Two new surveys tell a familiar story: Gov. Tom Corbett trails his challenger, Democrat Tom Wolf, by a wide margin.

But the polls from Quinnipiac University and the Internet polling firm, YouGov, diverge in methodology and on just how steep a hill the incumbent must climb to salvage his chances for a second term.

The Quinnipiac survey found the Democrat running away with the race, with a lead of 59 percent to 35 percent among likely voters. The YouGov results, compiled for CBS News and the New York Times, put Mr. Wolf’s advantage at 50 percent to 39 percent among registered voters.

The Quinnipiac survey is based on 1,161 phone interviews, including land lines and cell phones, with a random sample of voters who said they planned to cast ballots in the Nov. 4 election.

Advertise with us

The YouGov survey relies on questionnaires that a panel of 3,544 respondents selected and weighted to match the demographics of all the registered voters in the state completed on the internet.

In the traditional polling industry, random surveys such as the Quinnipiac poll, which in theory give each voter an equal chance of being included in the sample, have long been considered the gold standard. Logistical challenges, notably steadily falling response rates to phone calls, have complicated the challenges of traditional polling however. That has opened the way to innovative but controversial approaches such as the large internet panels that YouGov employs.

Similarly varying results have cropped up throughout the post-primary polling in this race. In recent weeks, for example, a Franklin & Marshall survey, conducted like Quinnipiac’s via live interviewers, found Mr. Wolf with a 24-point advantage. An automated phone survey, which the Republican-leaning firm Harper Polling conducted at about the same time, put the Corbett defect at just 11 percentage points. Through all this polling dissonance, however, one note has sounded consistently: Mr. Corbett has trailed by significant margins.

In the Quinnipiac survey, Mr. Wolf was the choice of nine out of 10 Democrats and a majority of independents, a group he carried 53 percent to 39 percent., and nearly a third of the Republicans said they would not vote for the incumbent.

Mr. Wolf, the York businessman, won majorities among men and women. The YouGov results, while not offering much overall consolation to Mr. Corbett, had a slightly less bleak picture for the former prosecutor. They showed a lower level of GOP defections from their nominee, 12 percent versus 28 percent in the Quinnipiac findings, and a nearly even split among independents, 39 percent Wolf and 36 percent Corbett.

Advertise with us

Mr. Corbett was ahead among the males in the YouGov sample, 43 percent to 41 percent, and trailed among women, 51 percent to 26 percent. Quinnipiac showed Mr. Wolf winning among men, 52 percent to 42 percent. Among women, he was 64 percent to 28 percent.

In television commercials and other media the Corbett campaign has been on the attack against Mr. Wolf since before the May primary, but the Quinnipiac results suggest the race remains largely a referendum on the incumbent.

A majority of the Wolf supporters in the survey said their vote was based mainly on opposition to Corbett rather than a positive assessment of his opponent. Overall, Mr. Corbett’s approval rating was a dismal 33 percent favorable and 55 percent unfavorable. Half the voters viewed Mr. Wolf favorably and just 22 percent unfavorably.

Mr. Wolf also got higher marks on each of the issues tested in the poll: the economy, education, spending and taxes.

In a week in which the two campaigns have aired dueling ads on Mr. Corbett’s education spending, Mr. Wolf’s greatest advantage was on education, where voters, by a margin of 61 percent to 29 percent, thought the Democrat would do a better job.

The Corbett campaign has also contended that a Wolf administration would mean higher taxes, but half the voters preferred the Democrat on that issue as well, compared to the 41 percent who said that they thought Mr. Corbett would do a better job on taxes.