Tuesday's balloting will indelibly color the legacies of Pennsylvania's longest-serving senator and its longest-serving congressman.
Sen. Arlen Specter, seeking his sixth term and his first as a Democrat, is trying to extend a record tenure in the Senate in the face of a challenge from Rep. Joe Sestak. Mr. Specter roiled state and national politics a year ago when he switched parties, unwilling, as he said, to submit his re-election to a jury of Republican primary voters. Mr. Sestak, a retired admiral and two-term congressman, is betting his political future on the premise that a Democratic jury won't be much more willing to give Mr. Specter a favorable verdict.
The voters in Western Pennsylvania's 12th Congressional District will write a posthumous final chapter in the career of Rep. John P. Murtha, who became the state's longest-serving congressman just days before his death set the stage for the special election to fill the balance of his term.
Will they honor Mr. Murtha's long shadow by electing his chief aide, Mark Critz? Or will they turn their backs on the seat's Democratic heritage and buoy national GOP hopes by choosing conservative Republican Tim Burns?
A Burns victory would be seized nationally as a sequel to Sen. Scott Brown's Massachusetts upset as evidence that 2010 will be a year of Republican resurgence. While Mr. Murtha had a secure hold on the district for a generation, it has been trending Republican in presidential and statewide elections. Sen John Kerry won it by only about 8,000 votes; President Barack Obama lost by just over 1,000.
Given the stakes of perception, national Democratic and Republican committees and a variety of outside interests have invested heavily in the outcome. Mr. Brown himself campaigned for Mr. Burns Friday. Former President Bill Clinton was scheduled to headline a rally for Mr. Critz in the late congressman's Johnstown home today.
It is probably unprecedented for a contest for governor to be only the third-most prominent political story in the state. Gubernatorial nominees will loom larger in post-primary coverage as the state debates painful choices imposed by a yawning budget gap. But for now, the chief national focus is on a neck-and-neck Senate race and a special election viewed as a harbinger for November's overall battle for Congressional control.
Crucial races
Mr. Specter's conversion to the Democratic Party, after his crucial support for President Obama's stimulus legislation, won the embrace of his new party's hierarchy, but its rank-and-file remains in play. Poll results in the last two weeks have bounced around within their margins for error as the incumbent has been battered by a Sestak ad reminding Democrats of his past allegiance to the Bush administration, along with the tactical calculation behind his party switch.
Mr. Specter has countered with an ad showcasing Mr. Obama's praise for him along with a serial effort, in a seemingly anti-incumbent climate, to turn the focus back to his challenger. He has attacked Mr. Sestak's congressional attendance record and questioned the circumstances surrounding the end of the retired admiral's 30-year career in the Navy. Mr. Specter's institutional support within the party and the labor movement are crucial to his hopes for victory, just as his White House support was crucial in 2004 in helping him across the GOP primary finish line just ahead of former Rep. Pat Toomey.
Mr. Toomey had been considering a run for governor this year when Mr. Specter's stimulus vote persuaded him to run again for the Senate. He is considered a heavy favorite for the GOP nomination over Johnstown activist Peg Luksik.
Mr. Specter appeared in Philadelphia with Gov. Ed Rendell Friday and Saturday, touting his record of delivering federal dollars to the state and criticizing his rival over the searing commercial in which the Sestak campaign charges that he changed parties to save his job.
In a bid for last-minute support, Mr. Specter planned to appear tonight in Pitcairn with his colleague, Sen. Bob Casey.
In Lawrenceville Saturday, Mr. Sestak spoke in front of the Goddess of Victory statue in Leslie Park and said of his veteran opponent, "His time has come and gone."
Mocking a misstep this week when Mr. Specter twice thanked "Allegheny County Republicans" while speaking to the county's Democratic party, Mr. Sestak said, "You've got to wake up in the morning and know who you are."
Raising money
A few hours earlier and a few miles away, Allegheny County Executive Dan Onorato opened his Saturday with a hand-shaking tour of the Strip District. Polls continue to anoint him the favorite in the Democratic governor's primary. His former Pittsburgh Council colleague, Jack Wagner, is far behind Mr. Onorato in fundraising and polling, but his landslide re-election as auditor general and his wide contacts within the state Democratic Party continue to fuel his hopes for an upset.
Montgomery County Commissioner Joe Hoeffel, who also lags in fundraising, argues that his record is most in sync with the party's liberal base. The candidacy of state Sen. Anthony Williams represents perhaps the biggest surprise in the Democratic race because of his late entry and startlingly robust fundraising.
Pennsylvania has no limits on campaign contributions in state elections. With the six-figure checks of a handful of financiers supporting his advocacy of school choice, Mr. Williams managed to raise millions in a matter of weeks, making him the only Democrat who has come close to competing with Mr. Onorato on the airwaves.
The Philadelphian flexed his financial and media muscles again over the weekend, airing his third ad attacking the front-runner -- this time criticizing his support for the county's drink tax and linking Mr. Onorato to the Port Authority's North Shore Connector, a project the ad derides as a "half-billion-dollar boondoggle."
As he greeted passers-by on sunny Penn Avenue, Mr. Onorato dismissed the commercial. "It doesn't seem to be having any impact," he added, referring to the consistent leads he has maintained since his own heavy advertising began to take effect.
As he trolled for votes in and out of the food stores lining the busy Strip, Mr. Onorato received an almost uniformly friendly reception. Inside the Pennsylvania Macaroni Company, however, Bill Sunseri offered a good-natured challenge: "You going to get rid of that alcohol tax?"
The Democratic nominee is expected to face Attorney General Tom Corbett in November. The Shaler resident, who has amassed indictments, convictions and headlines with prosecutions of political corruption, is far ahead of Rep. Sam Rohrer of Berks County in all polling. The Republican state committee endorsed Mr. Corbett.
At the same time, the GOP officials voted to back Bucks County Commissioner James Cawley as his unofficial running mate. In Pennsylvania, lieutenant governor candidates run separately in the primary but are teamed with the gubernatorial nominee in the general election.
This year, eight other contenders have joined Mr. Cawley to make it a free-for-all. Among them is state Rep. Daryl Metcalfe, the Butler County conservative and outspoken advocate of curbs on immigration, and Jean Craige Pepper of Erie, the only woman in the big GOP field.
On the Democratic side, former Philadelphia Controller Jonathan Saidel is competing against former Commonwealth Court Judge Doris Smith-Ribner and state Rep. Scott Conklin of Centre County.
Regional contests
The 12th District special election has dominated the congressional spotlight, but both parties have competitive primaries there for the full term that begins next year. Republican candidates are also vying in primaries in two adjacent districts, hoping to take on Rep. Kathy Dahlkemper, D-Erie, in the 3rd District, and Rep. Jason Altmire, D-McCandless, in the 4th District.
In a year in which incumbents in general and Harrisburg in particular are notoriously unpopular, it is perhaps surprising but entirely routine that the vast majority of state House members are unopposed.
In the 19th legislative district, Rep. Jake Wheatley, D-Hill District, is being challenged by Tonya Payne, the former city council member, and Mark Brentley, a member of the Pittsburgh city school board.
In the neighboring seat opened with the resignation of former Rep. Don Walko, Adam Ravenstahl -- brother of Mayor Luke Ravenstahl -- is both the Democratic nominee in a special election and the party's endorsed candidate in a concurrent primary for the subsequent full term. Alex Dubart of Reserve is the Republican nominee in a race in which, given the district's political history, the Democrat is all but assured of prevailing.
In the primary, his opponents are Dan Keller of Brighton Heights, Tim Tuinstra of Observatory Hill and Mark Purcell of Ross.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.