HARRISBURG -- The lieutenant governor doesn't have a lot of power in state government. He or she gets a spiffy office at the Capitol and a house with a swimming pool, presides over the state Senate and a couple other agencies and handles whatever other tasks the governor assigns.
But the job's low profile and lack of clout haven't stopped a stampede of candidates from running for it in Tuesday's primary election. There are nine Republicans and three Democrats on the ballot.
"It's the Manhattan phone book running for lieutenant governor," quipped Charlie Gerow, a Republican political strategist here.
Bucks County Commissioner Jim Cawley, arguably the GOP favorite, has been endorsed by the Republican State Committee and thus has party resources. His literature says he's running as a "team" with Attorney General Tom Corbett, the leading Republican gubernatorial candidate.
But Mr. Cawley, who is a Philadelphia attorney, is being vigorously challenged in the primary, especially by Lancaster businessman Chet Beiler, who lost a 2008 race for auditor general but is pouring a lot of his own money into this contest.
Other Republicans include:
• State Rep. Daryl Metcalfe of Cranberry, an outspoken conservative who wants Pennsylvania to empower police to crack down on illegal immigrants, as Arizona is doing. Mr. Metcalfe is running for both the No. 2 spot and for re-election to the state House.
• Russ Diamond of Lebanon County, who got much attention in 2005-06 as the head of PA Clean Sweep, which fought to overturn the legislative pay raise.
• Jean Craige Pepper of Erie, a one-time candidate for state treasurer and the only female in the GOP race, whose campaign slogans are "The best man for this job is a woman" and "Pick a pepper at the poll."
• Former state Rep. John Kennedy of Cumberland County, who also was sharply critical of the 2005 legislative pay raise.
• York businessman Steve Johnson, a political rookie who calls himself a "populist" and the "voice of the people" and said he wouldn't take a state pension if elected.
• Luzerne County Commissioner Steve Urban of Wilkes-Barre, who is also hedging his bets; besides this race, he's also seeking the GOP nomination for the state Senate, a seat being vacated by Sen. Ray Musto.
• Billy McCue, who describes himself as an independent entrepreneur who develops games for the Apple iPhone; he grew up in Brentwood and now lives in Carroll Township, Washington County; years ago he lost a race for the state House to former Rep. Richard Olasz.
The Democrats in Tuesday's primary include two-term state Rep. Scott Conklin, who is a former Centre County commissioner, and two Philadelphians -- former city Controller Jonathan Saidel, who has the endorsement of the state party and of Gov. Ed Rendell, and former Commonwealth Court Judge Doris Smith-Ribner.
Muhlenberg College political pollster Christopher Borick said last week that even though the primary is only four days away, the lieutenant governor competitors still aren't well known to most voters.
"It's been hard for these candidates to get attention in a year when even the candidates for governor have been struggling to become known," he added.
One reason for the gaggle of Republican candidates is the feeling in the party that it's due to take over power in Harrisburg -- after eight years of Democratic rule under Mr. Rendell.
"Clearly, Republicans believe that 2010 is their year," Mr. Gerow said. "At one point earlier this year, there were something like 15 candidates for lieutenant governor, but some have dropped out."
Why is the GOP optimistic?
"It's a perfect storm," Mr. Gerow said. "There is a huge national reaction against the Obama administration, a backlash against the large state spending that has gone on in the state over the past eight years and a general anti-incumbent mood."
There's also the fact that the governor's office has changed parties every eight years since the mid-1940s. In 2002, when Democrats figured it was their turn, nine Democratic candidates ran for lieutenant governor, the winner being Catherine Baker Knoll of McKees Rocks.
A poll last week by Quinnipiac University is already matching up Mr. Corbett against the four Democratic gubernatorial candidates. Mr. Corbett was six points or more ahead of them, another factor giving the GOP optimism.
Mr. Metcalfe is the only GOP lieutenant governor hopeful with much name recognition in southwestern Pennsylvania. One of his campaign promises is virtually unprecedented. He is vowing to criticize his own boss -- the next Republican governor, if the GOP wins in November -- whenever Mr. Metcalfe thinks such criticism is warranted.
For example, if either Mr. Corbett or his challenger on Tuesday, state Rep. Sam Rohrer, is elected in November and then reneges on a no-tax-increase pledge (which they both have made), Mr. Metcalfe will publicly criticize the governor. For a lieutenant governor to do that is unheard of and would create an awkward situation at the Capitol.
"Mr. Metcalfe has made his name in state politics by not being subtle in either his rhetoric or policy positions," Mr. Borick said.
Mr. Metcalfe is also trying to get attention by advocating that state and local police become active in checking for undocumented immigrants who have come to the U.S. illegally. Mr. Metcalfe complains they're costing state taxpayers millions of dollars annually in food stamps, welfare and other costs. He is getting support from conservative groups for this stand.
Having Mr. Cawley as the lieutenant governor candidate would give the GOP ticket geographical balance, since Mr. Corbett is from Shaler. While the other candidates don't admit that Mr. Cawley is the front-runner, he's attracting a lot of attacks by his competitors, especially Mr. Beiler.
Mr. Beiler, who runs a gazebo-making firm called Amish Country Gazebos, has a humorous TV spot in which an elderly woman (played by an actress) is complaining about property taxes in Bucks County.
"Because of that Jim Cawley, I have to pay such high property taxes, I can't afford to feed my cat any more," the fake voter complains in the ad.
Most of the candidates are vowing to "reform" Harrisburg, which is still suffering from the 2005 pay raise scandal, the ongoing Bonusgate trials and seven years of late budgets. But Mr. Diamond, the former Clean Sweep leader from Lebanon County, contends he would be the best reform candidate, having bucked the legislative establishment over the pay raise.
On the Democratic side, Mr. Conklin may have an advantage because he is the only non-Philadelphian. Antipathy toward Philadelphia politicians among many voters in the central and western areas of the state is likely to benefit him.
Mr. Saidel would benefit if there were a large turnout in the southeast for Sen. Arlen Specter, who is in a tough re-election race, and for state Sen. Anthony Williams, one of the four Democratic gubernatorial candidates. But Mr. Conklin could benefit if the Democratic vote in Philadelphia and its suburbs were divided between Mr. Saidel and Judge Ribner-Smith.
Mr. Conklin, a two-term state legislator after being a Centre County commissioner from 1999 to 2006, has been endorsed by some large newspapers, such as the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and the Philadelphia Inquirer.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.