WASHINGTON — Three Pennsylvania Republicans facing competitive re-elections next year gave Democrats the necessary support to force a vote on extending the expiring Obamacare subsidies for three years, though chances of avoiding an upcoming spike in premiums were still slim on Wednesday as Congress remained sharply divided.

U.S. Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick became the first in his party to sign on to the Democrats’ effort after GOP leaders declined to consider his alternative plan.

The moderate Bucks County Republican had been one of a few representatives trying to scrap together a compromise before Congress’ winter break at the end of the week and the expiration of the subsidies — which, on average, will double premiums for Pennsylvanians on the Pennie marketplace — on Jan. 1.

U.S. Reps. Ryan Mackenzie and Rob Bresnahan — who also represent competitive districts in eastern Pennsylvania — followed him to become the only four Republicans to join 214 Democrats. The discharge petition will force House Speaker Mike Johnson to bring up the clean extension for a vote, though not necessarily this week.

Advertise with us

Mr. Fitzpatrick rejected some of his GOP colleagues’ talking points during a committee meeting Tuesday night. He urged action for “people that we know back home that need our help.”

“As I’ve stated many times before, the only policy that is worse than a clean three-year extension without any reforms, is a policy of complete expiration without any bridge,” he said in a statement Wednesday after joining Democrats. “Unfortunately, it is House leadership themselves that have forced this outcome.”

Pittsburgh-area Democratic U.S. Reps. Summer Lee and Chris Deluzio continued to push for a clean extension while other Republicans such as U.S. Rep. Glenn Thompson stood by his party’s leadership.

“I’m really pleased with the package that’s coming together,” Mr. Thompson, who represents parts of Western and Central Pennsylvania, told the Post-Gazette on Tuesday.

Mr. Thompson said he agreed there was a “real need” for action and that “people can’t afford” the upcoming increases. But he said he preferred Mr. Johnson’s proposal that Republican leaders said would lower premiums by 11%. Mr. Thompson called that a “significant amount” and said Democrats were focusing too much on a smaller portion of individuals who get their insurance through the marketplace.

Advertise with us

The number of those individuals was more than 400,000 in Pennsylvania, though officials have said more individuals have dropped coverage since notices of the premium increases went out this fall.

“My Democratic friends are talking a lot about the 7% … We want to do this for all Americans,” Mr. Thompson said. “I think we have a better focus. We’re certainly concerned about the 7%, and I do believe with what we're putting forward, we’ll help to bring those premiums down.”

Mr. Fitzpatrick — during a House Rules Committee meeting where his compromise amendment was considered out of order — said it was “irrelevant” to focus on the fact that it’s only a small percentage of people impacted.

“To those 7%, this is everything to them. It’s everything to them,” Mr. Fitzpatrick said. “This is about our friends and neighbors. Take politics, take all that stuff, out of the equation.”

His amendment to Mr. Johnson’s bill would have extended the Affordable Care Act enhanced premium tax credits by two years while including other reforms like income limits to rule out higher earners.

Advertise with us

Mr. Deluzio, in an interview Tuesday night when a vote on that proposal was still possible, said he was considering the wide variety of options as they were being presented. He and other Democrats primarily continued to rail against Republicans for throwing together the options at the last minute.

“This is all very rushed, and I don't think it should have been because people have been now experiencing and seeing these prices on the exchange for a long time,” said Mr. Deluzio, of Fox Chapel. “I think the basics of what a deal could be — some extension and then an argument over the income levels for the subsidies — these are things that we've known could be the basis for a negotiation. And yet here we are.”

Ms. Lee, of Swissvale, on Wednesday rallied in a Capitol Hill conference room with about two-dozen people demanding a vote on the extension. She called the issue “beyond urgent” and “life or death” for people who are already rationing health care treatment because of rising costs.

She and others urged Mr. Johnson to bring up the Democrats’ plan for a vote immediately rather than waiting until January, which is permitted under the rules of the discharge petition. Even if that vote would pass the House, the Senate rejected a similar proposal last week and Republican Leader John Thune said his chamber would not vote again on any options before the holiday break.

“We have bipartisan support now to make sure that Americans don't have to choose life or death,” Ms. Lee said. “All we need is for Mike Johnson to bring a vote.”