WASHINGTON — U.S. Sens. John Fetterman and Dave McCormick voted along party lines Thursday on a pair of competing proposals to stave off a fast-approaching spike in health care costs for millions of Americans.
Both measures failed, pushing the 102% average premium increase for Pennsylvanians who get their insurance through the Pennie marketplace closer to reality starting in January.
Mr. Fetterman — after spending six weeks earlier this fall disagreeing with his party’s tactic of shutting down the government over the issue — voted with all Democratic senators on a three-year extension of the Affordable Care Act enhanced premium tax credits before they expire at the end of this month.
And Mr. McCormick, who has said his party is on the hook for solving the problem, voted with all Republicans on a plan that would put money into health care savings accounts for consumers rather than using the credits to insurance companies to bring down costs.
Neither bill received the 60 votes needed to pass — an anticipated outcome that Mr. Fetterman railed against in an interview this week.
“At this point, with this deadline, at this time of the year, I see no value in throw-away show votes,” the Democrat from Braddock told the Post-Gazette.
Read More
Mr. Fetterman said there was no realistic way for Republicans to piece together an alternative to the Obamacare subsidies before Congress leaves town for the holidays, as they’ve been trying to do amid GOP opposition to continuing the subsidies propping up former President Barack Obama’s signature legislation.
“You couldn't get an office painted in two weeks,” Mr. Fetterman said, sitting in his Capitol Hill office and gesturing to the walls. “So you're not going to remake health care … when you have just a couple days left.”
Mr. Fetterman’s vote in November was critical in ensuring the vote on Democrats’ proposal for a three-year extension of the tax credits on Thursday. After voting repeatedly with Republicans to end the historically long shutdown, eight of his colleagues eventually joined him in a deal in which Senate Republican leadership agreed to hold a vote but that did not guarantee the outcome. A majority of Senate Democrats and all House Democrats lamented the move, with officials like U.S. Rep. Summer Lee, D-Swissvale, saying it was “capitulating” in a way that gave up their leverage to force an outcome Republicans didn’t want.
“We have been very adamant, not just since the shutdown but quite before that about needing to fix this health care crisis,” Ms. Lee said in an interview with the Post-Gazette on Wednesday. “The fact that they refused to talk about it then shows me that they were hoping for this manufactured urgency because they're hoping to squeeze people.”
Mr. Fetterman said his votes to open the government and his support of the health care subsidies were aimed at avoiding higher costs for Pennsylvanians in need.
He pointed, as he did repeatedly throughout the shutdown, to the pause in Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP, benefits that impacted nearly 2 million Pennsylvanians and was only resolved after the shutdown ended. The more than 400,000 Pennsylvanians who get their insurance through Pennie are likely some of the same individuals, he said.
As both parties try to take credit for addressing affordability concerns, Mr. Fetterman said a one-year extension of the credits is a solution that should be palatable to everyone. He called it the “quickest, easiest, most elegant way” to get past the Jan. 1 deadline and then discuss income limits and other reforms — Republican priorities that he said he would be open to discussing.
“You don't have to die on an Obamacare hill as a Republican,” he said. “You can just say, ‘This is where we're at. Let's just now effectively put a pin on it, and we can negotiate on entirely appropriate kinds of things about income and other kinds of negotiations that can't possibly be figured out before the Christmas recess.’”
The uncertainty has potentially already had an impact. About 30,000 ACA enrollees dropped coverage in November, compared to 19,000 who dropped coverage in all of 2024, the Post-Gazette reported this week. Renewals are 15% lower in 2025 compared to 2024.
“People’s premiums tripling is unconscionable,” Ms. Lee said. “For everyone … who can squeeze by on that — and barely — there are people who will not be able to. They will just not be insured. [Republican opponents of the extension] know that that is a problem that they are going to have to pay for.”
Mr. McCormick also has called the premium increase “unsustainable” and heard from constituents on both sides of the aisle who are asking for a fix. He’s blamed Democrats for structuring Obamacare in the way that they have while also saying it now falls on Republicans who control both chambers of Congress to find a solution.
He voted with all but one of his GOP colleagues Thursday on a bill from U.S. Sens. Bill Cassidy, R-Louisiana, and Mike Crapo, R-Idaho, that would create health care savings accounts with deposits of $1,000 to $1,500 for individuals using the Obamacare marketplace and who earn less than 700% of the federal poverty line. Every Democrat voted down the idea.
Mr. McCormick then voted against a measure to advance the three-year extension of the subsidies. Four of his GOP colleagues voted with every Democrat, although they failed to reach the 60-vote threshold.
“While we need comprehensive reform, the Republican bill I voted for today is a first step toward eliminating fraud, expanding choice and reducing costs, and now we need to keep working together to get something done,” Mr. McCormick said in a statement Thursday.
In the House, meanwhile, three of Pennsylvania’s 10 Republican lawmakers are trying to bypass House Speaker Mike Johnson to force a vote on an extension of the enhanced premium tax credits through 2027. Their Bipartisan Health Insurance Affordability Act would also include new eligibility restrictions. By Thursday afternoon, four Democrats and 11 Republicans had signed a discharge petition that will ultimately need at least 217 votes to force Mr. Johnson to bring it to a vote.
U.S. Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick, R-Bucks County, said in a statement he was introducing the petition because individuals facing unaffordable cost increases “deserve a concrete solution now.” U.S. Reps. Ryan Mackenzie and Rob Bresnahan, also Republicans from the eastern part of the state, signed the petition. It was not clear if that or other competing ideas in the House will garner enough support.
“Every member must decide whom they serve: the people, or the politics,” Mr. Fitzpatrick said Wednesday. “We can prevent this — and we must.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.