The hotly disputed, neck-and-neck race for the late U.S. Rep. John Murtha's 12th District congressional seat escalated a notch Friday when a Pittsburgh television station pulled a Democratic ad that Republicans claimed was "demonstrably false."

Sinclair Broadcasting's local affiliate, WPGH Fox 53, suspended the 30-second ad by the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee.

The ad "falsely claims Tim Burns supports a 23 percent national sales tax and wants to ship jobs overseas," said Kent Gates, a political adviser to Mr. Burns, a Republican, who is vying with Democrat Mark Critz in a special election Tuesday for Mr. Murtha's seat.

Sinclair officials did not return calls for comment, while two other Pittsburgh stations, KDKA and WPXI, said they had no plans to pull the ad. Officials at a third station, WTAE, could not be reached for comment.

Advertise with us

Sinclair Broadcasting is no stranger to charges of political partisanship. In 2004, it ordered its stations to broadcast a documentary critical of John Kerry the month before the 2004 presidential election, prompting a firestorm of protest from Democrats.

Sinclair's decision to suspend the ad triggered a flurry of competing news releases Friday by the national Republican and Democratic congressional campaign committees, who have poured large amounts of money -- $1.7 million, combined -- into the special election to represent the heavily Democratic but socially conservative, blue-collar district.

Nationally, political analysts regard the race between Mr. Burns, a 42-year-old businessman who lives in Eighty Four, and Mr. Critz, a 48-year-old former aide to Mr. Murtha who lives in Johnstown, as an important bellwether for the fall midterm elections. It could also signal whether there will be voter backlash to the party in power and to President Barack Obama's health care law.

Sensing an opportunity to gain a seat that's been in Democratic hands since 1974, the Republicans have brought their party's stars in to campaign for Mr. Burns, including Massachusetts Republican Sen. Scott Brown, who joined Mr. Burns Friday for a rally on the steps of the Washington County Courthouse, while the Democrats are bringing former President Bill Clinton in for Mr. Critz tomorrow.

The high stakes in this race have been reflected in a series of fairly intense attack ads run by both sides. In this instance, Mr. Gates said the campaign asked the stations to pull the ad because Mr. Critz "had already apologized" at a Johnstown candidates' forum April 28th for claiming Mr. Burns supported the tax.

Advertise with us

"If he really is sorry, Critz should stop the smears and call on his Washington-based backers to do the same," Mr. Gates said, noting that FactCheck.org, a respected online site which analyzes political advertising, characterized the ad as misleading.

Actually, FactCheck posted a story on its site today that characterized both campaigns as running ads that are "chock full of false and misleading claims."

Still, the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee's current ad, which began running in Pittsburgh and Johnstown media markets May 12, was misleading, FactCheck said, because "it fails to mention that the FairTax proposal would also repeal the federal income tax entirely and do away with the Internal Revenue Service.

It would also eliminate gift, estate, capital gains, alternative minimum, Social Security, Medicare and self-employment taxes. But anyone viewing the DCCC's ad could easily conclude that Burns favored slapping a 23 percent sales tax on top of all existing taxes, which is not true."

At last month's forum, Mr. Critz claimed Mr. Burns had signed a pledge to support the FairTax, which would impose a national consumption tax on retail sales that proponents say would be 23 percent. In fact, Mr. Critz had erroneously referred to the no-tax-increase pledge sponsored by Americans for Tax Reform, an aide later said, and when he realized his mistake, he apologized toward the end of the forum.

Advertise with us

"If I've misstated Mr. Burns' position on something, I apologize," Mr. Critz said. "I didn't mean to do that, it's my understanding he did support the FairTax and if that's wrong I apologize."

Station managers at KDKA and WPXI noted that they rarely agree to pull ads by political campaigns.

"These spots are routinely challenged, almost every spot, on either side," said Christopher Pike, general manager of KDKA. "It's fairly typical behavior."

And in the days leading up to an election, "typically there are complaints on both sides when campaigns get negative," said Ray Carter, WPXI's general manager. "But rather than get into possible First Amendment issues, we prefer to let the voters decide."

At the rally for Mr. Burns Friday, Mr. Brown -- who won the late Sen. Edward Kennedy's seat in a special election in December -- seemed to revel in his role as a spoiler, pointing to similarities between himself and Mr. Burns, who, he said, was "an outsider, who's not beholden to any special interests, who will be an independent thinker."

Advertise with us

During his four months in "the other Washington," Mr. Brown said, he has learned "the out-of-control spending is real. ... And you have a very real choice and a very real chance to send a message to Washington that says 'We've had enough.' "

Mr. Burns -- who was also was joined by Attorney General Tom Corbett, the Republican candidate for governor, and U.S. Rep. Bill Shuster, R-Altoona -- dismissed experts who had called him as "a long-shot candidate." He pointed to Mr. Brown as evidence that "this conservative movement is for real" and described the 12th District race as "a referendum on the liberal Obama-Pelosi agenda."

"America is on the wrong track," he told a crowd of about 100 people. "This year, we can take the next step in taking our country back."