every borough,” said Rick Vilello, mayor of Lock Haven and a past president of the Pennsylvania Municipal League, speaking at a news conference Wednesday in the Capitol. He was flanked by representatives from the Pennsylvania Professional Fire Fighters Association, the Pennsylvania Fraternal Order of Police and the Pennsylvania State Association of Boroughs.

Advertise with us

“What is the appropriate contribution for the services that are provided? [Nonprofits] get police protection, they get sewer and water and plowing, and fire protection. There is a value to that. What’s a fair value? And how is that determined?

“This constitutional amendment takes the power [away from] local officials and sets the standard for non-profits that will just generate more tax-exempt property,” Mr. Vilello said. Forty-four percent of Lock Haven real estate is exempt from paying property taxes, he said.

Senate Bill No. 4 is scheduled for a vote today in the Senate Finance Committee, and is expected to pass. The bill would still need to pass the full Senate and House by mid-February to appear on the statewide primary ballot in May.

The legislation passed the Senate last session by a vote of 30-20 and passed the House 118-82; for a constitutional amendment, a bill must pass in two consecutive legislative sessions, and then must be approved by voters.

Supporters of the legislation, such as the Hospital & Healthsystem Association of Pennsylvania, say it is needed for clarity and statewide uniformity due to a 2012 court decision that struck down a portion of the law defining a “purely public charity.”

Advertise with us

Opponents have also decried what they see as the bill being fast-tracked for a swift approval, without public hearings or debate.

“This is the second session it’s being voted on, so it is certainly not being fast-tracked,” said Sen. John Eichelberger, R-Blair, a supporter of the bill who chairs the Senate Finance Committee.

Mr. Eichelberger said contrary to local officials’ fears, he believes they could end up with a greater ability to collect taxes from large nonprofits than they now have. The bill wouldn't insert any specific tax criteria into the constitution; that would still need to be hammered out by the Legislature, he said.