WASHINGTON, Pa. -- Ken Bonnell was, possibly, the walking emblem of the cranky voter of 2010: sporting a sticker for a Democratic congressional candidate and voicing his anger at his party's signature legislative accomplishment.

"What about health reform?" he asked, staring at Sen. Bob Casey. "What about that $500 million you guys took off Medicare?"

Mr. Casey was on a swing through the 12th Congressional District to stump for Mark Critz, his party's nominee to succeed the late John P. Murtha. Outside, a group of home-schooled volunteers, some from as far away as Schuylkill County, chanted for Republican nominee Tim Burns. One or two carried signs denouncing "Obamacare" -- the term opponents use to describe the administration's health care reform bill.

Mr. Casey nodded politely.

Advertise with us

"As people start to see the implementation of it, the animosity is going to diminish," he said. "I think it's a short-term problem, politically."

The problem is that, in the shorter term, voters go to the polls today and, from health care reform to a general surliness toward Washington, government and authority in general, the atmosphere is fogged with discontent.

In addition to threatening to reverse a 36-year legacy of Democratic rule in the 12th District, the seat held until his February death by the legendary John P. Murtha, primary voters today could conceivably retire the state's longest serving United States senator, as Democratic convert Arlen Specter struggles against a primary challenge from Rep. Joe Sestak.

Mr. Sestak was in Pittsburgh Monday for a round of closing arguments to the voters. The retired admiral wore an olive jacket with the patch of the U.S.S. George Washington Battle Group -- one of his Navy commands, as he fielded questions in a Highland Park coffee shop.

"His time has come and gone," he said of his opponent. "Thirty years in Washington and look at the mess we're in."

Advertise with us

One prospective voter asked him whether, if he lost, he would support Mr. Specter in the general election. Mr. Sestak wouldn't yield to the premise of the question, refusing to concede the possibility of defeat. But assured the morning crowd that, "I would do anything, ethically, morally, to defeat Pat Toomey."

Mr. Specter had made his last southwestern Pennsylvania appearance the previous night, telling a Pitcairn rally that he had risked his political career to further the agenda of the Obama administration. Mr. Specter also continued to characterize himself the stronger Democrat against Mr. Toomey, the likely GOP nominee.

Mr. Sestak scoffed at that assertion Monday. Citing poll numbers suggesting the incumbent's vulnerability, he declared that, "Arlen Specter can't beat Pat Toomey."

The latest Quinnipiac University survey mirrored the final Muhlenberg College tracking poll in finding a virtual tie in the Senate race. The Quinnipiac numbers, apparently the last batch of public data from an oft-polled contest, had Mr. Sestak at 42 percent and the incumbent at 41 percent, a result well within the survey 3.2 percent margin of error.

How might tonight's numbers contrast with that snapshot?

Advertise with us

In a race this close the logistics of turnout operations could be pivotal. Mr. Specter, with the support of the state Democratic establishment and most of the state's unions, inherited a ready-made Election Day apparatus. Mr. Sestak had to build one from scratch. Mr. Specter is hoping for a disproportionately heavy turnout from Philadelphia, particularly in the African-American wards where, polls suggest, he had heavy support.

The turnout models of the polling samples also assume that today's turnout will follow the traditional pattern of a steep drop off sharply from the levels of 2008's presidential year. The Democratic establishment and its ally, Organizing for America, the successor to the Obama presidential campaign, are trying to prod as many of the first-time 2008 voters to show up at the polls today. If they are successful to any significant degree, that could confound the turnout assumptions of the public polls.

Gov. Ed Rendell, one of Mr. Specter's most loyal allies, is hoping to drive the kind of unusually high Philadelphia numbers that carried him to a wide victory against Bob Casey in the 2002 Democratic primary for governor. Weeks ago, the governor was still predicting that his Philadelphia neighbor would clobber his challenger. More recently, he has softened those expectations.

In an MSNBC interview Monday, he sidestepped host Joe Scarborough's challenge to guarantee a Specter victory.

"You tell me what the weather is going to be and I'll tell you whether we can guarantee it or not," Mr. Rendell said. Calling it a "very close race," he added, "Arlen needs a good turnout from the southeast and the city of Philadelphia. It's supposed to rain here tomorrow and that's not a good sign."

Advertise with us

On the Republican side, neither weather nor turnout armies seemed likely to have much of an impact on the Senate sweepstakes. Mr. Toomey, the former Lehigh Valley congressman whose candidacy drove Mr. Specter from the Republican Party, is a heavy favorite over Peg Luksik, a conservative activist from Johnstown.

State Attorney General Tom Corbett is similarly the odds-on favorite for the GOP nomination for governor, but analysts will scrutinize his margins for signs of an insurgency from his party's right wing. Rep. Sam Rohrer, R-Berks, has tried to portray himself as the more authentic conservative and, like Mrs. Luksik, is hoping for a boost from the energy of the state's various tea party groups.

On the Democratic side, Allegheny County Executive Dan Onorato remained well ahead in the Quinnipiac survey, but his lead was tempered by a persistently high proportion of undecided Democrats. Mr. Onorato had the support of 39 percent of the Democrats Quinnipiac deemed most likely to vote, followed by state Sen. Anthony Williams, with 11 percent; Auditor General Jack Wagner, 10 percent; and Montgomery County Commissioner Joe Hoeffel, 9 percent.

Mr. Williams is the only Democrat who has had the resources to challenge Mr. Onorato on the airwaves. But Mr. Onorato built his fundraising advantage over years. By contrast, the Philadelphia state senator stunned the state's political world by raising more than $5 million in weeks from less than a handful of wealthy contributors,

Mr. Williams had the resources for a robust advertising campaign and is also expected to pour money into a vigorous turnout effort today in his Philadelphia base -- an effort that could also prove crucial to Mr. Specter.

Advertise with us

The contest in the 12th has become a proxy fight for the two parties as they wrestle for control of the national agenda. Long a safe seat that continued to return Mr. Murtha to the House on the strength of his ability to deliver federal dollars to the struggling region, it came into play in February when the 19-term Democrat died after gallbladder surgery.

Party leaders selected their nominees. In the case of the Democrats, the party's state executive board chose Mr. Critz, 48, the economic development director for Mr. Murtha.

On the Republican side, a party convention selected Mr. Burns, 42, a self-made software millionaire.

Additionally, both Mr. Critz and Mr. Burns face opponents in the Democratic primary, which is being held on the same ballot as the election to fill Mr. Murtha's unexpired term. While Mr. Critz appears to have no strong opposition, Mr. Burns faces a better-financed Republican primary opponent in Bill Russell, a retired Army officer who moved to the district two years ago to mount a well-organized challenge to Mr. Murtha.

Republicans also waged sharply contested congressional primaries in the 3rd and 4th Congressional districts, two Western Pennsylvania seats north of Pittsburgh. Former U.S. Attorney Mary Beth Buchanan was in an acrimonious race with Keith Rothfus for the right to challenge Rep. Jason Altmire in the 4th, while in the 3rd, six Republicans vied to challenge Rep. Kathy Dahlkemper, D-Erie, a freshman lawmaker.

Advertise with us

Mr. Critz Monday focused his message on jobs and economic development in the district, which has unemployment rates hovering just around the average.

He brought in Mr. Casey as well as Jon Bauman, better known as Bowzer from the '50s revival group Sha Na Na, for visits to a hotdog shop, a diner and, Monday night, the Italian Club in Monessen.

The campaign also unveiled a mailer from Mr. Murtha's widow, Joyce, endorsing him.

"While nobody can ever fill Jack Murtha's shoes, I know that Mark Critz will continue Jack's tireless work on behalf of Western Pennsylvania," she declares in the mailer that went out over the weekend.

Mr. Burns has taken the tack of running against Washington -- a move that has seen him rise in the polls in an anti-incumbent year.

"This race has come to represent what direction this country is going to take. Are we going to continue down the direction Obama and Pelosi want to take us or are we going to put the brakes on?" Mr. Burns asked Monday night, en route to an evening appearance at the Richland Fire Hall in suburban Johnstown.