The chaos has long faded.
But a year after two Western Pennsylvania prosecutors were thrown into the international spotlight — and caught in the middle of a blame game over who was at fault for the near-assassination of then-presidential-candidate Donald Trump — a residual bitterness remains.
“I love this job, and I’d like to keep it for a little while,” said Beaver County District Attorney Nathan Bible, who was just a few months into his term when a gunman opened fire on Trump in front of thousands at a rally in neighboring Butler County last year. “But you know, if I did this job for 12 years, I will probably look back on that as still being the craziest thing to happen.”
Mr. Bible and his Butler County counterpart, Richard Goldinger, are both homegrown in their respective rural counties, and neither is quite accustomed to the type of attention thrust upon them in the aftermath of July 13, 2024.
The shooting at the Butler Farm Show grounds marked the worst breakdown in U.S. Secret Service protection in decades. Trump and two spectators were injured by gunfire, and a man in the crowd — 50-year-old Corey Comparatore — was killed.
Neither district attorney was at the rally that afternoon.
Read More
But both had a stake in things going well: Each oversees specialized police units that were assisting Secret Service agents at the massive outdoor rally. When the chaos of the moment subsided, both found themselves on the receiving end of vicious finger-pointing.
And, ultimately, both felt compelled to step in and defend their respective men and women from the national ire.
For Mr. Goldinger, this was his county — he grew up in Butler, and he’s served as district attorney since 2008. Someone needed to become the local face of what had just happened, he said.
Mr. Bible’s route was a bit more circuitous. It was only in the days and weeks that followed that the extent of his SWAT team’s involvement came to light: A Beaver officer was the first to clock a suspicious man lurking around the American Glass Research building just outside the rally’s secure perimeter and that others had tried for hours to keep tabs on his movements.
Mr. Bible said he and his chief detective talked early on about how to handle the situation.
“We don’t want to throw anybody else under the bus,” he said, recalling the conversations. “But if anyone comes after any of our guys, we have to defend them.”
Within 24 hours of the shooting, a Secret Service spokesperson was placing blame with local law enforcement, telling CNN the day after the assassination attempt that local officers had been in charge of securing the building where the gunman — later identified as Thomas Matthew Crooks of Bethel Park — opened fire. Then-Director Kimberly Cheatle doubled down days later, telling ABC News that responsibility for that building fell solely on local police.
“That’s where it turned for me,” Mr. Goldinger said in a tinge of anger still palpable nearly a year later. “Because I knew what their involvement was. I know what they were supposed to do. And I had heard what they told me the planning process was.”
Indeed, his officers had already detailed for him the scattershot planning process and fragmented communication that they said left them with little direction heading into one of the biggest events ever in the mostly rural county. If nothing else, it was certainly the most politically charged.
“So it really made me mad that that was happening — that they were getting blamed,” Mr. Goldinger said.
Mr. Bible was a bit less measured as he recalled how it felt to watch as the feds tried to push blame onto the local officers: “It was kind of a little bit of a kick [in the groin], to be frank about it.”
Ronald Rowe Jr., who was appointed acting head of the Secret Service after Ms. Cheatle’s July 23 resignation, initially doubled down in blaming local law enforcement. Speaking to U.S. senators two weeks after the shooting, he blamed locals for the breakdown in communication the day of the rally, and accused them of holding onto information that should have been passed along to the feds in charge.
His remarks came even after text messages among SWAT officers showed they’d spotted the gunman nearly two hours before he opened fire. Sgt. Gregory Nichol, a member of the Beaver team and a Monaca police officer, was the first to spot Crooks. Later, another officer in the group text thread would tell him to “call it in to command.” He did, he told ABC News later, “and they acknowledged.”
The finger-pointing didn’t sit well with Mr. Goldinger.
“It was frustrating to hear [the Secret Service blame local police] knowing these guys volunteered their time out there all day in that heat, and then to have the Secret Service basically say, ‘Well, that was their job’? They didn’t even include [the building] in their perimeter,” he said, still incredulous.
Mr. Rowe would backtrack just a few days later, acknowledging that his agency was responsible for the catastrophic breakdown.
“In no way should any state or local agency supporting us in Butler on July 13 be held responsible for a Secret Service failure,” Mr. Rowe said Aug. 2, just three days after he’d emphatically pronounced that local officers should have seen and stopped the gunman before he was able to take aim from the roof.
“This was a Secret Service failure,” he continued in a briefing that day with reporters. “That roofline should have been covered — we should have had better eyes on [that].”
But by then, local law enforcement in both counties had gone on the offensive, detailing missteps such as the fact that Beaver SWAT officers never met with Secret Service agents pre-rally, or that the rooftop in question had been pegged as a potential point of concern.
In Butler County, the SWAT officers created a transcript of their radio transmissions that day.
“They were really proactive in saying, ‘Hey, wait a minute, this is what we did, this is what we were supposed to do, here’s some proof,’” Mr. Goldinger said.
For Mr. Bible, that mean throwing open the books to prove his team had done its job.
“At that point, we opened up and were willing to talk to anybody and say, ‘Here’s what happened,’” he said.
That included Good Morning America barely two weeks after the shooting, marking the first time those with direct involvement in security on July 13 had spoken freely about what did and didn’t happen. Mr. Bible called it “a bit of a relief” to be able to detail that day.
It was a tactic, though, that didn’t sit well with Mr. Goldinger.
“I’m like, ‘Why are they on TV right now? Why are they doing this?’” he said. “They’re not even the lead — you were there to assist, and now you’re on national TV?”
Both men say they’re still friends, but Mr. Goldinger said the divergent ways in which the teams defended themselves drove a wedge where there used to be cooperation.
“Our ESU team used to work with them — that’s why Beaver was there [July 13],” he said. “There’s a rift there because of all that.”
He’s not sure who initiated that rift: What would the Beaver team have against the Butler guys? Or, he mused out loud, maybe it’s his team in Butler that doesn’t want to work with the officers in Beaver?
The whole thing rubbed him the wrong way, Mr. Goldinger said, but “what’s done is done.”
It was a tough spot to be in, Mr. Bible added.
“We were walking a fine line of wanting to give [SWAT officers] the recognition that they should have but without pointing the finger at someone else not doing what they should have,” he said.
“So it was almost a relief when the fingers started getting pointed at us. It was like, ‘OK, great, now we can sort of unleash the truth.’”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.