HARRISBURG -- Legislative leaders are starting to make good on their promises to be more fiscally responsible -- at least when it comes to salaries of top staffers.
Still, overall payroll numbers are up slightly in the Senate, which gave hundreds of raises last year while House counterparts did not.
Seventy-four House and Senate staffers have salaries of more than $100,000 a year -- six fewer than a year ago -- according to records obtained from the chief clerks of the House and Senate.
Spokesmen for the caucuses attribute the change to retirements, salary freezes and an effort to reduce spending after grappling with a $3 billion state budget deficit last year.
"We have worked hard to trim costs and find ways to improve efficiencies," said Brett Marcy, press secretary to House Majority Leader Todd Eachus, D-Luzerne.
Other caucuses have done the same.
"We have made a concerted effort to cut back on expenses," said House Republican spokesman Steve Miskin. "Before, we would hire people and just create a position for them if we found a really good person. Now we only hire if there's a specific position we need to fill."
Mr. Eachus began making promises of fiscal accountability when he took over as majority leader in January 2009, but his initial hires did little to instill confidence in those promises. Chief of staff Laura Jan Kuller and chief legal counsel Nora Winkelman, for example, were hired at salaries exceeding their predecessors' by $24,000 and $17,000, respectively.
The House Republican caucus now employs 474 full-time employees, down 16 from a year ago.
One reason for the staffing reduction is the abrupt resignations of several highly paid staffers who were caught up in a legislative corruption probe, such as Brett O. Feese. Mr. Feese, a former state representative who became House Republican chief counsel, had been paid nearly half a million dollars over three years. Facing felony charges in the corruption probe known as Bonusgate, he resigned in November, leaving behind his designation as the highest-paid employee of the caucus.
The House Democratic caucus similarly shed seven staffers in 2007 during an earlier phase of the Bonusgate inquiry. Six of those seven ultimately were arrested.
The caucus now has 902 full-time employees, down 11 from last year. That number is expected to decrease even more when a new policy takes effect that is prompting some veteran staffers to consider retiring to preserve benefits under a leave policy that is changing June 1. The change will reduce departing employees' payouts for unused sick days and vacation time. Currently, employees are paid for up to 75 unused vacation days and receive 33 percent of their daily rate of pay for up to 120 unused sick days. Those who depart after June 1 will be paid for a maximum of 45 vacation days at full pay and a maximum of 100 sick days at 10 percent of pay.
Barry Kauffman, of the government watchdog group Common Cause, said the change is good from a purely fiscal point of view but may be harmful in terms of the loss of knowledge and experience.
"If all the high talent is leaving and the deadwood is staying, maybe it's a bad thing," Mr. Kauffman said in an interview Thursday. "To know if it's good for the General Assembly, you have to look at the number of people [who have accrued significant vacation and sick time], the positions of those people and the experience they bring," he said.
As in the House, staffing levels are slightly down in the Senate. In the majority caucus, Republicans have 374 full-time employees, down seven from a year ago. Democrats have 292, down eight from last year.
Since 2000, Senate Democrats have reduced staff by about 20 percent, spokesman Charlie Tocci said.
Still, payroll has risen a bit in Senate caucuses due to merit raises, promotions and increases that follow internal guidelines based on years of experience.
Senate Republicans, who hold an overwhelming majority in their chamber, now spend $21.14 million on staff salaries, up $259,000 from a year ago. Senate Democrats are spending $15.74 million, up $79,000 from last year.
In the House, meanwhile, payroll is down. Republican staff salaries total $31.58 million for the year, down $787,000 from last year. Democratic payroll, meanwhile, totals $38.06 million, down $305,000 from last year.
Tim Potts, a former House employee who co-founded the government watchdog group Democracy Rising PA, said the reductions are likely in reaction to public discontent over the highly publicized corruption probe. Still, he hesitated to give the Legislature credit for the change, saying lawmakers may return to their old ways as soon as the public stops paying attention.
A long-term solution, he says, would be to create an independent body to set salary scales that are in line with pay in the private sector.
"Salaries are not set by any objective means. They are whimsical and subjective," Mr. Potts said in a recent interview. "An independent review would do wonders for public confidence."
The highest paid aide in the Legislature is Edward J. Nolan, minority executive director of the House Appropriations Committee. His salary is $188,084, the same amount as a year ago.
With a few exceptions, the House caucuses froze salaries on Jan. 1. Some highly paid staffers, though, were approved for raises in the waning weeks of 2009.
One of the largest raises went to Paul Parsells, chief of staff to House Speaker Keith McCall, D-Carbon. His salary increased 12 percent, bringing it to $150,000. Mr. Marcy, the caucus spokesman, said the increase is because Mr. Parsells took on more responsibility when his boss, Rep. McCall, became Speaker of the House. That change happened in January 2008 but Mr. Parsells took no raise then, Mr. Marcy said.
Staffer Michael Rish's salary bump -- the largest in the Democratic caucus -- also was due to a promotion. Mr. Rish's salary had been $89,986 when he was leadership executive director. It increased 22 percent to $115,024 when he became chief of staff to the new house whip, Rep. Frank Dermody, D-Oakmont.
Still, his pay is lower than his predecessor, Ralph "Ed" Haines, whose salary recently has been on a roller-coaster ride.
In 2008, Mr. Haines received $101,062 in pay as senior policy analyst to state Rep. Bill DeWeese, D-Waynesburg, who then was majority whip. He was promoted in March 2009 to Mr. DeWeese's chief of staff, a job that came with a $125,034 salary. The raise, though, was short-lived.
When Mr. DeWeese was arrested in a corruption probe in December, he was forced to resign from leadership but remained a representative. With his boss now working with the smaller budget of a rank-and-file lawmaker, Mr. Haines was returned to his previous job classification and $101,062 salary.
Other former DeWeese aides also were demoted -- but kept their salaries. For example, press secretary Tom Andrews kept his $89,128 salary even though he was demoted to "media specialist 2." The two others with that job title are paid $57,730 and $58,396.
Records show that Mr. Haines is the only former DeWeese staffer whose salary was reduced after his boss vacated the whip's office. The reduction was because Mr. Haines's responsibilities lessened, Mr. Marcy said.
In the House Republican caucus, staffer Dave Thomas has seen his paychecks skyrocket in the last two years. Since 2008, his salary nearly doubled, rising from $69,384 to $130,000.
Two years ago he was executive director of the House Liquor Control Committee. Promoted last year to Appropriations Committee counsel, his pay increased to $103,506. Another promotion to legislative policy director came with another 20 percent raise. One reason for that increase was to match the salary Mr. Thomas had been offered by another lawmaker trying to recruit him for a job in the state Senate, Mr. Miskin said. House Republican leaders wanted to keep him on their staff because "he has helped tremendously in crafting strategy and working with members to pass their bills in the Democratic-controlled chamber," Mr. Miskin said.
Mr. Thomas and six or seven district office employees who received $2,500 raises were the only GOP caucus employees whose pay was increased, Mr. Miskin said. The caucus is entering is third year of a salary freeze, he said.
In the Senate majority caucus, the biggest pay increase went to Drew Crompton, who was appointed to the dual role of acting chief of staff and chief counsel to Senate Pro Tem Joe Scarnati, R-Jefferson. Previously, Mr. Crompton had been chief counsel. His salary increased 16 percent, bringing it from $117,600 to $140,436.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.