HARRISBURG -- Most Pennsylvania Democrats knew a lot about the two candidates for governor in the 2002 primary.

State Auditor General Robert Casey Jr., whose father had been governor and who had probably the best-known name in state politics, lost to former Philadelphia Mayor Ed Rendell, who enjoyed great popularity in heavily populated southeast Pennsylvania.

What a contrast this year. According to recent polls, the four Democrats running in the May 18 gubernatorial primary aren't exactly household names.

"It's like night and day this year," said Christopher Borick, a pollster at Muhlenberg College in Allentown. "In 2002, Casey and Rendell were brand-name candidates. Now, things are absolutely different. You have a cast that's anything but a known quantity."

Advertise with us

Two Democrats are familiar to Pittsburgh-area voters: Allegheny County Executive Dan Onorato, who lives on the North Side, and state Auditor General Jack Wagner, who lives in Beechview.

Mr. Wagner is a bit better known around Pennsylvania because he holds a statewide office and draws publicity by auditing state agencies, Mr. Borick said, while Mr. Onorato is boosting his name recognition by spending heavily on TV ads in the past three weeks.

With $6 million in campaign funds on hand, Mr. Onorato can afford a lot of TV exposure. Mr. Wagner had less than $1 million in his war chest as of his last report filed March 31, and his commercials are likely to go up on TV closer to the election.

The other two Democrats are known mainly in the southeastern part of the state -- Montgomery County Commissioner Joe Hoeffel and state Sen. Anthony Williams of Philadelphia. Mr. Williams, who was late in entering the race, had $1.7 million in political funds as of the last report and is also buying TV ads in order to boost his name recognition.

A recent Quinnipiac University poll showed Mr. Onorato leading, with 20 percent of the 921 respondents surveyed; Mr. Hoeffel was second, at 15 percent; Mr. Wagner third, with 13 percent; and Mr. Williams at 5 percent. But that still left 47 percent undecided, and a whopping 70 percent of those surveyed said they still might change their minds.

Advertise with us

According to the April 7 survey, Mr. Onorato was "slightly ahead" but "the undecided vote [was] so large" that Quinnipiac pollster Peter Brown considered the race a toss-up at that point. The next polls will likely show his lead increasing, after his saturation TV ads.

There's also a Republican primary on May 18 -- which also makes things very different from 2002.

In gubernatorial election years, there's usually just one Republican running -- the one chosen by the strongly regimented Republican State Committee. This year, that's Attorney General Tom Corbett of Shaler.

The Quinnipiac survey showed that the well-funded Mr. Corbett, with about $4 million in campaign funds on hand, is far ahead of his challenger, state Rep. Sam Rohrer of Berks County, by a 58-to-7 margin.

"It's been hard for Sam to crack into the Republican electorate," Mr. Borick said. "That race is like David and Goliath."

Advertise with us

But a sizeable portion of state Republicans are undecided, which gives the underdog an outside shot. Mr. Rohrer doesn't have a hefty war chest but is drawing support from conservative Republicans, the outspoken "tea party" members.

While Mr. Onorato is raising his profile through TV ads, Mr. Corbett has gotten a lot of publicity from prosecuting legislators of both parties for alleged misuse of taxpayer funds for political purposes. Some critics, however, have complained that Mr. Corbett is doing the same thing -- using his public office to benefit himself politically.

Both GOP candidates have been touting themselves as fiscal conservatives, and both have vowed to seek to cut state spending and to oppose all tax increases if they become governor.

All six candidates for the state's top job have one thing in common. They're all attacking the way state government has operated in the past five years -- middle-of-the-night pay raises, budget impasses, illegal bonuses, corruption arrests -- and they're all promising to "reform" a bad system.

"Everybody is trying to jump on the 'reform' bandwagon," Mr. Borick said. With all the bad publicity about the Legislature, he said, "It's no surprise that every candidate is trumpeting their ability to change Harrisburg."

Advertise with us

But they all faced criticism last week from two citizens' groups that were active in overturning the 2005 legislative pay raise. Tim Potts of Democracy Rising PA and Eric Epstein of Rock the Capital said all six men were, in effect, robbing constituents of service by running statewide campaigns on taxpayers' time.

"All of the gubernatorial candidates are benefiting from holding one office while seeking to relocate to the governor's mansion," Mr. Epstein said. "They all should resign their current offices."

Mr. Potts said the six candidates "should be replaced by people who will not be distracted from their official duties by preparing for the next step in their political careers."

The six candidates have refused to leave their current jobs, insisting they can carry out their current duties while campaigning for higher office.

Perhaps because of a general lack of recognition of the candidates, they've been willing to take part in a surprising number of debates, some of them televised, starting back in January.

Advertise with us

Mr. Hoeffel has clearly positioned himself as the most liberal Democrat, although he prefers the word "progressive." At a six-candidate debate here last week, he alone came out in support of an increase in the state gasoline tax to generate funds for road and bridge repairs.

Most legislators consider any kind of tax hike to be anathema, especially in an election year. The other five gubernatorial candidates opted for less controversial ideas to raise road revenue, such as increasing vehicle registration fees or building new roads that would require tolls.

Mr. Hoeffel is also alone in his call for a "graduated" state income tax, where higher wage earners would have a higher tax rate than lower-income people. Now, everyone is taxed at the same 3.07 percent.

While Mr. Hoeffel, a former three-term congressman, is short on campaign funds, he will probably do well in Philadelphia and its four suburban counties, which have many liberal-leaning Democrats. Mr. Williams, who is black, could also do well in Philadelphia, which has a lot of African-American voters.

Mr. Onorato and Mr. Wagner are more conservative on social and taxation issues, as befits many politicians from the Western part of the state.

Advertise with us

In the November general election -- if history is any guide -- Republicans should have an advantage. Since the 1950s, the two parties have alternated control of the governor's office every eight years. This "swapping" even predates a constitutional change in 1968 that allowed governors to serve two consecutive four-year terms.

Democratic party officials, to no one's surprise, are vowing to break that eight-year cycle of alternation this November.

Some political observers also say that based on patterns of history and geography, this year would seem to favor a candidate from southwestern Pennsylvania.

Mr. Rendell, a Democrat from the southeast, has served since January 2003. Before him came Tom Ridge, a Republican from Erie, who took office in 1995. He was preceded by Scranton Democrat Robert Casey Sr. from 1987 to 1994. Before him was Pittsburgh Republican Dick Thornburgh, who served 1979-86, and Philadelphia Democrat Milton Shapp, 1971-78.

So while it's a totally unscientific prediction, it could be southwestern Pennsylvania's turn to regain the governor's office this year.