Defense attorneys suggested that a prosecution witness had a grudge against Sen. Jane Orie because the senator had confronted her over money missing from a fund for 9/11 victims.
William Costopoulos, attorney for the senator, and James DePasquale, who represents her sister, Janine Orie, tried to raise questions on the credibility of several former staffers on a day when the jury heard still more testimony from former Orie employees that political work was a routine part of their duties in the Republican's offices in the North Hills and in the state Capitol.
Barbara Brown, who worked in the Harrisburg office from 2001 until 2004, and again for a short period in 2008, was one of five former Orie aides who told the jury Friday that she had performed a variety of political chores for the senator on state time. She said that in 2003, she had spent "a good 50 percent" of her work day, between May and November, on the unsuccessful high court campaign of Justice Joan Orie Melvin, who was eventually elected to the court in 2009.
"Joan's a priority; take care of Joan," she said, recalling her standing instructions in the months before the 2003 election.
Ms. Brown, like other witnesses, said that throughout her tenure on the senator's staff, she spent between 30 and 40 percent of her time on fundraising, record keeping and other campaign activity for the senator.
The defense presented an uncashed check for $325 from Ms. Brown to the Hearts of Steel fund, a charity established by Sen. Orie to raise money to honor the victims of the 9/11 attacks.
"How much money did you take from Hearts of Steel?" Mr. Costopoulos demanded in a brief, tense cross-examination of Ms. Brown.
"None," she replied
She explained that the $325 check, which turned up at some point in a drawer of the senator's North Hills office, had been for bracelets that she and her husband had purchased.
Mr. DePasquale echoed the attack.
"It was money taken by you," he asserted. "Your got caught and had to pay back $325. That's what happened, isn't it?"
"No," she replied.
The defense also presented a 2003 e-mail from Sen. Orie to then Judge Melvin in which she warned the jurist against accepting volunteer help from Ms. Brown.
"I know Barb has volunteered to work on your judicial campaign and that worries me very much," it said, adding that Ms. Brown's work performance had deteriorated, "since I confronted her about stealing money from Hearts of Steel."
Lawrence Claus, the prosecutor, contended, however, that that depiction was at odds with the fact that Ms. Orie had continued to employ Ms. Brown for many months after the reported confrontation and had, in fact, rehired her for her staff four years later.
Ms. Brown and Ginger Hope, former senior aide, gave similar descriptions of the work atmosphere of the Capitol office, one in which staffers routinely prepared fund-raising lists and solicited contributions from lobbyists. Ms. Hope said that in the days before Ms. Orie's annual fundraising event in Harrisburg, it was the main focus of her work day.
"Was she aware of it? Yes," she said of the senator's knowledge of the mixing of politics and legislative work.
The defense presented one exchange between two staffers describing fund-raising activities and sent on a state e-mail account.
"You two need to be smarter," Ms. Orie wrote in a handwritten notation. It admonished them to use private e-mail accounts in discussing the subject and to make sure that fund-raising calls were made after hours in a campaign office near the Capitol, rather than in her official office.
Earlier Friday, the jurors heard from three former district office staffers, each of whom left the senator's employ under unhappy circumstances.
Sharon Cochran described earning comp time for work by chauffeuring Judge Melvin to a campaign event in Johnstown.
She was followed to the stand by her son, Jason Davidek, who said that during the 2003 campaign, he drove Judge Melvin across the state on roughly 20 separate campaign appearances, and had been rewarded with comp time from his official duties. In all, he said, he spent approximately 30 percent of his time on political work.
Mr. Costopoulos presented evidence that Mr. Davidek had been reimbursed by the Melvin campaign for just three trips, suggesting he had exaggerated the number of events he had attended with the judge.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.