HARRISBURG -- Lawyers for former House Democratic Whip Mike Veon claim he and a former aide deserve a new trial because one juror in their corruption trial became ill during jury deliberations and had to be replaced by an alternate.

Attorney Joel Sansone, representing Mr. Veon, who is now in state prison after being found guilty of political corruption charges, and attorney Michael Palermo, representing former Veon aide Annamarie Perretta-Rosepink, asked Dauphin County Common Pleas Judge Richard Lewis Monday to throw out their convictions and order a new trial.

Senior Deputy Attorney General Frank Fina strongly objected to the request, saying the seating of the alternate juror, and a new start to deliberations by the reconstituted jury, was something that defense lawyers had agreed to. He claimed it's far too late for the defense now to say their clients were somehow prejudiced by the substitution of an alternate juror for one of the original 12.

Mr. Sansone, who participated in the hearing by phone, admitted that in hindsight, the defense probably erred in agreeing to seat the alternate juror, who had to be recalled after being sent home when the trial ended. Mr. Sansone went so far as to call it "ineffectiveness" by defense counsel.

Advertise with us

But Mr. Fina said mistakes by defense lawyers aren't sufficient cause for a mistrial.

At the time the original juror became ill, the jury had begun deliberating its verdict after listening to evidence and testimony for seven weeks this spring, and the prosecution didn't want to have to do the whole thing over again.

Mr. Veon, a former Beaver County legislator, wasn't at the Monday hearing because he is serving a 6- to 14-year sentence at a state prison in Somerset County. Ms. Perretta-Rosepink was present because she is out on bail during the appeal.

The defense also contended that the two defendants worked hard for their state-paid salaries, and any political campaigning that was done by the Veon office staff occurred on aides' private or personal time, not on state time.

Mr. Sansone said Mr. Veon was probably the "hardest working legislator" in the General Assembly. But Mr. Fina said Mr. Veon's work habits were irrelevant to the charges against him, noting Mr. Veon had been found guilty of "illegally using state resources for his own campaign purposes."

Judge Lewis said he would consider the defense arguments and rule within 120 days. If a new trial is denied -- and Mr. Sansone said he expects the judge to deny the request -- the defense can then appeal to state Superior Court.