HARRISBURG — The case of a woman from rural Pennsylvania who was sentenced to jail time last week for furnishing so-called abortion pills to her pregnant daughter is receiving growing national attention.
Her cause also is being picked up by Democrats who say the unusual criminal case is the result of Republicans’ continued hostility toward women and their reproductive rights.
“This is a direct consequence of the state Legislature’s obsession with restricting access to abortion, and they are the ones who should bear the responsibility,” said Susan Frietsche, a senior staff attorney with the Women’s Law Project in Pittsburgh.
She and other advocates say that responsibility also extends to the state’s top office. In 2013, Republican Gov. Tom Corbett signed a law that prohibits women from buying insurance coverage for abortion through the Affordable Care Act marketplace, and in 2011, he signed a law that added new regulatory burdens for abortion clinics in the state.
Mr. Corbett’s office declined to comment on the case.
Jennifer Whalen, of Washingtonville, Montour County, in north-central Pennsylvania, was sentenced after pleading guilty to purchasing and furnishing pills to her 16-year-old daughter, who was pregnant and wished to have an abortion. The daughter later had medical complications, which is how law enforcement officials ultimately learned of the purchase.
The incident took place in 2012, according to court records. Ms. Whalen bought the pills online from an overseas pharmacy for $45.
“The defendant stated she did not obtain a prescription because she didn't know a prescription was required,” according to the police criminal complaint, filed with court documents in Montour County Common Pleas Court.
The same complaint said the “victim was going to go to the hospital for an abortion but, at the time, she didn't have [health] insurance.”
The drugs Ms. Whalen purchased — Misoprostol and Mifepristone — can be used for what is known as a medical abortion. According to the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, a medical abortion can be performed only early in pregnancy — a woman can be no more than nine weeks’ pregnant.
The drugs are not approved for over-the-counter use, which means they require a doctor’s prescription, according to a spokeswoman for the ACOG.
About two weeks after taking the pills, “the victim experienced severe pain in her abdominal region requiring her to be transported to the emergency room” to be treated for an “incomplete abortion” and a related infection, court documents said.
Ms. Whalen pleaded guilty to statutes that require an abortion to be performed by a physician and another charge of dispensing drugs when not being licensed to do so. Her attorney declined to comment.
State Sen. Daylin Leach, D-Montogomery, in a statement earlier this week, said the types of laws passed by state lawmakers in 2011 and 2013 can have the effect of reducing access to abortion services.
“Abortion is a legal, constitutionally protected right that should be available to all women,” Mr. Leach said. “Pennsylvania’s misguided policies have made it nearly impossible for women like Ms. Whalen’s daughter to obtain a safe and affordable abortion.”
The nearest free-standing clinic that performs abortions is 75 miles from Washingtonville. According to abortion statistics from the state Department of Health, in 2012, 14 women from Montour County received abortions; eight of those procedures were performed in Montour County.
Talcott Camp, deputy director of the Reproductive Freedom Project at the American Civil Liberties Union, said the case and subsequent prosecution are unusual circumstances but not unheard of. She sees the case as symptomatic of increasing limitations being placed on abortion access.
“If you care about good health care, stop blocking access to it,” she said.
A statement from the Pennsylvania Pro-Life Federation said the case "is an example of the need to provide more education and support to pregnant and parenting women and their babies...When families like the Whalens are struggling financially and facing an unplanned pregnancy, they should not have to feel that abortion is their only option. Women deserve easy access to pregnancy and parenting support for themselves and their babies."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.