Marcellus shale, state taxes and term limits have emerged as top issues this year in the battle for the 48th District legislative seat being left vacant by state Rep. Tim Solobay, D-Canonsburg, who is seeking a state Senate seat.
There is no lack of interest in the seat, which spans several large municipalities in Washington County, including the city of Washington, Canonsburg, North Strabane and South Strabane. The district also is home to the Meadows Racetrack & Casino.
On the Democratic ticket for Tuesday's primary, political newcomer Brandon Neuman, 28, of North Strabane, will face off against Robert Fisher, 74, of South Strabane.
Mr. Fisher, the husband of county Democratic Jury Commissioner Judith Fisher, is a retired coal miner and steelworker and with his wife comprises one of the most powerful Democratic couples in county politics. He is a member of the executive committee for the state Democratic party and has been a local committeeman for more than 30 years.
Mr. Neuman, a lawyer specializing in civil litigation, has secured the endorsement of Mr. Solobay and worked as a Democratic committeeman and intern in Mr. Solobay's office in 2003, 2004 and 2006.
For the GOP nod, conservative activist and newspaper publisher Cody Knotts, 41, of North Strabane, will line up against South Strabane Supervisor Robert Koman, 48.
Mr. Koman, an independent marketing consultant, is the only candidate who has held public office, this year beginning his second six-year term with South Strabane.
Mr. Knotts staged an unsuccessful campaign to unseat former state Rep. Leo Trich, D-North Franklin, in 2000, and has served as a Republican committeeman for 24 years. He has used his newspaper, the Weekly Recorder, to promote conservative causes and to expose corruption in county government, along with consumer fraud.
During a recent League of Women Voters debate in North Strabane, the candidates discussed various issues, offering a wide spectrum of opinions.
As the county is beginning to wrestle with issues involving the Marcellus shale natural gas formation, candidates sounded off on whether natural gas production should be subject to a severance tax.
Mr. Fisher said he opposes drilling due to environmental and water usage concerns and said the gas "should be taxed heavily," with the proceeds benefiting local communities, not state coffers.
Mr. Neuman pointed to Pennsylvania as one of only two states with gas drilling that does not levy a severance tax. Such a tax could be combined with existing bonds to help repair roads damaged by heavy equipment, he said, or the bonds could be expanded.
Mr. Knotts and Mr. Koman opposed a severance tax, saying it could curtail development.
"One of the problems we have in Pennsylvania, is if it moves, we tax it," Mr. Knotts said.
The candidates agreed that issues involving water usage and pollution may need to be addressed through heightened regulations.
"I think we need to have responsible laws," Mr. Knotts said. "There's got to be moderation."
Mr. Neuman said communities and gas companies should work together to obtain funds for water treatment facilities and other issues.
Mr. Koman said that as an elected official, he was the only candidate who dealt directly with the issue, while Mr. Fisher said he was very concerned about the environment.
"When I see Halliburton trucks in Washington County, it just makes me sick," he said, alluding to large trucks used to haul water to and from drilling sites. Some of the white trucks have Halliburton signs on them.
The four candidates agreed that the state should sell or auction off its liquor stores in favor of privatization and they all expressed concern about underfunded state pensions that are expected to impact school districts and taxpayers in the next few years.
On the subject of consolidating school districts, Mr. Koman said he favored school vouchers, while Mr. Neuman said the issue should be left to a voter referendum.
Mr. Fisher said some school districts could be merged to save money, and Mr. Knotts said he favored centralized purchasing and possibly a single countywide superintendent, with autonomous districts.
Regarding term limits for legislators, Mr. Neuman suggested 20-year limits to allow young people more opportunities, while Mr. Fisher said he was a proponent of limiting legislators to two four-year terms, the same as governors. Longer terms open the door too much for special interest, he said.
Mr. Knotts said term limits weaken the legislative branch of state government and would give an unfair advantage to more populated urban areas, while Mr. Koman favored eight-year limits like those for presidents.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.