btHARRISBURG — A review of thousands of emails between the state Supreme Court and the Office of Attorney General found no improprieties, other than already-reported pornographic messages sent by a justice who retired following his suspension from the court in October.
The review, which was conducted by Pittsburgh attorney Robert Byer, was released Friday by the Supreme Court. It examined several thousand messages from 2008 to 2012 to and from individuals between the two offices.
The review was conducted in the wake of a pornographic email scandal that prompted the resignation of a number of state officials and the retirement of Supreme Court Justice Seamus P. McCaffery.
Mr. Byer's review found that, other than the previously disclosed emails from former Justice McCaffery, “there were no email messages of an improper nature sent by any Justice of the Supreme Court to any representative of [the Attorney General's Office], or from any representative of OAG to any Justice of the Supreme Court.”
The review also that found none of the emails contained “any discussion of or information related to any case in the Pennsylvania judicial system, with the exception of proper email messages related to a statewide grand jury investigation and a series of proper email messages related to authorizations to intercept wire, electronic or oral communications.”
A number of organizations had asked for a review or public release of the emails, to ensure justices were not having email conversations with the attorneys who appear before them, about the cases they are deciding.
“There was no reason for any justice of the Supreme Court to be recused from any case as the result of any email communication or any relationship evidenced by any email communication,” the review said.
A spokesman for Mr. McCaffery could not be reached Friday.
A spokeswoman for the attorney general’s office said the office’s internal review of the emails is ongoing.
“It’s been a rough few months for the court system, and we are pleased that the emails — with the exception of those from Justice McCaffery — were not improper,” said Lynn Marks, executive director of Pennsylvanians for Modern Courts, a nonpartisan court reform group.
“Moving forward, we hope that the court maintains its commitment to transparency and fully understands the need to avoid even the appearance of impropriety.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.