HARRISBURG — Santa Claus apparently missed a stop in his travels around Pennsylvania.
He failed to bring the Revenue Department stockings filled with tax money to close an estimated $2 billion budget deficit.
While tax collections have been above estimates for the year, December’s sales tax collections appear on target or slightly weaker than projected, said Matthew Knittel, executive director of the Legislature’s Independent Fiscal Office.
“No Christmas miracle,” Mr. Knittel said.
The Revenue Department will release its December tax collection data today, giving lawmakers and Democratic Gov.-elect Tom Wolf a clearer picture of the state’s finances when they are sworn into office.
Lawmakers take the oath of office Tuesday; Mr. Wolf takes the oath Jan. 20.
In the meantime, some lawmakers in the southeastern part of the state are floating bills aimed at raising business taxes to close the deficit.
A bill sponsored by Rep. Stephen McCarter, D-Montgomery, would raise the capital stock and franchise tax, which outgoing Gov. Tom Corbett cut from 2.89 mills to 0.67 mills over his four years in office.
Mr. McCarter says his bill would raise $1 billion by putting the tax, which is levied on companies’ physical assets and is scheduled to be eliminated by 2016, back to the 2008-11 rate of 2.89 mills.
A bill by Rep. Madeleine Dean, D-Montgomery, would impose a 4 percent tax on Marcellus Shale natural gas drillers to go along with the existing impact fee they pay on wells. The combined tax rate would be 5.9 percent. The new tax would go to public and higher education, while the impact fee would continue to go to municipalities.
Not to be outdone, Sens. John Rafferty, R-Montgomery, and Andy Dinniman, D-Chester, have a bill to add an impact fee for municipalities where natural gas lines must be built to get Marcellus Shale gas to refineries. Gas lines are proposed in the Philadelphia suburbs and through part of the Lehigh Valley.
But passage of the tax bills could be a long shot without concessions by Democrats and Mr. Wolf. Republicans dominate the Legislature, and they historically have preferred budget cuts over tax hikes. They’ve indicated they won’t consider new revenue ideas unless Mr. Wolf and Democratic lawmakers consider alternatives.
Rep. Mike Turzai, R-Marshall, who is expected to be elected House speaker Tuesday, has said he wants to privatize state liquor stores to raise revenue.
Newly minted Senate Majority Leader Jake Corman, R-Centre, said Mr. Wolf must be willing to provide all new state government hires corporate-style 401(k) plans instead of taxpayer-backed traditional pension plans as a condition for tax increases.
Sen. Pat Browne, R-Lehigh, the new Senate Appropriations Committee chairman, is crafting a pension bill along those lines.
The Legislature failed to enact either liquor privatization or pension changes, which is what Mr. Corbett had sought for the last two years of his term.
Mr. Wolf opposed both initiatives during the campaign. He ran on a platform to tax natural gas drillers to increase money for education and to change the state’s flat income-tax rate so higher earners would pay more.
The parties’ competing interests could make for interesting debate in the new year, said G. Terry Madonna, Franklin & Marshall College pollster and political science professor. But both Democrats and Republicans agree more money is needed for education and more revenue is needed to close the budget gap.
With those shared goals, Mr. Madonna said, all sides appear willing to negotiate and compromise, unlike when neither Democratic nor Republican lawmakers could get along with Mr. Corbett.
“It’s hard to believe the state can get through the next fiscal year without new revenues,” Mr. Madonna said. “It’s now obvious both sides have to give something.”
Wolf spokesman Jeffrey Sheridan said the governor-elect is working with his transition team to try to understand the scope of the deficit he will inherit. Mr. Wolf also has not taken a stance on any bills being floated, he said.
“We are going to work with leaders from both parties,” Mr. Sheridan said.
Steve Miskin, spokesman for the House Republican caucus, said all sides need a clearer picture of revenues and spending priorities before negotiations start.
Drew Crompton, chief of staff for Senate President Joe Scarnati, R-Jefferson, said there have been no substantive talks between Mr. Wolf’s team and Senate Republicans.
During his campaign, Mr. Wolf did not offer details of his proposal to change the personal income tax, so Republicans don’t know what his budget plan will be.
“We are not going to negotiate what he wants when we do not understand what he wants,” Mr. Crompton said.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.