Once again, a remote district in Appalachia's steel-and-coal belt declined to behave as predicted, opting to be less a mirror of national mood than a window into a unique corner of America.

Now analysts on both sides are struggling to identify precisely what happened in the sprawling 12th District, where Democratic candidate Mark Critz ran up an eight-point spread over Republican Tim Burns in the race to succeed the late John Murtha.

GOP strategists are spinning the outcome as a quirk of turnout driven by Democrats suddenly eager to vote in a hotly contested Senate race between Arlen Specter and the man who unseated him, Joe Sestak.

"I think people did show up to vote for Sestak. It was the Democrats that were never in our target universe," said Kent Gates, who consulted for the Republicans in the 12th.

Advertise with us

"They're saying it was the Democratic Senate primary and yadda yadda," retorted Mike Mikus, a South Fayette native who managed the Critz campaign. "But as a share of the electorate, Republicans made up a larger share of this election than in 2008 in the general election."

That 2008 general election gave the often quirky 12th, with its 2-to-1 Democratic registration margin, not to Democrat Barack Obama but to Republican presidential candidate John McCain.

Those 2008 numbers, coupled with the 12th's profile as a seedbed of conservative, anti-abortion, pro-gun labor Democrats, raised hopes that the GOP could wrest control of a congressional seat that had been in Democratic hands since the Nixon administration.

It was the Nixon administration that, presumably, was supposed to receive auguries from the 12th in February 1974. At that time, Mr. Murtha, a Democratic state assemblyman, was pitted against Republican Harry Fox in a contest to succeed the late Republican John P. Saylor. The national mood had been churned by Nixon's firing of Watergate special prosecutor Archibald Cox and both national parties and major media turned to the Conemaugh Valley for a foreshadowing of the president's fate.

The Murtha margin was a mere 122 votes in a decidedly Democratic district. Each side spent more time pushing theories of job development and the economy and eschewed talk of Watergate.

Advertise with us

No such symmetry emerged in the latest special vote in the 12th.

Mr. Critz, former economic development aide to Mr. Murtha, pushed hard on the issue of jobs creation and economic development all the while positioning himself in the Murtha mold as an opponent of abortion and gun control, a self-described conservative Democrat.

Mr. Burns fashioned a campaign that linked Mr. Critz to an unpopular administration, invoking President Obama and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi at almost every stop. Each side slathered the other with a vat of mud, the Critz forces suggesting Mr. Burns somehow favored tax breaks to ship American jobs overseas, the Burns camp blaming Mr. Critz for the greenhouse gas cap-and-trade bill, even though he had yet to hold office.

"In what other congressional district would you have the Democrat candidate saying they were pro-life and pro-gun?" demanded John Brabender, the Pittsburgh-based consultant who handled media for the Republicans.

In many ways, Mr. Gates said, the Burns campaign had no room to maneuver on traditional hot-button issues because the two men held virtually identical positions. Hence, it remained for Mr. Burns to fashion a message tapping into national sentiment while Mr. Critz played on the issue of jobs and, by extension, his connection with a late congressman who had been credited with creating many of them in his hometown.

Advertise with us

"They ran a national campaign in a district where it doesn't work," said Mr. Mikus, the Critz manager.

Mr. Mikus rejects the idea of the Sestak-Specter race becoming an unexpected get-out-the-vote drive for his man. Republicans, though, are certain of it.

As last week wore down, officials at the House Republican Campaign Committee sent pollster Gene Ulm back into the field in the 12th District to sort through results that upended his earlier polls that put the race at a dead heat.

What Mr. Ulm did was to re-interview 50 Democratic voters in Greene County who had earlier said they were leaning toward the Republican, Mr. Burns. Those early poll numbers gave credence to the idea that the 12th was a bellwether of national voter ire with the Obama administration and a Democratic Congress that had pushed through two programs especially disliked among the senior-heavy district in the midst of coal country: health care reform and carbon emission cap-and-trade.

What Mr. Ulm found was that 75 percent of those Greene County Democrats who were leaning toward Burns did in fact vote for the Republican.

Advertise with us

The deduction was that the middle-right Democrats of the district stayed with Mr. Burns, but that harder-line Democrats, more likely to lean center-left, turned out and drove up the numbers because they wanted to vote out Mr. Specter in the Senate primary.

"Anybody who's a hard-core Democrat who was energized to vote because they wanted to get rid of Specter? We were never in the game of getting them," Mr. Gates said.

Much like the 1974 Murtha-Fox contest, last week's special election also produced two candidates for a full term. In November 1974, Mr. Murtha won by a handy margin over Mr. Fox after each man took his party's primary.

Whether history proves destiny remains to be seen. National dollars and attention are likely to turn to other contests, including the Senate race between Mr. Sestak and Republican nominee Patrick Toomey.

Mr. Gates believes a different cohort of voters, including more of the swing Democrats he was hoping for last week, will turn out in November.

Advertise with us

"We can get our turnout model up to a level where we can win this thing," he said.

Not so fast, Mr. Mikus said. The Republican nominee still will be the man turned back at the polls May 18.

"Mark was focused on creating jobs in the 12th, and Tim Burns was obsessed with Washington," Mr. Mikus said. "He's not going to be able to turn around 51/2 months later and pretend he's somebody he's not."