The House and Senate each has an ethics committee responsible for investigating complaints against members, initiating investigations and holding members accountable for misconduct. The committees work in secret, leaving the public uncertain of how busy or diligent they are.
The chambers refused to release any records they might have showing how many ethics complaints they had received about members, or how many investigations their ethics committees initiated, in recent years.
The Legislature also has exempted from disclosure documents that would help the public to know whether basic ethics rules are followed and how often legislators’ official duties and outside business interests intersect.
The House, for example, refused to provide the Post-Gazette with sign-in sheets or other documentation of members’ attendance at what is supposed to be two mandatory hours of ethics training for each member every legislative term.
“As a courtesy,“ Anthony F. Barbush, the House chief clerk and open records officer said in an email, ”please be advised that, to date, all House members have completed required ethics training.“
In an interview, Rep. Scott Petri, R-Bucks County, the Ethics Committee chairman during the past term, said the training sessions include discussions of Ethics Commission rulings and of ethical scenarios lawmakers could face.
The House released records showing that Fox Rothschild LLP, a law firm, billed nearly $89,000 this year for services as independent counsel to the Ethics Committee. The expense records did not indicate what the work involved or how much time was spent on committee business.
Senate rules also require ethics training for members.
The Senate said it had no sign-in sheets or agendas, but expense records showed that the Senate retained Kathleen Clark, professor at Washington University Law School, to provide ethics training to both chambers this year. The Senate said the cost — nearly $34,000 for professional services and travel expenses — would be shared with the House.
Ms. Clark said her work included four training sessions — one for each caucus in each chamber — and focused on ethical standards and how to prevent ethical lapses. She said one prevention technique is embracing not merely the standards but the broader principles behind them.
She likened the line between right and wrong to the white stripe marking the sideline of a football field and suggested officials steer clear of it. ”My approach to this is, I don’t even want chalk on my shoes.“
She said the legislators were engaged in the discussion and asked good questions.
The ethics law requires lawmakers and other public officials to file statements of financial interest each year.
The statements provide only limited information about lawmakers outside interests, however, and the House declined to release documents that would shed additional insight — statements that members must file, under the Legislative Code of Ethics, when they receive compensation ”for assisting any person in any transaction involving the commonwealth or any of its officials.“
The House wouldn’t say how many members have filed such statements in recent years.
Joe Smydo: jsmydo@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1548.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.