WASHINGTON — With frustrated constituents in their ears, Pennsylvania’s federal lawmakers on Tuesday were confronting the possibility that health care premiums could soon skyrocket for millions of people if Congress fails to act on expiring Affordable Care Act subsidies.

“It doesn’t matter that it was Obamacare’s failure. Now we have to solve the problem,” U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick told thousands of people during a telephone town hall.

The Republican senator returned to Capitol Hill this week after a Thanksgiving break and a historic government shutdown that revolved around the pandemic-era tax credits that help many people pay for health coverage. Democrats in the minority voted to shut down the government to force Republicans to extend the subsidies past Dec. 31, but the parties never reached a full agreement and the majority party has not coalesced around a solution.

Mr. McCormick said during his town hall — as he has at other times during the months of partisan bickering — that he sympathizes with those who are facing increased costs. He said he wants to “extend the subsidies, but reformed” in a way that ensures people with higher incomes don’t get the benefits, a key focus for his party in the ongoing negotiations.

Advertise with us

He also said he wants a fix that "eliminates the fraud and then puts us on a glide path where we can kind of get through the next year or two.”

“You got a bunch of people that their premium’s going to be completely unsustainable,” Mr. McCormick said of the looming cliff.

The constituent who prompted his response underscored the bipartisan stakes.

Identified as Kurt from Lititz, in Lancaster County, the caller said he and his wife were facing an increase in payments from $550 to $2,073 through Pennie, the state marketplace. He said he “hated Obamacare” when it was enacted but now that he and his wife rely on it, the upcoming increase “is really going to hurt us.”

“It was stupid what the Democrats were doing,” Kurt said of the shutdown. “But you guys have got to pull a rabbit out of the hat in the next 30 days or a lot of people are going to be messed up.”

Advertise with us

Another caller, identified as Yvette from Orefield, in Lehigh County, joked with Mr. McCormick about missing him during his recent visit to Allentown because she regularly protests outside of Republican U.S. Rep. Ryan Mackenzie’s office with a sign that reads, “repeal Republican reaper care.”

“We really have to stop doing the finger pointing,” she said of the debate in Congress.

Mr. McCormick responded that he agreed with her on the importance of addressing costs that are “really spiraling out of control.”

“I want to make sure that the most vulnerable among us, the people that are served by community health centers, the people that are on Medicaid, that those programs actually meet their needs,” he said.

Earlier in the day, Pittsburgh resident Tori Baggot voiced those frustrations from the Keystone State on Capitol Hill as one of only a few speakers at a public meeting organized by Democrats.

Advertise with us

Ms. Baggot said her monthly payments are set to increase from $197 to $365, a hardship she can’t afford as someone who is starting to get a solely operated letterpress printing business off the ground and is also hoping to start a family soon.

“The financial burden of paying for the health care I need would involve a second job, pushing back or rethinking starting a family entirely, and possibly not being able to afford the specialist care that keeps me healthy and able to work at all,” Ms. Baggot said at a “shadow hearing” organized by Democrats on the House Subcommittee on Health, Employment, Labor and Pensions.

“My life will instantly become harder if Congress fails to renew these tax credits,” she said.

U.S. Rep. Summer Lee, D-Swissvale, is a member of the committee who supported her party’s shutdown fight over the issue. She said 24,000 people in her district covering Pittsburgh and parts of Allegheny and Westmoreland counties rely on the Affordable Care Act and the tax credits.

Those individuals and others were already facing a “crisis” with regularly rising health care costs — and “now we’re entering a catastrophe,” she said.

Advertise with us

“If Congress doesn't act before the end of the month, families in Western Pennsylvania and all over the country are going to see their already-expensive or too-expensive premiums jump by thousands of dollars,” Ms. Lee said.

Bipartisan talks have so far failed to produce a new plan to extend the subsidies before the end of the month, and hopes were dwindling during sessions of the U.S. House and Senate on Tuesday.

“I don’t think at this point we have a clear path forward, I don’t think the Democrats have a clear path forward,” Senate Majority Leader John Thune, R-South Dakota, said as Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer said Republicans were “in total disarray.”

The Associated Press contributed to this report.