WASHINGTON — Ravaged by black lung disease, retired coal miner Gary Hairston stood with nearly 100 other underground workers and advocates on Tuesday in front of the federal agency charged with protecting the lives of miners.
The West Virginia native had one message: Stop mine operators from exposing workers to deadly levels of the toxic dust that’s now causing a surge in the most virulent form of black lung.
For years, he said he had been coming to the capital with hundreds of others to plead with lawmakers to impose stricter limits on silica dust — a carcinogen in mines that’s far more dangerous than coal dust and has been singled out by health experts as the reason why so many younger miners are now suffering from the incurable illness.
“I hate to get up here and cry,” he said. “I've been coming up for over 27 years, talking to our congressmen. We got the silicon rule passed, but now we can't even get it enforced.”
Just six months after the rule was expected to take effect, the new threshold to limit the exposure of miners to silica dust is now being challenged in federal court — and its enforcement put on hold by the Trump administration.
Despite government estimates that the new threshold would save thousands of miners from illness and death, the industry has prevailed in holding back the protection even as medical experts say one in every five miners in central Appalachia is now afflicted with the disease.
Read More
Miners from the National Black Lung Association, the United Mine Workers of America and several chapters throughout Appalachia chanted demands for justice and waved signs warning: “silica kills.”
Some toted oxygen machines and pictures of people who had died of the disease, and dressed in T-shirts with pictures of skeletons and the words “Black Lung Kills.”
The demonstration comes weeks after the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette found that hundreds of mines from Western Pennsylvania to the far corners of West Virginia, Virginia and Kentucky were filled with dangerous levels of the toxic dust — in some cases twice the safety limit.
Year after year, inspectors turned up samples in underground workplaces that exposed thousands of miners to unsafe levels of the dust, but no enforcement mechanism was in place to crack down on the operators, the Post-Gazette found.
In hundreds of other cases in which the federal Mine Safety and Health Administration — which operates under the Labor Department — could have taken action, the Post-Gazette found that inspectors failed to impose any penalties even after repeated violations.
In addition, records show MSHA had missed hundreds of safety inspections, including testing for dust levels.
Between fiscal years 2018 and 2021, the agency had not conducted at least 1,509 mandatory inspections even though the agency claimed it had completed all of them.
Although MSHA was aware of the dangers of silica, it had delayed imposing a stricter threshold for decades, despite warnings from the government’s own medical researchers.
The new safety rule was finalized in 2024 under the Biden administration, cutting in half the amount of silica that miners could be exposed to and providing enforcement tools, like fines and even temporary mine closures.
The rule was supposed to go into effect in April, but instead MSHA paused protection, blaming mass layoffs at the National Institutes for Occupational Safety and Health under the leadership of Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
The mining industry also sued to block the rule at the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals, which temporarily halted the rule after the administration did not oppose the industry’s request.
For now, the industry asked that the new standard be held until at least Oct. 17, while settlement talks continue with the government.
The rally on Tuesday for greater protections comes just months after the current administration launched a campaign to promote coal production, including hundreds of millions of dollars to modernize coal plants and grow demand for a fuel that’s been in decline for years.
Longtime president of the United Mine Workers of America, Cecil Roberts, told the crowd that President Donald Trump needed to support not just the industry but also the workers behind it.
“If he does care about miners, he’s got to step in here and do something about this,” Mr. Roberts said.
Mr. Roberts said he has been fighting for better protections against silica in the halls of Congress since 2003, part of a decadeslong push by advocates who say the Labor Department has done too little to protect miners.
“Right this minute, there is some 35-year-old dying right now trying to get his breath,” he said. “This is the worst form of death one can imagine. We put people in prison for life for murdering people with a pillow holding it over their face until they are dead.”
Even as the problem has grown worse for the workers, the safety standards allow miners to be exposed to higher levels of the dust than in any other industry, said Dr. Leonard Go, a Chicago-based pulmonologist at Northwestern Medicine, who spoke at the rally.
“If you work in construction, they protect your lungs more than they do if you're a miner. It doesn't make sense that they pay more attention to silica in these other industries than they do in mining because it's the same toxic dust,” Dr. Go said.
Mr. Hairston, the president of the National Black Lung Association, said he could rely on Social Security benefits when he left the mines at age 48. As younger miners continue to be diagnosed with black lung — some even in their early 30s — there isn’t a safety net for them.
“They can't fall back on disabled Social Security, and they can't get black lung [benefits] from the state, so they come to the federal government.”
Without better protections, he said, “our young men [are] going to die.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.