In a small brick church in the heart of Charleroi, the Rev. Sharon Woomer had been planning a wedding with a pair of congregants when her phone buzzed, notifying her of news she and her congregation had been fearing for months.
In a 6-3 decision June 25, the U.S. Supreme Court allowed the federal government to end legal protections for migrants fleeing violence and devastation from natural disasters in Haiti and Syria, dealing a massive blow to Woomer’s congregation, the majority of which is Haitian.
The decision essentially puts hundreds of thousands of asylum seekers across the country — including those in Charleroi — at risk of becoming undocumented immigrants subject to deportation while stripping them of their ability to legally work.
It also throws the future of the borough into question as community leaders said the ruling could spark a mass exodus of Haitians, who may be forced to leave the country or face arrest, detention and deportation.
Woomer — who rushed to the bathroom to sob after learning of the decision — said she is terrified that the many Haitians in her congregation could be left with no choice but to return to the country they fled to avoid rampant gang violence, political turmoil and widespread food shortages.
“It is gut-wrenching to think of the possibility of these folks, these children, especially families, being separated and sent back to this unthinkable nightmare,” she said.
Read More
‘Fear is predominating. . .’
The decision has sent a new round of shockwaves through the small borough on the banks of the Monongahela River. The community was thrust into the national spotlight after President Donald Trump claimed Haitian immigrants were “virtually bankrupting” the borough during the lead up to the 2024 presidential election.
“There’s armies of panicked people out there,” said immigration attorney Joseph Patrick Murphy, who represents clients in Charleroi. “Fear is predominating the conversation.”
In the days since another landmark Supreme Court ruling— one June 30 that upheld the 14th Amendment’s guarantee of birthright citizenship, overturning an executive order by Trump — federal immigration enforcement operations have surged across the country, according to The New York Times.
Murphy said a mass exodus of Haitians from Charleroi, which has a population of just over 4,200, will result in the loss of the immigrant businesses that have cropped up along the borough’s main drag over the past few years.
“Charleroi will end up right back where it was in 2019,” Murphy said. “It was like a ghost town. …There was abandoned storefront after abandoned storefront.”
Haiti was designated for temporary protected status in 2010 “based on extraordinary and temporary conditions within the country” following a 7.0-magnitude earthquake, according to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. Syria was initially designated in 2012 amid armed conflict that prevented people from safely returning.
Former Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem moved in 2025 to rescind the status for Haiti and Syria along with several other countries, claiming they no longer met the conditions to be granted the status — though the U.S. State Department continues to advise people not to travel to either country because they are unsafe.
In a statement following the Supreme Court’s ruling, Department of Homeland Security General Counsel James Percival said Temporary Protected Status “was always supposed to be temporary and can be cancelled at the appropriate time.”
“We now have several more important tools to continue securing our borders,” Percival said.
While the ruling has left the borough’s immigrant community reeling, Charleroi Councilman Larry Celashi, who has long supported the president’s deportation efforts, applauded the Supreme Court’s decision after he testified before the U.S. House Judiciary Committee in December on the impact of TPS in the borough.
At the time, he told members of the committee that Charleroi — with its limited tax base, aging housing stock and scant municipal services — was unable to absorb an estimated 2,000 to 3,000 migrants during a short time period.
“I wondered whether our concerns would truly be heard,” Celashi, a Republican, told the Post-Gazette. “Looking back, I believe that testimony helped bring attention to the challenges our community faced.”
While he welcomed the ruling and Trump administration’s efforts to bring the case before the Supreme Court, Celashi said his community had yet to receive any federal aid to help it address financial issues he claimed immigration brought to the borough.
“Throughout this entire situation, my priority as a borough official has been, first and foremost, to serve the legal residents of our community,” he said. “I have repeatedly pointed out that the Borough of Charleroi has not received a single dollar in direct federal funding to help address the financial and operational impacts our community experienced. That remains unacceptable.”
Republican State Sen. Camera Bartolotta, whose district includes Charleroi, said, because immigration is a federal issue, she intends to work with Republican U.S. Rep. Guy Reschenthaler to provide assistance to the borough that may be needed as its immigrant population declines amid the Trump administration's deportation efforts.
“Many of these immigrants have seen the writing on the wall and they have self-deported or moved to other locations,” she said. “I’m hoping the empty storefronts in Charleroi that are available to anyone who wants to invest in the community will be filled by those who can bring a tax base.”
Borough Councilwoman Kristin Hopkins, a Democrat, disputed claims that Charleroi’s immigrants have had a negative impact and instead said that since Haitian immigrants began settling in the region about eight years ago, crime has gone down, tax revenue has increased and church attendance has risen.
“We’re all fearful that it would return back to what we had prior to the immigrant community coming here,” Hopkins said. “The only chance we have here in the Rust Belt for an increase in population is an occurrence like we’ve had as of late.”
Hopkins said that if Charleroi were to lose its immigrant population, it would amount to a lost opportunity for the borough’s revitalization after it was ravaged by the loss of U.S. Steel in the 1980s.
“This was really a chance that we had here that a lot of other communities didn’t have for growth, population growth, tax-based growth, and an opportunity to improve our schools,” she said.
Stress on the community
Those who have been working to help Charleroi’s immigrant community said the Supreme Court decision has been devastating.
“It’s a heavy stress on the community right now,” said Getro Bernabe, an immigrant community liaison in Charleroi, said. “They feel like they are lost.”
Jimmy Alexandre, the owner and operator of the borough’s Haitian Resource Center, which opened in January 2025, said people are losing sleep as they navigate what the ruling could mean for themselves and their families. Some immigrants, he said, are making contingency plans for their children in case they are detained.
“They have to do the math without having the numbers,” Alexandre said. “They’re not sure what to think.”
Alexandre said the court decision is especially hard for people who have lived in the United States for more than a decade.
“That wakes up a whole lot of trauma,” he said. “They worked hard to build what they have now.”
While the long-term impact of the Supreme Court ruling on Charleroi remains to be seen, the legal precedent could have much broader implications across the region and country. About 1.3 million refugees from 17 countries have legal protections under TPS — a program that could end altogether unless Congress intervenes.
If that were to happen, coupled with ongoing mass deportations and a dwindling flow of immigration to the country, economies, including Pittsburgh’s, would to take a hit, experts said.
Financial impact
Researchers with FWD.us, a national immigration and criminal justice policy group, found that Pittsburgh metro’s economy could lose up to $451 million annually, in addition to millions more in state and local taxes, if entire swaths of immigrant communities are taken out of the workforce.
The group predicted food costs would increase 14.5%, in part due to the agriculture industry’s reliance on immigrant workers, as well as a 6.1% increase in housing costs and a 3.9% increase for leisure and hospitality services by the end of 2028.
“All the evidence in the world is going to show that this stuff is just making people economically worse,” FWD.us President Todd Schulte said. “Basically, you’re moving people from the workforce so there’s fewer workers, but also you’re reducing overall economic activity, which is hurting the economy, so it hurts tax revenue.”
In a study published in April, the group found that there were about 2,000 immigrants with TPS in the Pittsburgh metro area who contributed an estimated $37 million to the local economy in 2024.
The largest one-time TPS revocation had previously been for three countries in West Africa in 2017 when the Ebola crisis dissipated, removing protections for about 17,000, Schulte said.
The Supreme Court’s latest TPS decision, by comparison, will impact about 350,000 Haitians and 6,000 Syrians nationally.
“It’s totally unprecedented,” he said. “There’s nothing close to this that has happened in terms of the loss of immigration status.”
While the total number of Haitian refugees in the area remains unclear, Dana Gold, chief operations officer of Jewish Family Services of Pittsburgh, said the organization had helped more than 500 Haitians with job placement, TPS case management, and other services since it began working with immigrants in Charleroi in 2021.
Gold said JFCS had worked for the past six to eight months to help Haitian immigrants make contingency plans if they are detained or deported, including for their children if the adults are arrested and separated.
“It’s a very chaotic environment that they came from where many of them have experienced threats to their lives, watched family members killed, and fled violence,” Gold said. “Now that this protection is being ended there is a lot of fear about what they are going to do. Going back is a death sentence for many.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.