Calling transportation investment vital to safety and the economy, the head of the state Senate Transportation Committee unveiled legislation on Tuesday that would bring in $2.5 billion per year in new revenue for roads, bridges, transit and other modes.

The measure quickly drew bipartisan accolades, even as key players cautioned that work remains to fashion a final bill that can pass the Legislature and be signed by Gov. Tom Corbett.

Senate Bill 1, introduced by Sen. John Rafferty, R-Montgomery, likely would result in higher gasoline prices for drivers. It would also raise license and registration fees and tack a $100 surcharge onto fines for moving traffic violations.

"We're at a critical juncture. We have roads that are in disrepair, bridges that are structurally deficient and transit agencies in need," Mr. Rafferty said at a Harrisburg news conference.

Advertise with us

The condition of the state's transportation network is becoming a negative in attracting new business to Pennsylvania, he said.

PG graphic: Governor's, Senate's plans compared

(Click image for larger version)

Mr. Rafferty's proposal builds on a transportation funding measure proposed by Mr. Corbett in February that would raise up to $1.8 billion in new revenue. Lawmakers in both parties had criticized the plan as inadequate to stop deterioration of roads, fix the state's 4,400 deficient bridges and shore up ailing transit agencies.

"This is a measure that's much better than what the governor originally proposed," said Senate Democratic leader Jay Costa Jr. of Forest Hills. "We have a transportation crisis. It's directly related to the safety of our roads and bridges."

Advertise with us

The broad support for Mr. Rafferty's measure was illustrated by the large audience at his news conference, which included scores of lawmakers, including Democrats, representatives of a variety of business and labor groups, health and bicycle-pedestrian advocates and AARP members.

"We view [transportation funding] as one of the highest priorities for making Pennsylvania more competitive," said David Patti, president and CEO of the Pennsylvania Business Council.

The issue comes down to a simple cost-benefit analysis for business, he said. Detours, bad roads, delays and closed bridges cost more than an increased gas tax, he said.

Added Frank Sirianni, president of the Pennsylvania State Building & Construction Trades Council, "This is a jobs bill." Unemployment in the construction industry is around 45 percent, he said.

Mr. Rafferty estimated that the bill would generate 100,000 construction jobs and enable the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation to do capacity-adding projects: new and wider roads, highways and bridges. Currently, PennDOT spends about 95 percent of its budget on maintaining existing infrastructure.

Advertise with us

Among those on stage with Mr. Rafferty were the other three transportation committee chairs: House Republican Dick Hess of Bedford, House Democrat Michael McGeehan of Philadelphia and Senate Democrat John Wozniak of Bedford. "We share the same priority, to see that this is done," Mr. McGeehan said.

Also on hand was Transportation Secretary Barry Schoch, an appointee of the governor, who praised Mr. Rafferty for leadership on the issue but stopped short of a full embrace of the bill's various elements.

"Every company that considers coming to Pennsylvania wants to talk to me about our transportation system," he said, and many are aware of the state's road and bridge problems. "We need to make this investment. It's overdue. It's been overdue for decades."

The biggest element of both Mr. Rafferty's bill and Mr. Corbett's proposal is a removal of the cap on the tax paid by gasoline wholesalers. At present, the tax is levied on a maximum price of $1.25 per gallon. Both plans would gradually remove the cap -- Mr. Rafferty over three years, the governor over five years -- allowing the tax to be levied on the full wholesale price.

Based on current prices, a full removal of the cap would raise the tax by 28.5 cents, from 19.2 cents per gallon to 47.7 cents, some or all of which could be passed on to consumers. Both plans would trim 2 cents from a separate flat tax assessed at the pump.

Advertise with us

Unlike Mr. Corbett, the senator is proposing increases to vehicle fees that haven't been raised since 1997. The cost of registering a vehicle would go from the current $36 for one year to $104 for two years, and a driver's license that costs $29.50 and is valid for four years would cost $50.50 and be valid for six years.

Both plans would do away with the tiny license plate stickers that are mailed to registrants, clearing the way for instant online renewals.

Mr. Rafferty also proposed a $100 surcharge for moving traffic violations, with revenue directed to public transit. Also, drivers cited under a "catch-all" provision for failing to obey a traffic control device, an infraction that doesn't add points to the license, would be fined $100 to $300 instead of the current $25.

Mr. Schoch estimated the overall cost of Mr. Rafferty's legislation for a typical driver (assuming no traffic offenses) at $2.50 per week. A Pittsburgh Post-Gazette calculation showed it at just over $3 per week, based on the current gasoline wholesale price. The actual impact will depend on what happens to gasoline prices, and how much of wholesalers' added expenses are passed on to consumers.

Mr. Rafferty's bill would raise more money for transportation and do it faster than the governor's plan. It also would leave the ailing Port Authority on a "stable footing," Mr. Costa said. The authority has projected that the governor's plan would provide only two years of relief, followed by a return of multimillion-dollar deficits.

Advertise with us

A joint statement from the Allegheny Conference on Community Development and the Greater Philadelphia Chamber of Commerce praised lawmakers for "working in a true bipartisan manner" on the issue.

"On behalf of the thousands of employers that make up their membership, both the GPCC and the Allegheny Conference support legislation to raise revenue for all modes of transportation, including transit systems that are critical to the economic viability of southeastern and southwestern Pennsylvania," the groups said.

Mr. Rafferty said he hopes to have the legislation passed in June.

Jon Schmitz: jschmitz@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1868. Visit the PG's transportation blog, The Roundabout, at www.post-gazette.com/Roundabout. Twitter: @pgtraffic. Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com, 1-717-787-4254 and Twitter: @KateGiammarise.

Calling transportation investment vital to safety and the economy, the head of the state Senate Transportation Committee unveiled legislation on Tuesday that would bring in $2.5 billion per year in new revenue for roads, bridges, transit and other modes.

Advertise with us

The measure quickly drew bipartisan accolades, even as key players cautioned that work remains to fashion a final bill that can pass the Legislature and be signed by Gov. Tom Corbett.

Senate Bill 1, introduced by Sen. John Rafferty, R-Montgomery, likely would result in higher gasoline prices for drivers. It would also raise license and registration fees and tack a $100 surcharge onto fines for moving traffic violations.

"We're at a critical juncture. We have roads that are in disrepair, bridges that are structurally deficient and transit agencies in need," Mr. Rafferty said at a Harrisburg news conference.

The condition of the state's transportation network is becoming a negative in attracting new business to Pennsylvania, he said.

Mr. Rafferty's proposal builds on a transportation funding measure proposed by Mr. Corbett in February that would raise up to $1.8 billion in new revenue. Lawmakers in both parties had criticized the plan as inadequate to stop deterioration of roads, fix the state's 4,400 deficient bridges and shore up ailing transit agencies.

Advertise with us

"This is a measure that's much better than what the governor originally proposed," said Senate Democratic leader Jay Costa Jr. of Forest Hills. "We have a transportation crisis. It's directly related to the safety of our roads and bridges."

The broad support for Mr. Rafferty's measure was illustrated by the large audience at his news conference, which included scores of lawmakers, including Democrats, representatives of a variety of business and labor groups, health and bicycle-pedestrian advocates and AARP members.

"We view [transportation funding] as one of the highest priorities for making Pennsylvania more competitive," said David Patti, president and CEO of the Pennsylvania Business Council.

The issue comes down to a simple cost-benefit analysis for business, he said. Detours, bad roads, delays and closed bridges cost more than an increased gas tax, he said.

Added Frank Sirianni, president of the Pennsylvania State Building & Construction Trades Council, "This is a jobs bill." Unemployment in the construction industry is around 45 percent, he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Rafferty estimated that the bill would generate 100,000 construction jobs and enable the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation to do capacity-adding projects: new and wider roads, highways and bridges. Currently, PennDOT spends about 95 percent of its budget on maintaining existing infrastructure.

Among those on stage with Mr. Rafferty were the other three transportation committee chairs: House Republican Dick Hess of Bedford, House Democrat Michael McGeehan of Philadelphia and Senate Democrat John Wozniak of Bedford. "We share the same priority, to see that this is done," Mr. McGeehan said.

Also on hand was Transportation Secretary Barry Schoch, an appointee of the governor, who praised Mr. Rafferty for leadership on the issue but stopped short of a full embrace of the bill's various elements.

"Every company that considers coming to Pennsylvania wants to talk to me about our transportation system," he said, and many are aware of the state's road and bridge problems. "We need to make this investment. It's overdue. It's been overdue for decades."

The biggest element of both Mr. Rafferty's bill and Mr. Corbett's proposal is a removal of the cap on the tax paid by gasoline wholesalers. At present, the tax is levied on a maximum price of $1.25 per gallon. Both plans would gradually remove the cap -- Mr. Rafferty over three years, the governor over five years -- allowing the tax to be levied on the full wholesale price.

Advertise with us

Based on current prices, a full removal of the cap would raise the tax by 28.5 cents, from 19.2 cents per gallon to 47.7 cents, some or all of which could be passed on to consumers. Both plans would trim 2 cents from a separate flat tax assessed at the pump.

Unlike Mr. Corbett, the senator is proposing increases to vehicle fees that haven't been raised since 1997. The cost of registering a vehicle would go from the current $36 for one year to $104 for two years, and a driver's license that costs $29.50 and is valid for four years would cost $50.50 and be valid for six years.

Both plans would do away with the tiny license plate stickers that are mailed to registrants, clearing the way for instant online renewals.

Mr. Rafferty also proposed a $100 surcharge for moving traffic violations, with revenue directed to public transit. Also, drivers cited under a "catch-all" provision for failing to obey a traffic control device, an infraction that doesn't add points to the license, would be fined $100 to $300 instead of the current $25.

Mr. Schoch estimated the overall cost of Mr. Rafferty's legislation for a typical driver (assuming no traffic offenses) at $2.50 per week. A Pittsburgh Post-Gazette calculation showed it at just over $3 per week, based on the current gasoline wholesale price. The actual impact will depend on what happens to gasoline prices, and how much of wholesalers' added expenses are passed on to consumers.

Advertise with us

Mr. Rafferty's bill would raise more money for transportation and do it faster than the governor's plan. It also would leave the ailing Port Authority on a "stable footing," Mr. Costa said. The authority has projected that the governor's plan would provide only two years of relief, followed by a return of multimillion-dollar deficits.

A joint statement from the Allegheny Conference on Community Development and the Greater Philadelphia Chamber of Commerce praised lawmakers for "working in a true bipartisan manner" on the issue.

"On behalf of the thousands of employers that make up their membership, both the GPCC and the Allegheny Conference support legislation to raise revenue for all modes of transportation, including transit systems that are critical to the economic viability of southeastern and southwestern Pennsylvania," the groups said.

Mr. Rafferty said he hopes to have the legislation passed in June.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.