HARRISBURG -- As Gov. Ed Rendell prepares to deliver his last state budget proposal Tuesday, all four chambers of the General Assembly have put him on notice that two major revenue-raising ideas are dead on arrival.
With elections coming up in May and November, Democrats and Republicans in the Senate and House are ruling out any chance of increasing "broad-based" taxes, such as the 3.07 percent personal income tax and the 6 percent sales tax (which is 7 percent in Allegheny County and 8 percent in Philadelphia).
"We are making our policy positions clear before the budget process gets under way in earnest," Senate Democratic leader Bob Mellow of Lackawanna said at a news conference last week. He was joined by several colleagues, including Sen. Jim Ferlo of Highland Park, who said he "isn't supporting any broad-based tax increases."
Democrats don't control the Senate; Republicans do, by a hefty 30-20 margin. But the GOP, both in the Senate and the House, has consistently spoken out against tax increases in fiscal 2010-11, which starts July 1.
Democrats do control the House but by a fairly narrow margin of 104-99, and whether they retain that control is a major issue in the November election. House Democratic spokesman Brett Marcy said last week the caucus is opposed to higher sales or income taxes.
The 2009-10 budget is $27.8 billion. Mr. Rendell recently said state spending -- driven by hard-to-control items such as funding for schools, welfare and prisons -- could increase by up to 4 percent, or $1.1 billion, in fiscal 2010-11. Education, at $11 billion, and welfare, at $10 billion, are always the two largest slices of the budget, followed by growing correctional costs, which are nearing $2 billion.
"We don't control the number of people that judges send to prison or the number of low-income people who qualify for medical assistance," Mr. Rendell said. The number of state prisoners, which now tops 51,000, is up sharply in the past few years.
Mr. Rendell is expected to support continued funding for the "educational costing-out study," done by the Legislature three years ago. It called for six years of increased funding for public schools. Last February, the study results prompted Mr. Rendell to call for a $418 million increase for schools in 2009-10, but he later scaled that back to $300 million.
However, many legislators have objected that 4 percent is much too large an increase for 2010-11, given the recession's ongoing damage to state revenues. Through Jan. 31, they were $374 million below forecasts made last year, and the red ink could reach a half-billion dollars by June 30.
Last June -- when the state faced a whopping $3.2 billion deficit -- Mr. Rendell, a Democrat, proposed a 0.5 percent increase in the personal income tax rate, which would have raised it to 3.57 percent. That move would have raised an additional $1.7 billion for the state.
But even legislators from his own party balked at that idea, led by a group of 25 or so conservative House Democrats nicknamed the "Blue Dogs," whose unofficial leader is Rep. Nick Kotik of Robinson.
This year, of course, is an election year for the 203 House seats and half of the 50-member Senate. Lawmakers who want to stay in office are unlikely to hike taxes in an election year, knowing that voters tend to remember such things.
But Mr. Rendell leaves office in January, when his second four-year term is up, so he doesn't have to face voters anymore. At recent news conferences, he has refused to slam the door on the idea of a higher income tax rate, answering questions with coy replies such as "We'll see" or "Tune in Feb. 9."
If he does rule out higher income or sales taxes, what are his other options?
One source might be the federal government, which is considering giving states more money for Medicaid, or medical assistance for low-income folks. According to news reports, Pennsylvania could be in line for an extra $800 million, which would help pay for the state's $10 billion public welfare budget.
"It's important to see whether we get that money," Mr. Rendell said. "We will continue to track it."
Another revenue generator would be removing some of the many existing exemptions to the sales tax and retaining only the major ones -- those covering food, clothing and pharmaceuticals. Making more items taxable could raise as much as $12 billion, which is far more revenue than is needed.
Mr. Rendell often cites gold sales, which are exempt from the sales tax, as an example of a commodity that should be taxed. Reducing the number of exemptions is an alternative to proposing a higher overall rate for the sales tax. If the rate were raised statewide by an additional 1 percentage point, it would generate an extra $1.3 billion, according to the state Revenue Department.
On Tuesday Mr. Rendell is expected to call for taxing sales of cigars and smokeless tobacco -- something he tried last year, to no avail. He says it "makes no sense" for Pennsylvania to be the only state that doesn't tax those items, adding that even tobacco-producing states like North Carolina tax them. Doing so would raise $50 million or so.
Mr. Rendell will also seek another new tax by asking legislators to enact a new levy on the extraction at the wellhead of natural gas from the plentiful areas of underground Marcellus shale in the state. But he estimated that levy would produce only about $100 million, which would just put a dent in the existing $374 million deficit.
Gas-producing companies are likely to put up stiff resistance to the new tax.
Another long-time goal of Democrats, which has never come to fruition, is ending what is called the "Delaware loophole," which enables Pennsylvania companies to avoid corporate taxes by establishing headquarters for some operations in Delaware.
State officials say that raising as much as $420 million in additional funds are possible by ending this loophole. Democrats argue the corporate net income tax rate of 9.99 percent -- one of the highest in the country -- could be lowered significantly with that additional revenue.
But Republicans strongly oppose what would amount to higher taxes for some corporations, and killing the loophole is unlikely.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.