HARRISBURG -- In the first meeting of all six candidates for governor this year, the four Democrats advocated limits on how much individuals and corporations could give to political candidates, while the two Republicans were hesitant about imposing such caps.

"Campaign finance reform is a must," said Allegheny County Executive Dan Onorato, who was joined in that view by state Auditor General Jack Wagner, Montgomery County Commissioner Joe Hoeffel and state Sen. Anthony Williams, D-Philadelphia.

Mr. Hoeffel suggested a limit of $5,000 for an individual contributor and for a political action committee, "to maximize individuals and lessen the influence of corporations." Mr. Hoeffel, who calls himself "progressive," also suggested looking at public financing of campaigns.

But the two Republicans running for governor, state Attorney General Tom Corbett and state Rep. Sam Rohrer of Berks County, weren't so sure campaign contribution limits were a good idea. Mr. Corbett said Colorado tried limiting people to giving $750 to a candidate, but political action committees and special interests found ways around the limits. He also said caps on contributions tend to favor incumbents, who are already known to voters.

Advertise with us

The six candidates met last night in a 90-minute televised debate sponsored by Common Cause/Pennsylvania, the League of Women Voters, a Philadelphia citizens group called the Committee of Seventy and Harrisburg Area Community College, where the debate took place.

Topics included whether independents should be allowed to vote in Democratic and Republican primaries; whether to change the way Pennsylvania redraws state House, Senate and congressional district lines after each census; ways to encourage more people to vote; whether to ban gifts from special interests to government officials; how to promote more openness and accountability in state government; how to get state budgets adopted on time, meaning by July 1 of each year; and whether to ban state employees from getting bonuses.

As for getting more people out to vote, Mr. Williams said he is willing to consider letting 16- and 17-year-olds vote; others said such teens could "pre-register" to vote, but wouldn't actually cast ballots until they turn 18.

Mr. Wagner and Mr. Hoeffel said they could support "same-day registration," meaning letting a person sign up to vote on Election Day and then immediately cast a ballot.

The four Democrats and the two Republicans have seven weeks left before the party primaries are held May 18. The two winners will face each other in November.

Advertise with us

Five of the candidates said voters registered as independents should be able to vote in one of the two party primaries in May.

Mr. Rohrer didn't go quite that far, but did say the parties should be encouraged to let independents take part. He also said the number of signatures needed for third-party candidates to get on a fall ballot should be lowered.

The candidates agreed that the process of redrawing district lines every 10 years is contaminated by politics, but some said it may be almost impossible to totally remove politics or selfish interests from the process.

"Gerrymandering is alive and well in Pennsylvania," said Mr. Onorato. "It happens every 10 years and it's wrong."

Last night the six men talked about having a nonpartisan commission draw the lines, but noted that politicians, such as legislators or the governor, would likely name them, thus letting politics into the process. Mr. Wagner suggested that the three groups sponsoring the debate -- Common Cause, the League of Women Voters and the Committee of Seventy -- might name the members.

Advertise with us

The candidates agreed that as governor, they would issue an executive order "on day one" forbidding any member of their administration from taking a gift or anything else of value from a special interest or someone seeking contracts from the state.

Mr. Onorato said he would insist that any member of his staff wait at least two years after leaving his job before going to work for a lobbying firm that deals with the state.

The candidates also agreed on making state government more "open and transparent," including putting all salary and contract information in easily understandable form online.

They also agreed to ban, as much as possible, "sole source" and "emergency" contracts, along with undisclosed changes to existing contracts, in order to get as much open competition for state contracts as possible.

Mr. Corbett said he was "leaning toward term limits" for legislators, but didn't say how many terms.

Advertise with us

Most of the candidates favored having the state auditor general do an annual audit of the General Assembly's $200 million "slush fund" and note how the money is spent. Leaders use it to pay staff salaries and other expenses if a new budget isn't enacted on time.

Current law says the Legislature will hire its own auditor rather than having the auditor general do it. Until the last few years, only the legislative leaders knew how much they had squirreled away in the account, which all the candidates said was wrong.

All the candidates said they would do more, as governor, to ensure that a budget was adopted by July 1. Mr. Wagner said no elected officials should be paid for any day when the budget is late. Last year, that would have cost the governor and legislators 101 days of pay, because the fiscal 2009-10 budget wasn't adopted until October.

The candidates also discussed "merit selection" of judges, where a commission, either named by a governor or private groups, would pick judges, rather than having them elected by voters, as they are now.